Dear Hollywood overlords: Please don’t turn the Oscars into the Grammys

This year, more than five million fewer people tuned in to watch the Academy Awards ceremony than a decade prior — the lowest ratings in the history of the svelte golden statue. No wonder ABC, which holds the rights to the ceremony for the next decade, reportedly sent a team of executives to meet with the leaders of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences (AKA the Academy), pushing for new ways to bring in more viewers.

To claw back viewers, the Academy announced a new “popular” film category, which will highlight films like Black Panther, Wonder Woman, and presumably any similar popcorn flicks. In other words, the sorts of top box-office performers that typically don’t garner critical consideration for Academy members. The new category, slated to debut at February’s ceremony, has many industry insiders reeling, and many film buffs asking questions.

What will be considered popular enough to compete in the category? How exactly do you define “popular?” Will the fact that the biggest popcorn flicks of the year could get coveted statues water down the very brand itself?

But my biggest concern is an even simpler one. I’m worried the Oscars could soon look a lot like another major media awards ceremony that has been all but ruined by its kowtowing to popular culture: The Grammys.

Popularity over quality

The move to include popular movies alongside other categories feels like the first step down the same slippery slope that led the Grammys to create separate categories for Country, Folk, Americana, and American Roots music, or to partition modern black music into Rap, Urban Contemporary, and R&B — with little to no obvious distinctions between categories.

Dividing similar artwork into so many disparate segments devalues overall criticism.

The Grammys have been broken – and frankly, nearly unwatchable — for decades. In an op-ed penned in early 2018, Washington Post music critic Chris Richards went so far as to say that only three “Album of the Year” picks have actually been valid in the past 38 years of the awards.

No one would argue that any award ceremony is completely objective, but at some point, dividing similar artwork into so many disparate segments devalues the overall criticism of the artwork itself.

What’s more, going out of your way to highlight popular things for popularity’s sake devalues the award, and that’s bad for ratings, too. Transitioning into a popularity contest hasn’t helped the Grammys, which has seen a steady decline in viewership in recent years, just like the Oscars. This seems like something an Academy member should have pointed out to the ABC executives so keen on ad sales and eyeballs.

dear hollywood please dont turn oscars into grammys bruno mars holding grammies getty
Don Emmert/Getty Images

Then again, those who broadcast awards ceremonies have become so infatuated with popularity, industry clout, and product sales, it often feels as though nobody in a suit is paying attention to the artwork itself.

Perhaps more importantly, no one in the ABC boardroom seems to be considering the significant shifts we’ve seen in the way media is made and consumed in 2018. Declining ratings almost certainly run in parallel with decreased cable subscribers, the rise of streaming, and the fact that Hollywood and the industry at large no longer have such a stranglehold on fame in the social media and YouTube era.

A better Academy

It’s clear that the Oscars, like the Grammys, have a problem with diversity and inclusion, both in terms of their actual voting bodies and the content they highlight. But the best way to solve these issues is to work harder to build a voting populace of diverse experts, rather than to simply focus on the bottom line. Perhaps then more viewers would actually tune into the event, as it would showcase a more accurate portrait of the industry – and the country — at large.

If the “popular” category does make it on the ballot, one thing’s for sure: The Academy of Motion Pictures should be very concerned about what gets nominated, and how it compares to the overall Best Picture choices, or they may have a Grammys-level problem. As it stands today, even a cursory comparison of music critics’ year-end lists compared to those who win golden gramophones will leave any serious music lover laughing (or crying).

Take this years’ Grammy awards as evidence: Did anyone besides those counting their cash actually think Bruno Mars’ 24K Magic was a better album than Lorde’s Melodrama, Jay-Z’s 4:44, Kendrick Lamar’s DAMN., or Childish Gambino’s Awaken My Love? Real critics sure don’t think so. After its release in late 2016, 24K Magic didn’t even make the year-end top 10 lists in Rolling Stone, Pitchfork, or Digital Trends, for that matter, among many others.

