Is Internet radio about to get rocked?

grace digital audios tabletop internet radio sports pandora controls audio gdi ir2550p  oct 2010

Internet radio has revolutionized the way many tech-savvy consumers listen to music. Whether it’s a personalized radio station from Pandora, playlists pulled down from Spotify, friends’ recommendations “scrobbled” through, or tapping into any of the myriad other sources for online music, Internet radio has become a way of life for many people.

However, just as Internet radio seems to have finally developed as a mainstream business, things look to be shaking up. The entire industry appears poised for another showdown in Congress over music royalty rates, and everybody is worried about Apple getting into the business — although the notoriously secretive company hasn’t said anything one way or another. Is the fledgling industry in danger, or just in for a shakeup?

The royalty problem

royalites cash (shutterstock arkady)

From 2007 to 2009, Internet radio services like Pandora waged a do-or-die battle with the U.S. federal government over the royalty rates they pay for music it streamed to users. Initially, royalty rates for Internet streaming were set low to encourage growth of the industry; when they were scheduled to go up, streaming operations cried foul, saying the due-to-be-imposed rates would drive them out of business. Pandora led the fight — and, surprisingly for an upstart Internet company, it won, inking a deal for the Internet streaming industry under which it pays either $0.02 per listener per hour of music streamed, or 25 percent of the company’s gross revenue— whichever is greater.

The model has worked out well — or, at least, worked better than going out of business. Pandora was able to pull itself back from the brink of oblivion and cement its position as the dominant player in Internet streaming with more than 150 million registered users. It currently accounts for almost three quarters of all online radio listening. Dominic Paschel, Pandora’s VP of corporate finance, indicated at an investor conference earlier this month that Pandora’s listener figures effectively make Pandora the largest radio station in most of the top 10 U.S. radio markets — and the company expected to be the top station in most of the country’s 180 top markets by the end of 2012. Last month, Pandora estimated it accounted for 6.3 percent of all radio listening in the United States.

That said, Pandora still isn’t making money. Although Pandora’s revenue totaled over $120 million for its most recent quarter, roughly half of that — $60.5 million — was paid out in the form of those $0.02 per listener per hour royalties. Pandora is having strong success growing its mobile advertising revenue. By the end of 2012, it should be pulling in about $15 million in mobile advertising alone. Advertisers find Pandora attractive since they get immediate metrics on who has been exposed to their messages (unlike traditional broadcast radio).

New legislation

washington dc

Pandora and other streaming providers would like to at least get out of the “whichever is greater” clause of the current royalty requirements on streaming music. As such, they’re backing the Internet Radio Fairness Act, newly proposed legislation introduced in the House of Representatives from Jason Chaffetz (R-UT) and Jared Polis (D-CO)— Ron Wyden (D-OR) has introduced a similar bill (PDF) in the Senate. The proposed legislation would have Internet radio royalty rates set by the same mechanism that’s currently used to set royalties for cable and satellite radio. These are set by a panel of federal judges who evaluate the commercial value of the music and material being broadcast, as well as the effect royalty rates have on the industry overall. It’s a more amorphous process, but Pandora — and lots of other players in the streaming field, including the National Association of Broadcasters (NAB) — believe it would result in substantially lower royalty rates.

How much lower? Nobody knows, but probably between 8 and 16 percent of revenue. Under the same process, cable TV music services pay about 15 percent of the revenue in royalties, while satellite radio operator SirusXM pays about 8 percent of its revenue in royalties. (Both industries, it should be noted, pay separate royalties to publishers and songwriters.)

Pandora characterizes the proposes legislation as ending “discrimination” against online streaming services.

“The Internet Radio Fairness Act will address this discrimination by extending to Internet radio the same standard used to determine virtually all copyright rate-setting processes, including satellite and cable radio, allowing us to compete on a level playing field,” wrote Pandora founder Tim Westergren on the company blog. Pandora has also posted a summary of the bill and sent out email to users urging them to support the legislation.

What’s really fair?

