Skip to main content

Elon Musk fires back at critics, defends donating ‘noninvasive’ ventilators

Tesla CEO Elon Musk defended his company’s donations of “noninvasive” ventilators, which may not be able to treat severe cases of coronavirus, and accused his critics of being fake accounts and trolls.

As the coronavirus outbreak worsened in March, Musk offered to donate ventilators to hospitals to address shortages of needed medical equipment. The UCLA Health and the NYC Health and Hospitals networks both thanked Tesla for the donations on Twitter.

But one of the tweets raised questions about how useful the donated devices really were. The photo appeared to show ResMed-made Bilevel Positive Airway Pressure (BiPAP) machines, which are similar in design to the common noninvasive Continuous Positive Airway Pressure, or CPAP, devices.

While BiPAP and CPAP machines can help patients with conditions like sleep apnea breathe, they aren’t able to deliver oxygen straight to the lungs, which is the method many patients with critical respiratory issues need, the Financial Times reported.

Critics on Twitter piled on against Musk, who quickly defended himself after a supporter noted that New York Gov.Andrew Cuomo confirmed the BiPAP machines could be converted into the ventilators required to treat COVID-19 patients.

Invasive ventilators are for worst case patients. Survival rate at that point is low, as Gov Cuomo has pointed out. Nonetheless, we start delivery of intratracheal Medtronic units in NYC tonight.

— Elon Musk (@elonmusk) April 2, 2020

Musk also tweeted that it was “weird that so many troll/bot accounts were activated to attack on this fake issue.”

ResMed CEO Michael Farrell, in a recent interview with CNBC, praised Musk’s efforts in purchasing the company’s BiPAP machines from a platform five years ago, and then sending the devices from Asia to New York.

An NPR report from late March found CPAP devices may increase COVID-19 infections by aerosolizing the coronavirus. The face masks used with the machines allow air to escape — possibly explaining the disease’s spread through a Washington state nursing home.

The more advanced BiPAP devices are still safe to be used, so long as patients are treated using breathing tubes, not face masks.

For the latest updates on the novel coronavirus outbreak, visit the World Health Organization’s COVID-19 page.

Editors' Recommendations

Aaron Mamiit
Aaron received a NES and a copy of Super Mario Bros. for Christmas when he was 4 years old, and he has been fascinated with…
Elon Musk’s Starship update included movie of Mars mission
Elon Musk giving a Starship update in February 2022.

“Let’s make this real,” Elon Musk said to a crowd of enthusiastic supporters on Thursday night after watching a dramatic animation depicting a future Starship mission to a city on Mars.

The SpaceX boss was giving the first public update in two years on the progress of the company’s next-generation space transportation system that’s already part of NASA’s plans for a crewed lunar landing, and yes, could one day carry humans to Mars, too.

Read more
How to watch Elon Musk’s Starship update today
watch spacex land next gen starship rocket for first time sn10 high altitude flight test  edit

Starship Update

SpaceX boss Elon Musk is about to offer an update on the company’s progress with its next-generation Starship rocket.

Read more
Elon Musk’s Starlink helping to restore Tonga’s internet
Elon Musk

SpaceX chief Elon Musk has sent a team of Starlink engineers to the South Pacific to help get Tonga back online after a recent volcanic eruption severed the only cable connecting the island nation to the internet.

With repairs to the undersea cable still ongoing, and a population desperate to contact loved ones overseas, several politicians in the region have been making public calls asking Musk if he would be able to use his Starlink internet satellites to restore Tonga’s internet connection following the January 15 disaster.

Read more