Skip to main content

Spotify does actually reduce piracy, claims the European Commission

Though they’re nowhere near as dangerous as the Somali crew, nor as glamorous as Captain Jack Sparrow, the music pirates of today are certainly a problematic bunch. But according to a new study conducted by the European Commission, the availability of free music made possible by services like Spotify has indeed curtailed piracy  in recent years. In fact, the Commission claims that there is “clear evidence” that Spotify “displaces music piracy.” That said, however, when it comes to helping the music industry make money, Spotify isn’t exactly helping — unfortunately, the money the service saves artists by protecting them from piracy is subsequently lost by the provision of, you know, free music.

As per the Commission’s study results, “our analysis shows that interactive streaming appears to be revenue-neutral for the recorded music industry.” Researchers Luis Aguiar and Joel Waldfogel examined weekly data for both the digital sales and torrents for 8,000 musicians between 2012 and 2013. When taken in conjunction with Spotify’s data, the two found, “For every 47 streams the number of illegal downloads decreases by one.” And considering Spotify’s impressive user numbers, these minute decreases actually add up to be quite significant.

Spotify, which has long insisted that its presence is a huge boon to the music industry at large, is no doubt thrilled with this latest piracy displacement theory. But of course, every conclusion should be taken with a grain of salt — as TorrentFreak points out, “streaming services also impact legal track sales on iTunes and other platforms,” which means that people who might otherwise feel compelled to buy Adele’s “Hello” are instead choosing to simply listen to it on repeat on Spotify.

Researchers note, “… our sales displacement estimates show that the losses from displaced sales are roughly outweighed by the gains in streaming revenue.”

So tough call, music biz — you’re caught between a rock and a hard place, and one’s name is Spotify, and the other’s is piracy.

Editors' Recommendations

Lulu Chang
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Fascinated by the effects of technology on human interaction, Lulu believes that if her parents can use your new app…
Spotify tweaks search functionality to make music discovery more convenient

As a streaming service, Spotify hangs its hat on music discovery, but until recently, its search functionality had made the process a bit more cumbersome than it needed to be. Fortunately, the company will soon release a small tweak that places search filters at the top of the page (just below the search bar), allowing users to easily switch back and forth between artist, song, playlist, and album searches.

Previously, people needed to scroll down below their search results to apply these filters, a process that was confusing to some and irksome to others.

Read more
If you sign up for Spotify’s Car Thing, you might get one for free
Spotify Car Thing

Spotify's Car Thing, a gadget that lets users access the company's streaming music offering in a driver-friendly format, is finally a product regular Spotify Premium subscribers have a chance of getting their hands on.  As part of the device's formal launch, subscribers can sign up to get one, and, remarkably, Spotify is discounting the entire $80 price, asking that eligible customers only pay the $7 shipping charge.

What exactly is Car Thing? It's a device that Spotify has been working on for a few years, using early prototypes to understand how its customers interact with Spotify's streaming audio content while in their cars. The version that the company has just released looks like a smartphone with a large rotating knob attached to the front of the display.

Read more
Spotify vs. Pandora

You’ve probably heard that there are two types of people out there: people who listen to their music on Spotify and people who use Pandora. While Pandora has been around for decades and many people credit the streaming service for revolutionizing the music industry, there’s also a reason Spotify has become so popular in the past few years.

If you're a music lover, both services are certainly worth using. Still, if you're considering upgrading to paid tiers like Spotify Unlimited or Pandora Premium, you will want to know what you're getting for your hard-earned cash. We pit Spotify and Pandora against each other to help you decide which is right for you, and after comparing these two music services closely, Spotify comes out on top.
For better or worse, Pandora's Music Genome Project helped revolutionize the music industry when it debuted in 2000, creating a new standard for online music streaming. Since then, numerous competitors have sprung up, with iHeartRadio,, TuneIn, and more borrowing Pandora's "radio station" model with varying degrees of success. In fact, Pandora has been so successful at radio-style programming that SiriusXM recently agreed to purchase it.

Read more