Spotify Pandora

On one hand, Pandora’s argument makes a pretty pretty basic appeal to fairness: Internet radio stations pay a far higher proportion of the their revenue in royalties than their competitors. That kind of pressure makes it very difficult to run a successful business. For every regular user Pandora acquires, it must pay more for additional bandwidth, storage, and processing, but also an ongoing royalty burden that stifles revenue growth. Without turning a profit, the company has been a tough sell to investors. After all, to get to a break-even point, Pandora has to add an enormous number of new ad-supported subscribers. If the royalty rate were to go down, that break-even point (or, dare we say, profitability point) gets much more achievable.

On the other hand, it’s easy to argue Pandora and similar streaming services have dug their own hole in the royalty landscape… and now they have to lie in it. Many Internet streaming services run few or no audio advertisements in their streams. That all-music-all-the-time model effectively maximizes the amount of royalties the services have to pay. Conversely, if the services devoted a portion of their free audio streams to advertising, not only would they have to pay less in royalties, they would be able to generate more money through ad sales.

“If Pandora ran several minutes of audio ads per hour (the way terrestrial radio does) versus just a few 15-second spots, the percentage of revenues paid out as royalties would be dramatically lower and would be more in line with satellite radio or cable TV,” notes BTIG analyst Richard Greenfield (registration required). “Interestingly, Spotify’s radio product runs substantially more advertising per hour than Pandora. We suspect this is a business decision focused on reducing royalty costs relative to revenues.”

Lower royalty rates mean less money going to record labels and, perhaps ultimately, to artists — meaning the people who actually perform and produce the content would see less compensation. That’s assuming they see any compensation at all. It’s not quite accurate to say royalties go directly into musicians’ pockets: Some does (particularly for indies and artists on small labels), but most monies are filtered through record companies, which tally them against an artist’s debt to the label. For all but the most commercially-successful artists, labels usually come to the conclusion artists don’t get a cent. All told, the U.S. Bureau for Labor Statistics found that all music performance royalties paid during 2011 totaled about $2 billion; that’s about one third of the U.S. recording industry’s total revenue.

Not surprisingly, the record industry is not interested in seeing royalty rates go down for Internet streaming. In fact, New York representative Jerrold Nadler (R) has introduced legislation (dubbed the Interim FIRST Act) that pretty much would do the opposite of the Internet Radio Fairness Act, boosting royalties due from cable and satellite operators to about the same levels currently being paid by Internet streaming operators.

“There’s nothing fair about pampering Pandora, with its $1.8 billion market cap, at the expense of music creators,” said Ted Kalo, executive director musicFIRST, an industry group representing musicians. “Going from a fair market, ‘willing buyer, willing seller’ rate to a government mandated subsidy will break the backs of artists, while Pandora executives pad their pockets.”

Apple: The elephant in the room

iTunes 11

Royalties aren’t the only issue being faced by the Internet streaming business. Now the world’s most valuable company, industry watchers have long expected Apple to enter the Internet streaming market. Speculation has been simmering since Apple’s acquisition of Lala back in 2009. According to market research firm NPD, Apple’s iTunes service commands nearly two-thirds of the U.S. digital music market and 29 percent of all retail music sales — spanning both digital and physical sales.

If Apple were to enter the music streaming market, industry watchers agree that it wouldn’t immediately blow competition out of the water — services like Pandora and Spotify are well-established. But by hooking a streaming service in with its existing iTunes empire and iOS ecosystem — Apple could quickly exert strong influence. Albert Fried’s Richard Tullo estimated Apple could snag 20 million online radio customers in a year. Last month, some estimates put Spotify’s total audience at about 15 million.

Apple’s non-presence in the Internet streaming market is so palpable that Pandora’s stock took a 22 percent hit the week before Apple introduced the iPhone 5 on a Wall Street Journal report (subscription required) that Apple would unveil an “Apple Radio” service alongside the new iPhone. Meanwhile, the New York Post reports the potential Apple Radio service was kiboshed over a last-minute snafu with record label Sony/ATV over (what else?) royalties.

