Skip to main content

Spotify won’t like Apple’s new streaming music royalty proposal

apple proposes download equivalent streaming pay music or itunes gift card
Apple has submitted a new proposal to the United States Copyright Royalty Board regarding streaming royalty payments, one which executives at the tech giant hope will simplify the manner in which rights holders are paid for streaming music plays, according to Billboard.

Streaming services like Apple Music, Spotify, and others currently pay publishers and songwriters based on a complicated formula designed to pay out between 10 and 12 percent of streaming services’ overall revenue. That percentage is determined based on backroom negotiations with record labels and copyright holders, and is difficult for everyone involved because of a lack of standardization.

Related Videos

Apple wishes to simplify the whole process, by paying 9.1 cents per 100 streaming plays — essentially making each 100 streams equal the royalty rate of a single paid download. This would make accounting simpler industrywide, and create a transparency of payment never before seen in the digital music age.

But it would also seriously hinder industry members who like the revenue-based streaming model — players like YouTube and Spotify, who operate free ad-supported streaming. Because free services generate very little revenue, those services don’t have to pay out as much.

If Apple’s proposal were to become law, many free streaming services would be too financially hindered to remain in business. For labels and songwriters, this could actually be a good thing. Many industry members have expressed overt interest in curbing free streaming wherever possible, as it doesn’t make anyone any money.

Apple Music wouldn’t be hindered by new royalty decrees, as its service is and has always been pay-only. And musicians would likely enjoy a massive increase in transparency regarding pay-per-play, as even top pop stars weren’t privy to their label’s backroom negotiations with major services.

As of right now, the Silicon Valley company’s proposal is years from becoming reality, as the suggestion comes as the Copyright Royalty Board is in the early days of determining statutory rates for streaming music from 2018 to 2022.

Editors' Recommendations

Spotify Wrapped 2022: what it is and how to view it
Spotify Wrapped 2022.

For loads of music lovers, the beginning of December is a special time of year when Spotify drops its annual Spotify Wrapped list, a data-derived deep dive into -- for better or worse -- all the good, bad, and embarrassing music we've been cranking into our earholes for the past year. If you're a Spotify devotee, you've likely already gotten their teaser email about this year's list, which usually lands at the end of November or in the first week of December. But if you haven't, no worries, we've got all the details here.
Further reading

Spotify Wrapped 2022 is here: What's your 'listening personality'?
What is Spotify: music, pricing, and features explained
Apple Music vs. Spotify: Which music streamer is the best?
Instafest: How to make your own Spotify festival lineup

Read more
Spotify Wrapped 2022 is here: What’s your ‘listening personality’?
Spotify Wrapped 2022's new Music Personality feature.

The much-anticipated 2022 edition of Spotify Wrapped is here, with a detailed, data dive into all the most listened-to music, podcasts, artists, albums, and more for the year, as well as offering you a look at your own listening data from 2022. It's always a fun way to discover some of your own listening stats (like how many hours you logged, or the songs you played on repeat), all presented in a cool slideshow-style presentation on your phone or tablet. Apple Music has its own version of it, as does YouTube Music, but Spotify's is easily the standard. And this year, as usual, they've added a few new tricks.

Spotify Wrapped is a shareable social media goldmine for the company, and this year the music streamer has added a couple of new features, including "Your Listening Personality," which uses your listening habits throughout the year to slot you into one of 16 personality types, including The Specialist, The Adventurer, The Fanclubber, and The Replayer. The feature uses metrics to look at how you tend to listen to music -- do you listen to the same tracks or artists on repeat, are you the first to jump on new releases, or are you a wanderer of the Spotify catalog looking for something new?

Read more
What is Tidal? The hi-fi streaming music service fully explained
Two Tidal UI screens on smartphones.

Most big-name music streaming services have a lot in common. Apple Music, Spotify, Amazon Music, Pandora, and YouTube Music all have similar choices in music and quality -- it's just a matter of picking your preferred platform.

Tidal, on the other hand, breaks the mold. The business structure emphasizes the artists having more control over the platform, and it offers higher-quality audio in comparison to the big names. We have all the details on how this service works so you can decide if it's right for you.
What is Tidal?

Read more