Skip to main content

Digital Trends may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. Why trust us?

Here’s why Clayface should be the main villain in The Batman Part II

While acclaimed horror filmmaker Mike Flanagan (Doctor SleepThe Haunting of Hill House) brushed aside Deadline‘s report of him helming a solo Clayface movie on Twitter, that same piece also slipped in that the villain might play a significant role in Matt Reeves’ The Batman Part II. That news comes across as exciting and curious, as Reeves typically has a passion for presenting fantastical elements through a more realistic lens.

And since the most famous renditions of the classic supervillain are essentially colossal mud monsters, that might be tough to pull off with the current iteration of the Dark Knight. Reeves and Robert Pattinson’s take on Batman and his budding cinematic universe are steeped in gritty crime-noir, but Clayface’s inherently tragic origins and presence he brings shouldn’t disqualify him either. Basil Karlo’s acting background and Phantom of the Opera influences could easily make him a foreboding presence in The Batman Part II without feeling out of place.

Modernizing the “Golden Age”

Split image of the Golden Age and modern versions of Clayface, respectively.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Many fans likely assumed after the rumors and reports began circulating that Reeves would likely use the “Golden Age” version of Clayface, should he use such a villain at all. This iteration of the Batman antagonist was a vengeful, spiteful actor-turned-serial-killer who became furious that they were remaking the horror film he originally starred in, leading him to adopt the moniker of the villain he played to hunt down the cast.

It makes sense for something like The Batman universe, as it’s still hard to imagine Pattinson’s Dark Detective fighting a 20-foot-tall clay monster, but that might also feel derivative of what last year’s movie tackled. But even in the modern era of DC Comics, the comic book source material has made Basil Karlo the most well-known version of Clayface, even blending his acting origins with the monstrous depiction of later versions that are more popular.

And as grounded as The Batman is, Part II arguably doesn’t need to strip all of the fantastical elements from the villain to make him work. As TV shows like Batman: The Animated Series and even comics as recent as the Clayface-centric one-shot Batman One Bad Day: Clayface has shown, there’s plenty of exciting room for a humanized sense of tragedy and macabre body horror to work in Reeves’ character-driven stories.

Finding common ground between realism and fantasy

Xermanico's art of Clayface facing off against Batman in One Bad Day.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

While taking away all of the clay-like shapeshifting elements of the villain would make him feel like just another serial killer and going full-blown “movie monster” would feel jarring to Reeves’ grounded approach, a combination of influences from the source material and other horror movies could help Clayface find a healthy common ground.

As depicted in the episode Feat of Clay from Batman: The Animated Series, connecting the Basil Karlo iteration of the villain, his self-obsession with performing, and the chemical substance that transforms him into the grotesque Clayface could be connected to the organized crime element of The Batman Part II. Colin Farrell’s Oswald Cobblepot is set to make waves in Gotham City’s underworld in HBO Max’s The Penguin, and he could be the one keeping Karlo on a string through drug addiction, blackmail, or both.

And even though The Batman Part II is unlikely to venture into outright horror, movies like The Phantom of the OperaThe Thing, and perhaps even The Invisible Man provide templates to build tension around Clayface’s role in the story. The motive would certainly need to be different from Paul Dano’s Riddler, but this villain could give off an enticing “who can you trust?” angle to a new detective thriller.

Split image of Basil Karlo as Clayface in One Bad Day.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The threat wouldn’t revolve around the identity of the culprit, rather, it would be about how the culprit could be anywhere and almost anyone. In terms of the physical horror aspect, the latter two horror films could also provide some inspiration, but the recent One Bad Day: Clayface one-shot by Collin Kelley, Jackson Lanzing, and Xermanico shows how unsettling Clayface can be even when human-sized.

Xermanico’s art style and character design for Karlo’s more grotesque forms and shapeshifting abilities are a solid blueprint, but so is Kelley and Lanzing’s dialogue for the villain. Reeves is no stranger to delving into the realm of emotion and the psyche, and some increasingly unhinged internal monologuing while impersonating various identities would absolutely fit the director’s noir style.

