Skip to main content

Should you get caught snooping around with a camera, say you are doing it for art

should you get caught snooping around with a camera call on your rights as an artist arne svenson neighbors julie saul galler

What’s creepier than a Peeping Tom? If you’re in the state of New York, it’s the fact that a stranger from afar can take photographs of someone while he/she is at home, and it’s perfectly legal. OK, before you start zooming in on your neighbors with that telephoto lens, it’s actually not as simple as that. Here’s the story.

Gothamist (via The Daily News) reported that a Manhattan Supreme Court judge has ruled in favor of Arne Svenson, an artist who created a series of photographs of residents in a luxury apartment building, called “The Neighbors,” which he took from his home across the street. Two of the residents, Martha and Matthew Foster, sued Svenson when they discovered the artwork of them and their family was exhibited in a gallery, and took him to court to take possession of the photos and also bar Svenson from showing the photos in the future. The Fosters claim that Svenson’s work “shocks the conscience and is so out of keeping with the standards of morality in the community,” even though the photos don’t reveal any faces.

But Judge Eileen Rakower said the Fosters’ argument was not convincing enough because Svenson was making art. “Art is considered free speech and is therefore protected by the First Amendment. While it makes the [Fosters] cringe to think that their private lives and images of their small children can find their way into the public forum of an art exhibition, there is no redress under the current laws of the state of New York.”

So, there you have it. If you decide to be “that guy” and take “rear window” photos of your neighbors without their consent, just make sure you call it art. But, unless you’re a legit artist, good luck proving that to the cops.

(Image via Arne Svenson/Julie Saul Gallery)

Richard Grech
As a father of young triplets, Richard Grech has his hands full. But, as a photography enthusiast and one of Digital Trends'…
DJI’s 2022 drone contest offers record prize pool
A photo taken from a drone.

Leading drone maker DJI has teamed up with the SkyPixel online community for its eighth annual photo and video contest.

Whether you’re an experienced drone pilot or an absolute beginner still finding your way, the contest is the perfect opportunity to send your machine skyward in a test of your creative skills.

Read more
How $80 of photo processing software magically saved me thousands
photo editing topaz labs denoise ai phil camera

It's a good time to be a photographer, whether you're just starting out and really don't have any idea what you're doing, or if you're a seasoned pro looking to try something new.

The gear is better than ever, making even entry-level bodies better than what the previous generation started out with. Software options make cataloging and processing your photos faster and less destructive, so you can revisit things for years and give old pics new life.

Read more
Sony A7 III mirorless camera is $300 off for Black Friday
Sony Alpha a7 III Mirrorless front view.

There are a lot of great Best Buy Black Friday deals going on right now, and whether you're looking for TVs, laptops, or even headphones, there's a little something for everybody. Of course, many folks may not realize that Best Buy has some fantastic deals on high-end photography gear, such as this Sony Alpha a7 III mirrorless camera. While it usually goes for a whopping $2,200, Best Buy had brought it down to $1,900, and while that relatively doesn't seem like much, you could always spend the $300 savings on a new lens.

Why you should buy the Sony Alpha a7 III
The Sony Alpha a7 III is a camera with so much tech that it might as well be three different cameras. It has excellent dynamic range, low-light performance, and high-speed performance, and the full-frame sensors make the images look absolutely stunning. Interestingly, the a7 III manages to do an excellent job at both low and high ISOs, the latter of which can go as high as 51,200 non-boosted, which, granted, adds a lot of noise, but noise reduction helps with that. As for the video, well, sadly, it's not as impressive, at least in terms of advancements in image quality, and while it can do 8-bit 4K at 30 frames per second, it's no longer ahead of the pack in that regard, like the Panasonic Lumix GH5 is with its 400Mbps 10-bit codec and 60-fps 4K.

Read more