Skip to main content

This 2020 Nicolas Cage sci-fi horror is massively underrated

Lavinia standing in front of a colorful tornado in "Color Out of Space."
RLJE Films / RLJE Films

Five years ago, RLJE Films released director Richard Stanley and actor Nicolas Cage’s underrated sci-fi horror film, Color Out of Space, a modern adaptation of H.P. Lovecraft’s short story. The movie follows the Gardners, a family of alpaca farmers, as they are visited by a brightly colored meteorite that mutates their land and everything in it.

Before Color Out of Space, Richard was known for directing Hardware and Dust Devil and for being notoriously fired from the infamous 1996 movie The Island of Dr. Moreau, starring Marlon Brando and Val Kilmer. However, Color Out of Space marked Stanley’s glowing return to filmmaking to work on his passion project. Though the film received considerable acclaim upon release, Color Out of Space has been all but overlooked by general audiences since its release in 2020.

Recommended Videos

Five years later, this movie still displays the potential to become a cult classic, not just because of Cage. The way it adapts Lovecraft’s story and brings its alien horror to life with jaw-dropping visuals and heart-wrenching performances makes for an unforgettable cinematic experience. Here are the easy reasons why Color Out of Space deserves at least one viewing and far more recognition from audiences:

Its faithfulness to the source material

Nicolas Cage looking at a colorful forest in "Color Out of Space."
RLJE Films / RLJE Films

Though Color Out of Space is set in the modern era, Stanley stays true to the source material while drawing inspiration from his own life. Specifically, the director draws from his mother’s experience with cancer and translates it into the character of Theresa Gardner and her mastectomy. This creative change adds an extra layer to the story, turning the Color into a symbol of cancer as it infects the land around it, slowly killing it as it turns it into something new and terrifying.

Like Lovecraft’s story, the film unfolds with several horrific tragedies and zero hope for the Gardner family. The universe shows no mercy on them as the Color claims their lives and minds, fitting with the source material’s tone. The film also adds more of Lovecraft’s work into the story with the presence of the Necronomicon and Ward’s vision of an alien planet writhing with tentacled creatures. By mixing occult magic with alien sci-fi, the film creates a genre-bending nightmare that makes Lovecraft’s stories so revolutionary. This execution proved that Stanley could’ve directed his planned adaptation of Lovecraft’s The Dunwich Horror very well.

The horror

COLOR OUT OF SPACE Official Trailer (2020) Nicolas Cage Movie

As a faithful Lovecraft adaptation, Stanley’s film depicts one family’s descent into Hell at the hands of an otherworldly force they can neither understand nor defeat. The film’s alien terror echoes John Carpenter’s The Thing, as everything the Color touches turns into horrific monstrosities. Though some of these creations don’t look that realistic at times, the CGI’s quality can be forgiven due to the film’s low budget. Nevertheless, the film’s creature designs are downright terrifying, specifically the mutant fusion of the Gardners’ alpacas and the spider-like fusion of Theresa and Jack.

The latter creature is especially horrifying, as it takes a mother and son’s loving bond and twists it into an agonizing Freudian nightmare. With Theresa absorbing poor Jack into her body as she turns into an animalistic monster, this slow and unsettling transformation is painful to watch and will get under viewers’ skin. All in all, Color Out of Space is one of those films that will stick with its audience long after the credits roll, with the movie’s dark and psychedelic ending burning into viewers’ brains for years to come.

The performances

Nicolas Cage in "Color Out of Space."
RLJE Films / RLJE Films

The film’s horror can’t exist in a vacuum, and the cast elevates it as they fill the void with their engrossing performances. Playing the unfortunate witnesses to the Color’s wrath, the cast effectively captures the pain, confusion, and sorrow their characters face as they lose themselves and each other to an all-consuming entity. It’s an incredibly dark story, and audiences can’t help but ache from watching the characters endure their tragic fates.

At the forefront of Color Out of Space is Cage, who gives another mesmerizing performance as his character becomes possessed by the Color. The actor goes “full Cage” in his role, descending into a rage-filled trance like Jack Torrance in The Shining as he tries to protect his family, succeed with his farm, and maintain order. He may go a little too over-the-top at times, but his performance still adds to the wild and chaotic spirit of Stanley’s film, making it one of the most distinctive and must-see adaptations of Lovecraft’s work.

Stream Color Out of Space on Shudder.

Topics
Anthony Orlando
Anthony Orlando is a writer/director from Oradell, NJ. He spent four years at Lafayette College, graduating CUM LAUDE with a…
7 obscure sci-fi movies from the 1980s you need to watch
Herbert West in "Re-Animator."

Though the 1980s were a terrific time for science-fiction films, there were a few members of the genre that didn't get the recognition they deserve and faded into relative obscurity. Many of them did generate a decent cult following over the years, yet they remain underrated pieces of cinema that demand to be seen by a much wider audience.

So for audiences looking for a new sci-fi movie to get on board with, check out these seven films from the '80s that stand out as some of the genre's unsung wonders.
The Last Starfighter (1984)

Read more
Danny Boyle’s Sunshine is the best sci-fi movie you’ve never heard of
A man standing in front of the sun in Sunshine

The sci-fi genre is thriving. From acclaimed Oscar-winning films like Denis Villeneuve's Dune to ambitious and original entries like Jordan Peele's latest movie, Nope, the genre is experiencing what fantasy went through in the noughties: a wave of enthusiastic support from the industry and audiences alike. Television is also in the sci-fi game, with hits like Stranger Things and Severance scoring with critics and becoming fan favorites among viewers.

Yes, the genre is more popular than ever, and we might very well be heading toward a full-blown sci-fi renaissance in television, film, and literature. Perhaps if Danny Boyle's underrated Sunshine had come out in this sci-fi-loving environment, it might have been acknowledged for the masterpiece it is. Instead, Sunshine came out in 2007, a time of spectacle and mind-numbing escapism when audiences weren't feeling its brand of thought-provoking, almost philosophical gloom and doom. And so Sunshine slipped through the cracks, barely making an impression in cinemas. Sunshine grossed a disappointing $34 million against a production budget of $40 million. That's a flop if there ever was one. And it's not like it gained new life on DVD; on the contrary, Sunshine died, much like the sun in its daring plot, and no bomb or heroic crew rescued it from its doom.

Read more
3 underrated movies on Max you need to watch in February 2025
A woman points a gun in Dredd.

Max may not always have the vast selection that its streaming rivals enjoy, but it does have a lot of movies to enjoy. And some of these films deserve a lot more love than they received in theaters. That's why we've compiled this list of the three underrated movies on Max that you need to watch in February.
Our first pick is a fantastic comic-book-inspired action flick that barely anyone saw in America, followed by a touching dramedy and a spy thriller with a terrific cast.
Need more recommendations? We also have guides to the best movies on Netflix, the best movies on Hulu, the best movies on Amazon Prime Video, the best movies on Max, and the best movies on Disney+.
Dredd (2012)

Fans of The Raid: Redemption will recognize a lot in Dredd, the 2012 adaptation of one of the United Kingdom's most popular comic book icons. Judge Dredd (The Boys' Karl Urban) may look like a hero, but he's an authoritarian with a badge who offers little flexibility while serving as judge, jury, and executioner on the dangerous streets of Mega-City One in the future.
Dredd's temporary partner, Cassandra Anderson (Olivia Thirlby), will be by his side for the duration of her evaluation as a judge. Cassandra will get her test by fire when she and Dredd are locked in a sprawling apartment complex filled with criminals who are out to kill them.
Watch Dredd on Max.
Waitress (2007)

Read more