YouTube sues MP3 conversion tool as the industry prepares for a new fight over content rights

youtube mp3 conversion tool Google has had an interesting relationship with the music industry in regard to piracy. Rights holders have continually insisted that given Google’s power over search, it should block sites where you can illegally download music. Of course, the other side of that argument is that the world’s largest search engine should distance itself from censorship as much as possible as well as the fact that plenty of sites offering illegal downloads also have plenty of content that is legal to obtain.

In the midst of this never-ending argument is Youtube-MP3.org. The site is a simple tool for taking YouTube videos and converting them into MP3 files by simply copying and pasting a video’s URL. Then you can download this content to your computer, and even add it to iTunes if you so desire.

That might sound a lot like illegally downloading music – but there’s a very important loophole. According to YouTube-MP3 founder Philip Mantesanz, the application doesn’t use the YouTube API… which is one of the things it’s being accused of doing in Google’s lawsuit against the site in Germany.

In addition to YouTube-MP3’s denial of violating YouTube’s Terms of Service, Mantesanz’s lawyers “agree that there are no copyrights of a third party violated by providing this service and it has to be considered legal,” because according to German law it is legal to download digital radio broadcasts as well as YouTube videos. YouTube-MP3 has launched a petition to fight Google and remain up and running.

But YouTube-MP3 isn’t singularly in Google’s crosshairs: Other YouTube conversion websites have also been targeted by claims of TOS violation and copyright infringement. TorrentFreak reports that Music-Clips.net received a letter from YouTube accusing it of the same. And it probably won’t be the last, because this is a new form of piracy that rights holders are going to have to fight, and it’s gaining steam.

Earlier this year, in the wake of Spotify’s US launch, there was another, less hyped launch for an app called SpotifyRip. The tool provides a function called stream ripping, where it records music from your sound card without any background noise and then lets you save that file. Again, sounds illegal… but again, it’s technically not. As the site explains in hilariously honest plain speak:

Is ripping streamed music illegal? No. The general consensus is that streaming web radio sites like spotify [sic] are legal to rip from for personal use. Nobody has ever been tried in court for this matter. However you may need to check in certain parts of the world with more restrictive laws. It is impossible for sites and application like Spotify to know that you are doing this, however ripping music does go against Spotify’s terms of service. If you were to publicly announce that you were doing it in some way then they would have every right to ban you. But apart from this they could never know. Can I pass the ripped songs on to my friends? Legally, no. This is a form of file sharing. You should only rip for personal use.”

What YouTube-MP3 and its cohorts are doing would be consider audio ripping, and it’s one giant grey area. Basically, because streaming and broadcasting applications like YouTube, Pandora, Vimeo, Spotify, and the like are so new, the powers that be haven’t adapted their policies to specifically outlaw converting or recording these files.

Defenders of audio ripping could also argue this is similar to what DVR services are doing: recording live TV for later use. Canada recently passed a law called the C-11 Copyright Modernization bill upholding this very function:

“The bill C-11 text states that if content an individual acquires legally (such as YouTube), uses for private purposes, not gives the content away, makes no more than one copy, and keeps the content for a reasonable amount of time in order to listen at a more convenient time, then, ‘It is not an infringement of copyright for an individual to fix a communication signal, to reproduce a work or sound recording that is being broadcast or to fix or reproduce a performer’s performance that is being broadcast, in order to record a program for the purpose of listening to or viewing.’

This means that under C-11 a citizen is within the law to ‘Time Shift’ audio from YouTube to be listened to later on their computer. The digital rights do not end here. Next, under C-11 ‘it is not an infringement of copyright for an individual to reproduce a work or other subject-matter or any substantial part of a work or other subject-matter’ meaning they can ‘Format Shift’ the audio downloaded from YouTube to the medium of their choice, such as iPod, CD, thumb drive, et cetera, as long as the content was obtained legally, not reproduced from an infringement, not distributed to others, and used for private use. C-11 legislation does not prohibit individuals from taking audio from YouTube and transferring it to your favorite devices for later listening.”

