A former teacher appraises Bill Gates’ plan to put a camera in every classroom

camera in every classroom

Bill Gates wants a video camera in every classroom in America. After partnering with Measures of Effective Teaching, observing 3,000 willing teachers, and spending millions of dollars researching educational effectiveness, the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation thinks it has the formula for what makes a good teacher.

Mr. Gates believes that the single most important determining factor in the educational success of a child is the efficacy of their teacher. It’s a point in which the majority of people can agree, even teachers themselves. He posits that the only way to truly obtain teacher improvement is through meaningful professional development based on impartial, regular observation. One of his main talking points is that athletes use video all the time in an effort to improve their craft, so why shouldn’t teachers be afforded the same opportunity?

As a former teacher myself, I’d like to first discuss the observation process as it stands now.

The observation process as it stands is a farce.

Depending on a variety of factors, including contractual language and the power of the local teachers’ union, an American teacher is officially observed during a lesson anywhere from once to five times in a school year. In the vast majority of cases – especially with the observations that will help administrators evaluate teachers – these observations are scheduled with the teacher weeks in advance.

Unscheduled visits are very rare and usually cannot be used in the evaluation of the teacher, for better or worse. Even then, the teacher usually receives some generalized warning that they might be visited that day, especially if the visit includes the administration’s superiors from the district. They want to look good, too.

Scheduled observations obviously give the teacher an opportunity to organize what amounts to a dog and pony show. The administrator will be lucky enough to catch that teacher’s most engaging and insightful lesson of the year. If a teacher does not organize the dog and pony show on observation day, they are a fool.

That’s not to mention that the students will be inherently on their best behavior that day, simply because the principal or assistant principal is sitting ten feet away from them.

bill gatesIn short, the observation process as it stands is a farce and is in no way reflective of what goes on in a teacher’s classroom on a daily basis. Mr. Gates should be commended for trying to fix it; except that he also tries to assuage the teachers by saying they will be allowed to choose which lessons are filmed. So much for realistic insight.

Unannounced observations are the only way to achieve a meaningful view of a classroom. However, they have an understandable negative stigma among the teaching community

In the best-case scenario, teachers are worried that unannounced observations, via video or otherwise, will be used to micromanage the profession. Worst-case: they will be used to weed out teachers that were just having a bad day. It’s not like politicians have established a lot of good will and trust with the teaching profession recently.

There are simply too many classrooms, and too many other responsibilities, for administrators to be able to carry out unannounced observations themselves, which is where the video idea really shines. Ancillary benefits would include the ability to post truly effective lessons online for other teachers and students’ benefit. That’s not to say that every classroom becomes a MOOC, just that there will be far more videos available on what a good Pythagorean Theorem lesson looks like.

Teachers tend to operate in a bubble for the vast majority of the school year. They may take a few good ideas from conferences they attend and colleagues they talk to, but if a teacher remains teaching the same subject for their entire 30-year career, their repertoire will not change much from year 1 to year 30. Further, they rarely have the opportunity to observe other teachers, as their only available time to do so would be during a planning period. Then they fall behind on their own work.

Truly good teachers want to be evaluated fairly for a variety of reasons, the most important one being that they want to improve their craft and learn from other high-performing educators, which is exactly what MET’s program promises. Good teachers probably would not object to unscheduled video observations, so long as they occur multiple times during the year to get an accurate cross-section and that they only make up a percentage of the evaluation process, not the whole.

The teachers who mail it in day-to-day (except on observation day) will be quickly found. They should be offered the opportunity for remediation before any punitive steps are taken. Perhaps the idea of cameras themselves will remediate the vast majority of these teachers.

The benefits or detriments for students are enough to be discussed in their own column, but let’s just say that parent-teacher conferences would have the chance to be a lot more insightful.

I don’t pretend to know what makes a good teacher. I do know that I was one, as measured both by test scores and the esteem of my students. What made me successful was often observed (my dogs and ponies were very well-trained) but might not be able to be taught.

