What Facebook should learn from this ‘colonialism’ debacle

facebook andreessen indian colonialism marc tweet
Marc Andreessen could not have chosen a more loaded term than “colonialism” to describe Facebook’s ill-conceived attempt to enter the Indian Internet market. It rankles not only because of Facebook’s particular offer — Free Basics — but because it resonates with a global problem with the Internet.

Facebook must’ve thought it had a win-win proposal: A developing nation would get free Internet access and Facebook would be a core app for the millions of Indians it brought online. (Om Malik has a great piece on the politics of free.) It’s the same strategy that Apple followed by making its computers extraordinarily low-cost for schools: An entire generation of students grew up with computers in their classrooms, and those computers just happen to be made by Apple.

But Apple didn’t limit those computers to applications and information that it had chosen. Facebook’s free Internet access doesn’t include the open Web we associate with the Net; instead, it’s “a range of free basic services like news, maternal health, travel, local jobs, sports, communication, and local government information.” Facebook has evolved the Free Basics program so that any site can apply for inclusion, but Facebook still is the one that decides which apps to include, without any transparency or accountability.

This is a serious problem, and it certainly violates Net neutrality, as the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India correctly decided when it ruled to block the service. (If only the American regulators would stop the major access providers from lifting data caps on the sources that they prefer, which is also a clear violation of the Neutrality rule.)

The West too often has assumed that its own culture is dominant.

We could call Facebook’s action paternalistic — the wise father deciding what’s in our best interests to know and explore. In this case Facebook had a justification for some type of paternalism because the essence of the deal was that it would provide low bandwidth access; the company wanted to ensure that no high-bandwidth sites were accessed. But it could have done so without becoming a gatekeeper of those sites and their low-bandwidth versions. For example, there are wireless ISPs, or Wisps, in the United States providing access in rural areas that block some high-bandwidth apps that can dramatically lower the bandwidth for other customers sharing the signal. The last time I rode Amtrak, it blocked YouTube for the same reason.

But cherry-picking a handful of sites as the “basics” of the Internet goes beyond bandwidth management, and beyond paternalism or even censorship. It’s not just a Net Neutrality violation. It rings of colonialism, especially in the Indian context.

Colonialism was marked not just by the exploitation of foreign lands, but by the insistence that it was for their own good. Those nations needed to be “civilized,” they were repeatedly told. There were elements of colonial culture that were beneficial to the colonized, of course, including the introduction of modern medical techniques … when they were made available, that is. But to have one’s labor sold for crusts while being told that your oppressors were in fact morally superior adds insult to injury. Go to Jaipur, for example, and tell me that Indian culture — or more accurately, cultures — was inferior to Britain’s.

Unfortunately, colonialism is not just an issue for commercial programs like Facebook’s Free Basics but a lens through which the Internet as a whole can be viewed. The Internet originated in America, and it initially spread most rapidly to Western countries. The West had an early lead in shaping expectations and exploring possibilities. Even as countries like India and China and Brazil have developed their own sites, apps, and Internet culture — in fact, all countries where a significant portion of the population has embraced the Internet — the West too often has assumed that these countries want and need Western Internet sites and Western leadership.

The great promise of the Internet is that it is a global space connecting localities. But it turns out that it’s harder to appreciate other local cultures than Western minds may think. We grew up thinking of American culture as the most advanced and desired, and there’s no doubt that we have been highly valued contributors to world culture, from jazz to fast food. But just as too many Americans expect the rest of the world to speak English, we too often have assumed that our culture is the one the world really wants. This is a colonial mindset. Andreessen put his finger on it, to his distress. (And he has apologized.)

This is perhaps a good learning moment. Ideally we can learn from India’s contributions to Internet citizenship, as well as from all other cultures of the world. At the very least we should be aware that people always value their own culture. That’s what it means to be a culture. We’re all local citizens, after all — even on our global World Wide Web.

The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not reflect the beliefs of Digital Trends.


Nvidia’s new GPUs look amazing, but that doesn’t mean you should buy one

Nvidia's GeForce 2080 is a powerful graphics card that supports ray tracing to deliver real-time cinematic renderings of shadows, light, and reflection in games, but unless you were already planning on upgrading, you'll probably want to…

If you're light on memory, these are the best lite apps for Android and iOS

Looking to save data, storage, and reduce performance issues? Lite apps and Progressive Web Apps (PWAs) are the best options. Here's our roundup of lite apps and PWAs for all the most popular apps on the market.
Movies & TV

The best shows on Netflix, from 'The Haunting of Hill House’ to ‘The Good Place’

Looking for a new show to binge? Lucky for you, we've curated a list of the best shows on Netflix, whether you're a fan of outlandish anime, dramatic period pieces, or shows that leave you questioning what lies beyond.
Home Theater

Throw away those EarPods -- we dug up the best headphones in every style

Trolling the internet for hours to find headphones is no way to live. Instead, leverage our expertise and experience to find the best headphones for you. Here are our 10 favorites.

Don't take your ISP's word for it: Here's how to test your internet speed

If you're worried that you aren't getting the most from your internet package, speed tests are a great way to find out what your real connection is capable of. Here are the best internet speed tests available today.

No, blue light from your cell phone won’t make you blind

A new study from the University of Toledo reveals the process by which blue light impacts the photoreceptors in our eyes and leads to macular degeneration, an incurable eye disease that causes blindness later in life. The fact that blue…
Movies & TV

Bored with Netflix? As it goes global, the selection is about to explode

Netflix is going global. And even if you never leave step foot outside America, you should be excited. More subscribers abroad means more original, diverse content, and plenty to watch when House of Cards gets stale.

New Wear OS smartwatches have arrived! Here’s why you shouldn’t buy them

The likes of Skagen and Diesel have unveiled new Wear OS smartwatches at IFA 2018. You shouldn't buy them, because they're utilizing an old processor. Qualcomm is expected to announce a new wearable processor next month.
Home Theater

8K is the next big thing in TVs. Get over it

8K is the next big thing in TV. At least, that’s how LG, Samsung, Sony, and Sharp would have it. At IFA 2018, Samsung announced it would begin shipping its gorgeous Q900R series series 8K TVs this year. LG arrived with a glorious 88-inch…

Opinion: Apple needs to modernize its antiquated annual app update routine

While Google updates its core Android apps frequently through the Play Store, Apple saves up core app updates for its annual iOS unveiling. Perhaps it’s time that Apple took a new approach.

Canon and Nikon’s new mirrorless cameras impress. Should Sony start worrying?

Canon’s EOS R and Nikon’s Z mirrorless systems are coming out of the gate strong, incorporating features that took Sony years to implement and refine. But Sony still has a lead, and may have it for some time.

XS Max? XR? Apple’s new iPhone names are a confusing mess

Apple's new iPhone range has the most baffling set of names we've seen in a while, and it's not good news. The phones may be great, but the confusing names shift away from the one brand name everyone knows.

OPINION: Apple’s new iPhones show off its best tech, and also its greed

We’re just as enamored by the new iPhones as the next person, but with fast charging an extra cost and the removal of the headphone dongle it feels like Apple is gouging us on accessories.
Smart Home

The Google Home Hub doesn’t have a camera. Here’s why that’s a good thing

Bucking the smart display trend, Google's new $149 Home Hub smart display surprisingly doesn't have a camera. We think a camera-less Google smart speaker with a screen is a good thing, and here's why.