Skip to main content

Why The Last of Us is better as a TV show than a video game

HBO’s series The Last of Us has proven to be one of the most popular and well-crafted TV shows in recent memory, which has helped dispel the stigma toward video game adaptations. But naturally, many people armed with their keyboards have deconstructed the series and made heavy comparisons to the acclaimed video game it is based on.

While some may prefer the game over the show, the TV series has arguably improved it in multiple aspects, including in terms of plot, characters, visuals, and overall mainstream appeal. The series has finished its first season, and with another on the way, there is already proof that The Last of Us is better off as a TV show.

The show focuses more on the narrative

A still of Bill and Fred getting married in The Last of Us HBO TV show.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Video games, by nature, are all about gameplay. People use games for escapism, focusing more on how immersive and enjoyable the experience of playing them is than on the quality of the narrative. Even some of the most acclaimed video games of all time have stories that can hardly be considered adequate, but many gamers hardly seem to care.

However, The Last of Us has a layered, engaging, and emotional story that deserves to be seen, and the gameplay can sometimes get in the way of how the audience experiences it. Fortunately, the TV show is simply about watching the characters. It thus places a greater emphasis on the story, the characters, and the setting, allowing more people to fully appreciate the artistry behind the game.

Live-action is easier to digest

A woman walks ahead of a man and a girl in The Last of Us.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

For some people, a video game’s story is more engrossing when its human characters aren’t CGI creations. While the games did a great job bringing their cast to life through advanced motion-capture technology, the fact that they still don’t look or move like real-life humans can be distracting to certain audiences, specifically older ones who didn’t grow up watching CGI.

But since the characters in The Last of Us TV show are completely live-action, there’s no risk of them stepping into the uncanny valley and disheartening audiences. As a result, the series can appeal to many more people, and based on its tens of millions of viewers, the live-action approach has worked quite well.

TV reaches a broader audience

Ellie and Riley ride a carousel together in The Last of Us Episode 7.
Liane Hentscher/HBO

While a vast amount of kids and adults play video games these days, there is still a large number of people, specifically those in older age groups, who don’t pick up a controller. According to a study on TrueList, Americans who don’t play video games make up roughly 24% of those younger than 18 and 33% of adults older than 18. These media habits have limited the exposure The Last of Us has received as a gaming exclusive, preventing it from receiving more of the recognition it deserves. However, since many more people watch TV and films, The Last of Us now has plenty more fans after becoming a series on HBO.

More creative freedom

John Hannah as epidemiologist Newman in "The Last of Us."

Since the games had players controlling Joel and Ellie most of the time, the gameplay limited the story to their perspectives. But because TV shows focus more on the story itself, writers have a greater chance to explore the world and characters of their narrative than they do when making a video game. This benefits The Last of Us a great deal, as it gives the show’s creators more room to expand upon the source material while adapting it for television.

For instance, while the game starts with the first night of the pandemic, the HBO pilot builds up to it with scenes exploring Joel and Sarah’s regular lives and the lives of the people around them, which makes the apocalypse even darker when it finally comes. The episode also opens with a gripping talk show scene in 1968 that chillingly heralds the planet’s impending doom from the newly discovered fungus.

TV allows for more diversity

Sam in "The Last of Us."
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The Last of Us games are no stranger to promoting diversity with its cast, with main protagonist Ellie famously being a lesbian. The show has also taken another step further by casting Chilean-American actor Pedro Pascal as Joel (who is Caucasian in the games). Similar to how the writers were given more freedom to create stories for The Last of Us, they were given the chance to shine more light onto underrepresented groups.

One example is the show’s outstanding third episode, which gives side characters Bill and Frank an hourlong romance together that’s well-developed and much more tender than what was seen in the games. Likewise, the writers of the series changed Sam’s character by making him an eight-year-old deaf person. As he and his older brother, Henry, are seen surviving and communicating through sign language, the show normalizes the experiences of deaf people and combats the stigma surrounding them. This all helps make the TV show more enjoyable to many more people than the games ever were.

All nine episodes of The Last of Us are available to stream on HBO Max.

Editors' Recommendations

Anthony Orlando
Anthony Orlando is a writer/director from Oradell, NJ. He spent four years at Lafayette College, graduating CUM LAUDE with a…
Hogwarts Legacy works better as a TV show than as a video game
A student waving a wand in Hogwarts Legacy.

In its long history as a franchise, Harry Potter's video games have never really been a central part. The novels were hugely popular, as were the feature film adaptations, while the games were on a separate tier for die-hards who couldn't get enough of the world. With Hogwarts Legacy, that paradigm may be about to shift.

The game is certainly the most full-throated effort to launch Harry Potter into the realm of video games, and it seems like it's largely been a success. Hogwarts Legacy has performed well critically, and it seems to be moving a decent number of units as well.

Read more
HBO’s The Last of Us reinforces an important queer theme from the games
the last of us hbo show video game queer themes long time bill and frank

Spoilers for The Last of Us Part I, The Last of Us Part II, and The Last of Us HBO show.

The Last of Us video games put queer stories front and center in the narrative, and the HBO adaptation of the same name is following their lead with its focus on a gay relationship in its third episode, Long, Long Time, which aired recently. While the relationship between Bill and Frank was certainly present in the 2013 zombie action game, it was relegated to the background as Joel and Ellie navigate the beginnings of their complicated relationship. In the show, however, we're shown the couple's 20-year relationship as they grow from hesitant strangers to lifelong partners.

Read more
5 ways video game adaptations can learn from The Last of Us
video game adaptations can learn last of us the hbo pedro and nick

The first season of The Last of Us on HBO is going down as one of the best video game adaptations of all time, even if it's not perfect. Whether you believe the lousy reputation video game adaptations have is justified or not, these first few episodes of the series serve as the premier examples of how to adapt a game properly. As such, it's worthwhile to break down what other video game adaptations can learn from The Last of Us.
Halfway through the first season, five factors have played a significant part in The Last of Us' continued success on HBO. Thankfully, they are all elements other video game adaptations could learn from, even if they are based on an IP with a significantly different tone. If the quality of this show is any indication, video game adaptations have a bright future.
Be faithful

This one seems like it should go without saying, but it's something a lot of films and TV shows based on games don't get right. Even successful ones like the Sonic the Hedgehog films seem to feel a bit ashamed of the source material when they bring video game characters into the "real world." The Last of Us series works masterfully because it plays into the strengths of the source material, adapting an already critically acclaimed story accurately and respectfully. As a result, a great story is still great.
HBO's The Last of Us isn't a direct 1:1 adaptation (more on that later), but it's still unmistakably a TV version of the video game's story and even gameplay in some segments. That faithfulness shows respect for the game and is more likely to get fans on board with the creation and any potential deviations it might make. Sadly, many video game adaptations seem like they feel embarrassed of the source material, which shows in the quality of the final product and the fan reception to it.
Improve upon the source material

Read more