The music distribution industry and rights holders have been pretty preoccupied with targeting BitTorrent and other P2P file-sharing sites – and they’ve done so effectively, as music piracy has significantly decreased. But that’s the nature of the digital beast: There’s always another and a newer way. And if there isn’t, the Internet will invent one. 

Music

Brian Eno sets out to change music (again) with Bloom: 10 World

We always felt that Bloom was a musical system that could be developed further -- it was as if we’d built a CD player and only ever released one CD. For this release, we’ve created ten new worlds, starting with a reimagined version of…
Computing

M4A is great for quality, but not for storage. Here's how to convert to MP3

Despite its remarkable ability to retain audio fidelity at a smaller size, M4a files aren't the best when it comes to compatibility. Check out our basic guide on how to convert M4a files to MP3.
Music

The best free music download sites that are totally legal

Finding music that is both free and legal to download can be difficult. We've handpicked a selection of the best free music download sites for you to legally download your next favorite album.
Music

Apple Music vs. Spotify: Which service is the streaming king?

Apple Music is giving Spotify a run for its money, but which service is best for you? In our Apple Music vs. Spotify showdown, we compare and contrast all we know about the two streaming music services.
Home Theater

Plex amps up its music offerings with tight integration with Tidal

Plex may not be the first platform you think of for music streaming, but that may be about to change. The popular media server has added Tidal to its growing list of features, letting Plex users integrate their collections with Tidal's.
Smart Home

Apple Music hits the Amazon Echo. Is the cold war over?

It's about time. Amazon and Apple seem to have called a truce as Amazon agrees to add Apple Music to an ever-growing line of streaming music services on its Echo smart speakers that includes competitors like Spotify.
Deals

Enthusiast alert: Get up to 67% off Polk Audio speakers at Adorama

Any time is a good time to upgrade your home theater sound system, which makes Adorama's Polk LSI Blowout Weekend Sale particularly tempting. Adorama has discounts up to 67 percent on Polk Audio's top-of-the-line LSiM Series for…
Home Theater

An acclaimed Apple analyst says the new AirPods are coming in 2019

Apple plans to release new AirPods much the same as it does new iPhones, and a wireless charging case, water resistance, and better Siri integration are among the improvements we can expect in future models.
Mobile

You may soon be able to listen to your own songs on Spotify’s Android app

If you love Spotify's streaming, but also have a large collection of niche music, then it can be hard to marry your two passions. Thankfully, Spotify appears to be testing the ability to import local songs to its Android app.
Computing

Block out the sun and drown out the haters with Bose’s new AR sunglasses

Bose has announced its quirkiest listening device yet, a pair of headphone-integrated sunglasses that allow you to meander the brightest places with your favorite tunes in tow. Called the Frames, the glasses will sport 3.5 hours of battery.
Home Theater

Spotify Wrapped reveals rad facts about your musical tastes and habits

The website may be a bit tough to find at first, but Spotify Wrapped tells you awesome facts about your year in listening. From how many minutes you spent jamming out to your top artists, and beyond, there's a lot to dig into.
Social Media

What do yodeling and Kylie Jenner have in common? YouTube’s top 2018 videos

In a true nod to the variety found on YouTube, the platform's top 10 list of videos from 2018 range from celebrities to sports, from perfectly tossing a picture frame on the wall to a kid yodeling in aisle 12 at Walmart.
Music

From Paul McCartney to Mariah Carey, this is the best holiday music

Whether you're a fan of classic jazz standards or modern R&B masterpieces, there's something for everyone on our playlist of the best holiday music. Pour some eggnog and curl up by the fire, this one is sure to get you in the holiday…
Emerging Tech

Feast your eyes on the wildest, most elaborate Rube Goldberg machines ever built

Want to see something totally mesmerizing? Check out several of the best Rube Goldberg machines from across the internet, including one that serves cake and other that do ... nothing particularly useful.