Grammy Awards

While there are always some qualms about what gets nominated for Best Picture at the Oscars, you can’t level nearly the same criticism at the most recent Best Picture nominees — films like The Shape of Water, Dunkirk, The Post, or Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri. But with the inclusion of the Best Popular Movie category, we soon may be able to.

Does a movie deserve equal consideration in the winners’ circle just for putting asses in seats? If the Academy really thinks so, it won’t be long before it has a tough time convincing winners that its once-coveted golden statues are worth anything more than a People’s Choice Award.

Emerging Tech

Materials scientists have found a way to make graphene twice as tough

Graphene may be stronger than steel, but its extreme thinness also means it can tear. Researchers have found a way to make it more than twice as tough, using carbon nanotubes for reinforcement.
Smart Home

Get the support you deserve at work in one of the best office chairs

Sitting at the office all day can be tough on more than just your back. Check out our picks for the best office chairs, whether you're in the market for something basic or a bit more luxurious.
Movies & TV

'Prime'-time TV: Here are the best shows on Amazon Prime right now

Amazon Prime brings more perks than just free two-day shipping. Subscribers get access to a huge library of TV shows to stream at no extra cost. Here are our favorite TV shows currently available on Amazon Prime.
Home Theater

From the Roku Ultra to the Fire TV Cube, these are the best streaming devices

There are more options for media streamers than ever, so it’s more difficult to pick the best option. But that’s why we're here. Our curated list of the best streaming devices will get you online in no time.
Movies & TV

A U.S. comedy that ended in 2004 is now the most-streamed show in the U.K.

It ended 14 years ago, but Netflix has given a U.S. comedy a new lease of life in Britain. In fact, it's currently the most-streamed show there, beating the likes of The Grand Tour and Stranger Things.
Movies & TV

‘The Meg’ devours the weekend box office to knock off ‘Mission: Impossible’

Giant shark movie The Meg surprised just about everyone with a massive opening weekend that gave studio Warner Bros. Pictures its biggest premiere of the year so far. It knocked Mission: Impossible -- Fallout down to second place.
Movies & TV

Star Trek 4 in trouble as Chris Pine, Chris Hemsworth take their Kirks and go home

Chris Pine and Chris Hemsworth have both reportedly left talks to star in Star Trek 4 due to contract disputes with studio Paramount Pictures, leaving the status of the fourth film uncertain.

Listen up! These are the best movie soundtracks of all time

Whether you're a lover of beautifully composed original scores or a fan of perfectly compiled background music, these are the best movie soundtracks of all time — from Star Wars to Garden State.
Home Theater

Put your home theater to the test with these spectacular Blu-ray releases

What's the point of having all of that awesome home theater gear if you can't breed a little jealousy in your friends and family? We've put together this list of fantastic Blu-rays that have the goods to drop a few jaws.
Movies & TV

Was there a 'Captain Marvel' Easter Egg In 'Avengers: Infinity War'?

Academy Award winner Brie Larson will play Captain Marvel in the upcoming Marvel Studios movie hitting theaters in March 2019. Here's everything we know about Marvel's first female-led superhero movie.
Movies & TV

'Westworld' creators hint at characters they have big plans for in season 3

HBO wrapped up the second season of Westworld with a finale that asked as many questions as it answered, leaving fans eager to know more about season 3. Here's everything we know so far about the show's next act.
Movies & TV

MoviePass re-enrolls customers, while Costco offers refunds

MoviePass is reportedly re-enrolling users who had recently canceled the service, giving them an error message when they try to jump ship again. This comes as part of the launch of a new plan from the struggling company.
Movies & TV

'Star Trek: Discovery' has found its Mr. Spock for season 2

The crew of the U.S.S. Discovery will return for more adventures on CBS All Access in the near future. Here's everything we know about Star Trek: Discovery season 2, from the cast and themes to the season premiere.
Home Theater

Dish Network or DirecTV: Which is the better choice for you?

So, you’ve chosen to go with a satellite television provider. Check out our quick rundown of what both Dish Network and DirecTV offer in terms of content, hardware, and pricing, and why you might choose them over streaming services.