Paving the way for more fantastical villains

Split image of Mr. Freeze in Batman Annual, Robert Pattinson in The Batman, and Clayface in One Bad Day.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

In the first movie, the street-level scope and grimy crime-noir atmosphere perfectly emphasized Batman’s detective traits, but should these reports pan out and Clayface becomes a prominent part of The Batman Part II, the door might be creaking open for more bizarre villains. Even if Reeves’ take is relatively grounded, the director has managed just fine in showcasing alien invasions and talking apes that feel “real.”

Between the creative liberties that could take Basil Karlo’s acting origins and the body horror of later incarnations and make something believable, there’s even room for some clever meta-commentary on the ruthlessness of show business to give the villain a unique drive.

James Gunn and Peter Safran’s Batman in The Brave and the Bold will surely aim to differentiate itself in the mainline DCU with more fantastical elements. But considering Caesar in the Planet of the Apes movies somehow made an inherently campy concept both serious and intimate, it shouldn’t be outside of the realm of possibility that Mr. Freeze can get his theatrical redemption in Reeve’s Bat-verse.

The Batman played it fairly safe when it comes to the fantasy of the superhero genre, but Clayface in The Batman Part II can begin to dip this universe’s toes further into the bizarre without giving fans a case of tonal whiplash. More importantly, unlike Joker, Catwoman, Penguin, and the Riddler, audiences still haven’t seen a live-action, big-screen version of Clayface. With The Batman Part II, the time is right for the villain to make his debut and give Batman a formidable nemesis to battle.

DC Studios and Matt Reeves’ The Batman Part II releases in theaters on October 3rd, 2025, and The Batman is available to stream now on HBO Max.

Editors' Recommendations

Guillermo Kurten
Freelance Writer, Entertainment
A University of Houston graduate in Print Media Journalism, Guillermo has covered sports entertainment and practically all…
The best Batman movies and shows on HBO Max
Batman standing with Gotham and the Red Hood looming overhead.

Though Batman is a character that dominates a massive share of the pop culture space, that doesn't stop DC Comics from giving the brooding Dark Knight his own day of celebration every year. The superhero has spawned a treasure trove of engaging media across every medium he's featured in, with movies and TV being the biggest highlights outside of the comic book source material.

And even though Warner Bros. seems to be at its most volatile state in recent memory following the scorched-earth-esque merger with Discovery, fans can typically find most of the character's best stories in one place. If fans want to celebrate the occasion, then delving into the various live-action and animated Batman movies and TV shows on HBO Max seems like a fitting way to do so.
The Batman (2022)

Read more
Batman and the city: depictions of Gotham from The Dark Knight to Gotham Knights
Batman overlooking the neon lights of Gotham in Arkham Knight.

With the enticing expansion of Matt Reeves and Robert Pattinson's The Batman universe, it's once again an exciting time for the character in the theatrical space, and the recent release of WB Games Montréal's Gotham Knights has once again highlighted how the city itself is such an important backdrop. As cheesy as it might be to say, Gotham City truly helps elevate the Dark Knight's tales when treated as a metaphorical character of his world.

The gloomy, crime-noir city that seems perpetually dark and stormy is the foundation that serves Batman's wider mythos, whether it's in Christopher Nolan's standard-setting The Dark Knight trilogy or Paul Dini and Bruce Timm's hallowed Batman: The Animated Series. And even though Gotham is often characterized by such moody adjectives, there have still been several attractive iterations of it across mediums to serve their aforementioned and respective functions.
From the page to the big screen

Read more
Batman’s live-action future should be on HBO, not on the big screen
Robert Pattinson as the Dark Knight in red promo art for The Batman.

Matt Reeves' recent Dark Knight venture is the third major live-action rendition of the character in the last 10 years, and while it seems like a lot to already be thinking about what comes after The Batman movies, Warner Bros. Discovery and DC could do well to look to TV for the next take's future.

That might be asking a lot, especially considering the company's chaotic merger laying waste to a slew of streaming projects and DC's reputation for its use of Batman -- and lack thereof -- in the live-action TV space. However, while The Batman is an exciting fresh start for a detective-focused, neo-noir Gotham City, a shakeup in the medium of choice could give the next long-term reboot a new and tantalizing creative angle through the HBO brand.
A change of pace from the theatrical format

Read more