If you can’t beat ’em, buy ’em

As things stand, the Internet radio industry finds itself in limbo. Its revenues are constrained in the United States by what it sees as onerous royalty agreements, and the market could face major disruption at any time if Apple decides to launch its own music streaming service. The launch of Maps in iOS 6 proves Apple is far from infallible (and let’s not forget the imminent closure of Ping), but the Cupertino giant also can’t be ignored.

At the same time, other major digital media companies — like Google and Amazon, but also firms like Samsung and radio broadcaster ClearChannel — don’t want to be shut out of the Internet streaming market. The quickest way to get in would be to acquire an existing player like Pandora, Spotify, or

Of the major streaming operators, Pandora is the most attractive takeover target. Although Pandora is not profitable, Pandora dominates the online streaming market, and has amped up its mobile advertising game recently. According to eMarketer, Pandora currently earns more money from ads on mobile devices than any company but Google.

Bottom line: don’t be surprised if the Internet radio landscape shifts radically in the next six to 12 months.


As deaf gamers speak up, game studios are finally listening to those who can’t

Using social media, personal blogs and Twitch, a small group of deaf and hard-of-hearing players have been working to make their voices heard and improve accessibility in the gaming industry.

Winamp eyes big comeback in 2019 with podcast, streaming support

Classic audio player Winamp is getting a major overhaul in 2019 that's designed to bring it up-to-date and make it competitive with the likes of Apple Music, Amazon Music, Spotify, Audible, and more, all in one go.
Home Theater

The best MP3 players of 2018

Want to go for a run, but your phone is weighing you down? No worries. Can't fit your whole music library on your smartphone? Don't sweat it. Check out our list of the best MP3 players, and find one that works for you.

Spotify vs. Pandora: Which music streaming service is better for you?

Which music streaming platform is best for you? We pit Spotify versus Pandora, two mighty streaming services with on-demand music and massive catalogs, comparing every facet of the two services to help you decide which is best.

Spotify is the best streaming service, but its competitors aren’t far behind

It can be hard to decide which music streaming service is for you, so we've picked out the individual strengths of the most popular services, aiming to make your decision a little easier.

Here are the best internet radio stations for your listening pleasure

Even in the streaming era, radio stations get some of the best exclusives and curate some of the finest handpicked playlists around. Here are the best internet radio stations, for your listening pleasure.
Home Theater

Genius gives Apple Music a brainy boost with new lyrics integration

Genius has announced its most in-depth partnership to date with Apple Music, bringing lyrics to the app as well as making it the default player for the Genius mobile app and website.

A wealth of rich tunes: Cash in with the best songs about money

There may not be as many songs about money as there are songs about love, but it's a close second. If you're looking for a skrilla-inspired playlist, check out our picks for the best songs about money.
Home Theater

5 gorgeous turntables that spin stacks of wax in style for less than $500

Vinyl records are awesome, but they're also finicky. To get the best out of your stacks of wax, it's best to play them on a quality turntable. Here are the best turntables to be had for under $500.

From 'E.T." to 'Lord of the Rings,' these are the best movie soundtracks ever

Whether you're a lover of beautifully composed original scores or a fan of perfectly compiled popular music, these are the best movie soundtracks of all time — from Star Wars to Garden State.

The best new music this week: Kurt Vile, Valley Maker, and more

Are you looking for the best new music? Each week, we scour the internet to find the most compelling new releases. On tap this week: Kurt Vile, Valley Maker, Broncho, The Dodos, Colter Wall, and Ambrose Akinmusire.

Amy Winehouse is coming back as a ‘hologram’ for a 2019 world tour

Amy Winehouse is set for a holographic return to the stage in 2019 in a global tour featuring her greatest hits, though how fans of the late singer feel about the "comeback" is another question entirely.

Jam out in style with the 25 best playlists on Spotify

Music is the world's most potent drug, and the best playlists on Spotify will make you catch feelings. We've scoured the service for its top collections, and brought them together in one place -- for you.

How to convert and play FLAC music files on your iPhone or iPad

The high-resolution revolution is upon us, and FLAC files are a popular way to store hi-res sound. But what if you’re an iOS user? Check out our article to find out more about FLAC files, and how to use them on Apple devices.