Save for his concession to allow teachers the “out” of selecting their lesson to be filmed, Gates is on to something with this approach. Our students’ success in school is the greatest determining factor in our nation’s continuing greatness. The benefits are too great to ignore.

The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not reflect the beliefs of Digital Trends.

Home Theater

Why I still won’t wear wireless headphones

Wireless headphones promise liberation from cords, tangles, and snags, but there’s just one issue holding them back: battery life. And until manufacturers figure it out, sales numbers prove consumers aren’t yet biting.

Best family-friendly games both parents and kids love

There are a wealth of great games out there that both parents and kids can enjoy together. We compiled a list of 30 games across all genres that are sure to make family game night a great time.
Movies & TV

The best movies on Netflix in September 2018, from 'Spotlight’ to ‘Black Panther’

Save yourself from hours wasted scrolling through Netflix's massive library by checking out our picks for the streamer's best movies available right now, whether you're into explosive action, subdued humor, or anything in between.
Movies & TV

September brings 'The Dragon Prince,' an animated war series, to Netflix

Looking for a new show to binge? Lucky for you, we've curated a list of the best shows on Netflix, whether you're a fan of outlandish anime, dramatic period pieces, or shows that leave you questioning what lies beyond.

From true crime to comedy, here's our list of the best podcasts around

When you aren’t in the music mood, podcasts can be your ear candy. Whether you love to stay up-to-date on the latest news or want to know what’s happening in sports, you’ll find something on our must-listen-to podcast roundup.
Home Theater

We all cut cable, and now we’re just as screwed on streaming

As live TV streaming services like Sling TV and PlayStation Vue raise prices in tandem, it raises questions about whether these services were ever a viable alternative to cable in the first place.
Home Theater

AT&T wants to make HBO more like Netflix, and it could be a disaster

After acquiring HBO parent company Time Warner, AT&T is pushing HBO to become more like Netflix, but for all of Netflix’s success, this plan might not be great for either HBO or its customers.
Virtual Reality

HTC says ‘it takes time to launch a new technology,’ claims lead in VR revenue

HTC posted a response to a Digital Trends editorial charting VR headset sales on Amazon. The company said "it takes time to launch a new technology," and posted data showing it makes the most revenue among its peers.

What’s the point of the Note’s S Pen? Samsung needs to find one or kill it

The Galaxy Note 9’s announcement will bring with it another S Pen stylus, a feature only the artistic will get excited about. Samsung should be embarrassed about its lack of use, and we’re hoping the Note 9’s stylus includes new…

No, blue light from your cell phone won’t make you blind

A new study from the University of Toledo reveals the process by which blue light impacts the photoreceptors in our eyes and leads to macular degeneration, an incurable eye disease that causes blindness later in life. The fact that blue…

Nvidia’s new GPUs look amazing, but that doesn’t mean you should buy one

Nvidia's GeForce 2080 is a powerful graphics card that supports ray tracing to deliver real-time cinematic renderings of shadows, light, and reflection in games, but unless you were already planning on upgrading, you'll probably want to…

New Wear OS smartwatches have arrived! Here’s why you shouldn’t buy them

The likes of Skagen and Diesel have unveiled new Wear OS smartwatches at IFA 2018. You shouldn't buy them, because they're utilizing an old processor. Qualcomm is expected to announce a new wearable processor next month.
Home Theater

8K is the next big thing in TVs. Get over it

8K is the next big thing in TV. At least, that’s how LG, Samsung, Sony, and Sharp would have it. At IFA 2018, Samsung announced it would begin shipping its gorgeous Q900R series series 8K TVs this year. LG arrived with a glorious 88-inch…
Movies & TV

Bored with Netflix? As it goes global, the selection is about to explode

Netflix is going global. And even if you never leave step foot outside America, you should be excited. More subscribers abroad means more original, diverse content, and plenty to watch when House of Cards gets stale.