Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Music
  3. Apple
  4. Legacy Archives

Apple battles news outlets over old Steve Jobs testimony in antitrust suit

Add as a preferred source on Google

Though long removed from this mortal coil, Steve Jobs may still be forced to show the world what he did not recall three years ago — in HD.  CNN, Bloomberg and the Associated Press jointly filed a motion with the Oakland federal court for the public release of Steve Jobs’ videotaped 2011 deposition in Apple’s antitrust case over market monopolization accusations on Monday, according to CNET.

Apple is currently embroiled in a decade-old lawsuit centered around claims that the tech giant knowingly attempted to monopolize the digital music download market by restricting compatibility between competitors’ music marketplaces and Apples own iTunes and iPod devices.

Recommended Videos

Thomas Burke is representing the three news outlets suing in the case, and cites “substantial public interest in the rare posthumous appearance of Steve Jobs” as reason for the unreleased video’s dissemination. The motion for the video’s release comes after Apple’s lead attorney Bill Issacson denied Burke’s emailed request for the footage Sunday night. The 44-month old video, recorded in April 2011, was officially entered into “regular testimony” by Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers at Apple’s request after the plaintiff’s approval, meaning it may be reported by those in attendance but cannot not be released anywhere else.

Judge Rogers did not seal the evidence, however, which would have officially restricted its release. The three news outlets have opposed any retroactive sealing of the footage. The transcript to Jobs’ testimony is available online and features a generally coy and elusive Jobs having trouble recalling emails he sent, and other dealings with RealNetwork in 2004, the parent company of a music service called RealRhapsody. RealRhapsody allowed songs downloaded from the music service to become compatible with iPods. In 2004, Apple released a software update that counteracted the RealRhapsody technology.

The motion for public release of Jobs’ testimony was filed by the news outlets just hours after Judge Rogers rejected the second of two plaintiffs in the class action antitrust lawsuit against Apple, Monday afternoon. Both of the released plaintiffs were alleged iPod owners claiming to have had non-iTunes music removed from their devices by Apple between 2007 and 2009.

Plaintiff Melanie Wilson was removed last Thursday after Apple provided documents showing she did not make an iPod purchase within the claim’s time period of September 2007 to March 2009. Marianna Rosen was also removed from the case after the plaintiffs’ lawyer Bonny Sweeney was unable to provide sufficient evidence that Rosen purchased an iPod between the same time period. Judge Rogers gave Sweeney until later today to find a replacement plaintiff, however, and denied Apple’s request to have the case dismissed.

Sweeney informed The San Jose Mercury News “a lot of people have reached out to us in the last several days saying that they were interested in helping out and stepping forward as a plaintiff.” With over 100 million iPods sold in that 18 month time span, that’s a whole lot of potential witnesses.

Keith Nelson Jr.
Former Staff Writer, Entertainment
Keith Nelson Jr is a music/tech journalist making big pictures by connecting dots. Born and raised in Brooklyn, NY he…
The best music streaming services of 2025
Spotify on an Android device.

Who could have ever imagined that one day we would be able to access the entire discographies of our favorite artists and albums right from our smartphones or tablets, no matter where we are in the world? This remarkable convenience is one of the many wonders of music streaming services, a revolution that has transformed the way we experience and enjoy music.

In today's digital age, numerous audio platforms have emerged, each offering unique features and catering to different tastes. Whether it's Spotify, Tidal, Apple Music, or any of the myriad other options available, these services aim to deliver your beloved tracks, intriguing podcasts, hilarious comedy specials, and countless other sound bites directly to your ears with just a few taps on your screen.

Read more
Save on Avid Pro Tools music production software and start creating magic
Pro Tools end of year sale.

Typically, when you create music, whether a full-fledged track, background music for another project, or even just playing around, you have to use a variety of tools. You might have to jump between applications to do various things, like recording, applying post-production effects, and more. Avid Pro Tools is a comprehensive end-to-end audio production suite that aims to provide you with everything you need. With the tools, you can create, edit, produce, mix, master, and deliver, and much more.

Here's the kicker: For New Year's you can save 33% off and make music for a full year at a heavily discounted price. Normally, you'd pay $99 per year for Avid Pro Tools Artist, but right now it's only $66 per year. That deal will only be available from December 31 to January 3, though, so there isn't a lot of time if you want to take advantage.

Read more
Spotify vs. Pandora: which streaming service should you choose?
spotify vs pandora on iphone

Let's settle a musical debate: which music streaming platform should you use: Spotify or Pandora?

Both services have their unique strengths and weaknesses. Spotify boasts a more extensive music catalog, robust social features for sharing and discovering music with friends, and a more polished user experience across devices.

Read more