Where’s the line between fan-fic and copyright infringement? Ask the Power Rangers

On Monday night, a fan-made Power Rangers video stormed the Internet, racking up millions of views in less than a day.

That’s a familiar story. But you know what else it racked up in less than a day? Threats of legal action. Haim Saban, the billionaire owner of the Power Rangers franchise, is forcing sites like Vimeo to take down the video.

That’s actually rare for fan-made videos, which have been making their way around the Internet since the days of dial-up – usually without ruffling any corporate feathers . The fans over at Star Trek Continues have produced four full-length Star Trek episodes of their own. Lucasfilm officially backs an annual competition just for Star Wars fan videos. Every video game character you can think of has been given the narrative video treatment by fans.

So why did the fans behind Power/Rangers piss off Haim Saban so much?

Probably because the video was too good.

‘Til now, rights holders have mostly allowed fan videos to prosper for three reasons:

  1. They aren’t made for profit.
  2. They tend to have a “home-made” quality that won’t get them confused for the real thing.
  3. Rights holders would look like dicks to go after them.

One look at the Twitter feed of the film’s director and you’ll see multiple posts that attest this was not a for-profit venture.

He wrote those tweets after Vimeo pulled the video at the request of Saban Brands. But get this: Vimeo had the video as a “Staff Pick” before they pulled it. So clearly Vimeo thought it was OK before Saban insisted otherwise. Joseph Kahn even goes out of his way to assert that every frame of the video is an entirely original creation:

And Kahn is absolutely right on both counts. It isn’t made for profit. It doesn’t include any copyrighted material. He does have some legal ground to stand on.

But so does Haim Saban.

There’s nothing “home-made” about that video. The fans who made it are working Hollywood professionals. The cast and crew have long lists of credits – really good credits! The reason why Power/Rangers now faces legal threats are two-fold.

First, it’s so well-made, one could make an argument that it’s actually competing with — and over-shadowing — the main brand. Second, Haim Saban clearly doesn’t mind looking like a dick.

So what happens next? The fact that the video still exists on YouTube is telling. Google must have received the same takedown requests that Vimeo got, but hasn’t acted on them. Considering how quickly YouTube usually takes things down, that means its moderators don’t see clear-cut infringement. And more importantly, neither do YouTube’s lawyers.

This is clearly one genie that can never truly go back in the bottle.

Further, if Saban were to make good on his threats of legal action, I’m not entirely sure what he’d go for. The producers haven’t monetized the video, so it’s not like Saban can try to seize that money. Saban could sue for damages, but good luck proving the impact of a YouTube video on the bottom line of any current or future Power Rangers productions. His most legitimate lawsuit would simply force the video to be taken down, but you know who he’d have to sue to do that? Google. Yeah, good luck with that.

I suppose Saban Brands could sue the producers to assume copyright of the video, claiming it owns the underlying material, and therefore owns the expression of it. But then what? To make any money off the video, the company would have to release it on its own, which it obviously doesn’t want to do. It would basically be going through a lot of trouble and expense simply to shelve it entirely, and it’s probably too late for that. This is clearly one genie that can never truly go back in the bottle.

All that said, I do sympathize with Saban on one thing: If I had dedicated fans who turned out “fan movies” way better than anything I ever produced, I’d be pretty pissed, too.

The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not reflect the beliefs of Digital Trends.

Cars

2019 Ford Ranger online configurator launched, pricing revealed

The 2019 Ford Ranger midsize pickup truck starts at $25,395, but a fully loaded version can top $40,000. The Ranger is making its return to the United States after a seven-year absence.
Music

Listen up! These are the best movie soundtracks of all time

Whether you're a lover of beautifully composed original scores or a fan of perfectly compiled background music, these are the best movie soundtracks of all time — from Star Wars to Garden State.
Movies & TV

The best shows on Netflix in August, from ‘Arrested Development’ to ‘Dark Tourist’

Looking for a new show to binge? Lucky for you, we've curated a list of the best shows on Netflix, whether you're a fan of outlandish anime, dramatic period pieces, or shows that leave you questioning what lies beyond.
Computing

Why stop at one? Nvidia’s rumored GTX 1180 might double down on cooling fans

A rumor stemming from the leaked printed circuit board for the GeForce GTX 1180 graphics card claims that Nvidia redesigned the drum fan to accommodate a dual-fan design. This rumor focuses on the Founders Edition model.
Home Theater

Put your home theater to the test with these spectacular Blu-ray releases

What's the point of having all of that awesome home theater gear if you can't breed a little jealousy in your friends and family? We've put together this list of fantastic Blu-rays that have the goods to drop a few jaws.
Movies & TV

Was there a 'Captain Marvel' Easter Egg In 'Avengers: Infinity War'?

Academy Award winner Brie Larson will play Captain Marvel in the upcoming Marvel Studios movie hitting theaters in March 2019. Here's everything we know about Marvel's first female-led superhero movie.
Movies & TV

'Westworld' creators hint at characters they have big plans for in season 3

HBO wrapped up the second season of Westworld with a finale that asked as many questions as it answered, leaving fans eager to know more about season 3. Here's everything we know so far about the show's next act.
Movies & TV

MoviePass re-enrolls customers, while Costco offers refunds

MoviePass is reportedly re-enrolling users who had recently canceled the service, giving them an error message when they try to jump ship again. This comes as part of the launch of a new plan from the struggling company.
Movies & TV

'Star Trek: Discovery' has found its Mr. Spock for season 2

The crew of the U.S.S. Discovery will return for more adventures on CBS All Access in the near future. Here's everything we know about Star Trek: Discovery season 2, from the cast and themes to the season premiere.
Home Theater

Dish Network or DirecTV: Which is the better choice for you?

So, you’ve chosen to go with a satellite television provider. Check out our quick rundown of what both Dish Network and DirecTV offer in terms of content, hardware, and pricing, and why you might choose them over streaming services.
Movies & TV

Latest 'John Wick 3' photo confirms the return of two powerful characters

The third installment of the wildly successful action series that stars Keanu Reeves as a deadly assassin forced out of retirement, John Wick 3: Parabellum, hits theaters in May 2019. Here's everything we know about the movie so far.
Movies & TV

Tarantino casts actor to play Bruce Lee in 'Once Upon a Time in Hollywood'

Quentin Tarantino's ninth feature film, Once Upon a Time in Hollywood, uses the infamous 1969 Manson murders as a backdrop to tell a story set in bohemian Los Angeles. Here's everything we know so far.
Movies & TV

David Harbour is 'taking risks' with Jim Hopper in 'Stranger Things' season 3

With a sophomore season as strong as its first, Stranger Things is now moving on to season 3. Here's everything we've learned so far about the Netflix series' upcoming third season.
Home Theater

From game consoles to high-grade spinners, these are the best Blu-ray players

Streaming may be popular, but the disc isn't dead yet! To get the very best picture and sound quality from your system, you need to be watching Blu-ray or 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray discs. Here are the best Blu-ray players you can buy right now.