Skip to main content

Pot, meet kettle: The user that filed the lawsuit against Instagram is still using her account

Why I’m NOT quitting Instagram
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Remember December’s controversy over Instagram’s changes to its Terms of Service? The media and user reaction to the updated policy – which including the assumption that Instagram could sell user images – was so severe that the company has been backtracking little by little ever since. To Instagram’s credit, the company remained steadfast about its policy over the ownership of uploaded photos. Still, in December a user stepped in and conveniently filed a class action lawsuit against Instagram’s policy changes. Now, Instagram wants the charges dropped and has circumstantial evidence to defend itself.

Spearheading the anti-Instagram campaign is plaintiff Lucy Funes. Now here’s why Instagram has a case to defend itself against the class action suit: Instagram gave users until January 16 to do whatever they felt was needed to prepare for the impending terms update. The actual terms of service took effect January 19. Funes was quick to jump on the class action, and filed the lawsuit just four days after Instagram’s first announcement on December 17, which was clearly one month lucy funesbefore the new terms of service set in. Ironically, during the given 30 day period, Funes herself didn’t opt to delete or deactivate her Instagram account as was probably expected from someone who was devoting her time to suing Instagram. In fact, Reuters reports, Funes continued to remain active on her Instagram account after January 19. In fact, we found her Instagram account (which is curiously public), and she’s been consistently taking and posting photos – the most recent of them being from two days ago.

Recommended Videos

The lure of selfie appears too great for Funes to stop using the app, and her Instagram addiction really isn’t helping her case. After all, if she’s so concerned about Instagram forcibly transferring her and other users’ rights following the terms of service update, you wouldn’t expect her to be using Instagram at all in the first place. On that note, Instagram defended against the claims that the user’s original images lost its copyright once it was shared on its platform. The company cited a clause in its older terms of service, before this mess was spurred by hysteria, that Instagram’s users were the owners of all of their own content.

Despite Funes’ questionable priority, fears over the use of shared Instagram photos do have some merit. Facebook has once been sued for using its users’ profile images to sponsor brands without permission, although that case was settled with a $20 million payout by the social network. And since Instagram is a Facebook owned company, the photo-sharing platform clearly has monetization in mind.

There’s a possibility that user-uploaded Instagram photos could be used in a similar manner to promote brands. Instagram won’t necessarily sell a photo, especially after that backlash, but it could associate your work (or face) with a product that you might not necessarily be comfortable promoting – although we’re beginning to see this type of outreach, and it’s primarily done with users’ knowledge (i.e., brands advertising to you to use a specific Instagram hashtag so they can feature your content). Another possible strategy would  be to intersperse branded content into your news feed. 

While it appears there are some  holes in Funes’ case, we’ll have to wait to see if the courts heed Instagram’s request to throw out the lawsuit. The fact remains that the photo-sharing platform riled users and privacy advocates, and it has a lot of saving face to do in order to win everyone back over. 

Francis Bea
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Francis got his first taste of the tech industry in a failed attempt at a startup during his time as a student at the…
An ace photographer is about to leave the ISS. Here are his best shots
The moon and Earth as seen from the ISS.

NASA astronaut Matthew Dominick is preparing to return to Earth after spending seven months living and working aboard the International Space Station (ISS).

After arriving at the orbital outpost, Dominick -- who is on his first mission to space -- quickly earned a reputation for being an ace photographer. He's been using the facility’s plethora of high-end cameras and lenses to capture amazing shots from his unique vantage point some 250 miles above Earth. Sharing his content on social media, the American astronaut has always been happy to reveal how he captured the imagery and offer extra insight for folks interested to know more.

Read more
Filter-free and fun, the Fujifilm Instax Mini 11 Instant Camera is on sale Right Now for Prime Day
fujifilm instax mini 11 camera prime big deal days

It's 2024, and you’re considering a point-and-shoot camera. Zero judgment here. I miss the good ol’ days of flipping through actual photo albums instead of doom-scrolling on Instagram. You can get back to those days by snagging a (in the ice white color), and it’s the perfect time because it’s on sale. Get it for 24% off during Amazon’s Prime Big Deal Days, but hurry while inventory is going strong.
There’s something magical about having a physical photo right in your hand seconds after snapping the shot, and it adds a fun, retro vibe to moments you want to capture and keep. Plus, having an actual picture to hold and display can be so much more satisfying than just another digital file on your phone. I picked one up two years ago for my eight-year-old daughter, and it’s been an instant hit in our household. And now, at its $59 sale price, I'm definitely going to be stocking up on a few to gift ahead of the holiday season.

How the Fujifilm Instax Mini 11 works
The delightful throwback comes with a FUJINON 60mm lens and an automatic exposure feature that adjusts the shutter speed for the best shot, even in low light. While the picture quality won’t be as crisp as what your smartphone can capture, it’ll still produce a quality image worthy of slapping on a refrigerator.
If selfies are your thing, this camera has a dedicated Selfie Mode (with a mirror). We set up a DIY photo booth for my daughter's birthday party with sticker frames so each kid could go home with a photo souvenir, and it was a total hit.
You can opt to make it a set with a range of accessories to buy separately, like a carrying case, a handy strap, those sticker borders I mentioned, and photo albums to hold the memories.

Read more
The Canon EOS R100 mirrorless is ideal for beginners — $170 off today
Canon EOS R100 mirrorless camera with lens attached

If you don't want to spend the money on a high-end DSLR camera, mirrorless cameras are an excellent alternative. But they, too, can be expensive, at least normally. Right now, thanks to a bevy of Prime Big Deal Days discounts, the best camera deals, in general, and super great Prime Day camera deals there are a ton of offers available. So, it's a great time to shop if you've been on the fence. However, we wanted to call out a great deal for novice photographers on the Canon EOS R100 mirrorless camera. Normally $600, it's just $429 right now as part of the event, saving you over $170. The bundle includes the RF-S18-45mm lens. Again, a great starting point for casual or novice photographers.

 
Why shop this Canon EOS R100 mirrorless camera deal for Prime Big Deal Days?

Read more