Skip to main content

BMG sues Cox Communications for turning a blind eye to music piracy

cox communications sued music piracy bmg 8378920539 5aa3989a50 z
Image used with permission by copyright holder
If someone pirates a song while using Cox Communications, does it make a sound? If the latest allegations against the company are true, it would appear not. Last Wednesday (Nov. 26), Berlin-based music company BMG Rights Management and Round Hill Music filed a lawsuit against Cox Communications for lack of account termination for repeat copyright infringers. According to the lawsuit, over seven million separate acts of copyright infringement have been committed by over 200,000 Cox subscribers over a “significant amount of time.”

The lawsuit states BMG and Round Hill Music have monitored BitTorrent systems since 2012 in order to extract information about the infringers and relayed that information to the accompanying Internet Service Providers (ISPs). The lawsuit even mentions specific IP addresses which engaged in tens of thousands of copyright infringements. It claims Cox was notified 54,489 different times for each individual copyright infringement act by IP address over a 64-day span.

Cox Communications was the only major Internet Service Provider that did not sign up for the Six Strike Program (Copyright Alert System) last year, which detailed how ISPs will provide a six-step process towards terminating accounts known to repeatedly pirate copyrighted material. Instead, Cox has its own Cox Graduated Response which allows a subscriber to keep an account even after 12 complaints of copyright infringement, as long as the subscriber contacts Cox’s Customer Safety Department “to find a solution to the complaints.”

The lawsuit claims “Cox subscribers do not face any real threat of account termination,” even when Cox is knowledgable of infringement, and that the Cox Graduated Response “precludes Cox from from relying on the safe harbor protections of the DMCA (Digital Millennium Copyright Act).”

The DCMA was enacted in 1998 and its “safe harbor” provision protects ISP’s from monetary liability related to their users engaging in copyright infringement, as long as the ISP meets certain guidelines. One of the major guidelines is that the ISP must provide notice and takedown procedures that offer easy ways for copyright holders to disable access to copyrighted material.

Depending upon how the lawsuit pans out, it appears Cox may want to play nice with copyright holders or it could be a cold winter for the company’s next earnings report.

Keith Nelson Jr.
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Keith Nelson Jr is a music/tech journalist making big pictures by connecting dots. Born and raised in Brooklyn, NY he…
What is spatial audio? Apple’s 3D sound feature fully explained
Person listening to spatial audio using Apple AirPods Max headphones.

At WWDC 2021 (Apple's annual Worldwide Developers Conference), Apple officially added support for spatial audio with Dolby Atmos Music for Apple Music. It quickly became a popular format among consumers, too: Apple estimates that by February 2022, playback of spatial audio tracks had quadrupled from just a few months prior as people experimented with the format. But what exactly is spatial audio? How is it different from (or the same as) Dolby Atmos? And what kind of audio equipment do you need to listen to it?

There's a lot of ground to cover, and some of it is a bit technical, but we're going to break it all down in easy-to-understand terms. You'll be a spatial audio expert in minutes, and you'll know exactly how to access this growing trend in movie and music streaming.
What exactly is spatial audio?

Read more
The best podcasts of 2022
best podcasts

Whether you've already stored all your favorite podcasts in your app of choice, ready for listening, or are new to the world of podcasts, there's no denying their popularity. Podcasts are everywhere these days and have become some of the most beloved entertainment and education mediums worldwide. Whatever you're into, from tech and video game chat to world news and politics or true crime, there are plenty of specialized interest shows to choose from.

With so many podcasts available, there’s no way that you can listen to all of them. To help you out, no matter your interests, we've gathered a variety of shows to turn you on to your next great listen.

Read more
How to convert your vinyl to a digital format
Rebirth of cool: Is vinyl ready for a second wind, or just a fad?

It doesn't matter one bit if your vinyl collection consists of just a single milk crate or if it fills several Ikea Kallax shelves and is slowly taking over your home — we can all agree that there's just something about vinyl.

Maybe it's the warm, uncompressed sound spinning off a solid turntable, or the feel of holding a physical piece of art in your hands while the record spins — it's a special experience that has regained much of its glory in a world dominated by digital streaming. The problem is, records are fragile, and crates full of them don't fit in your back pocket.

Read more