Skip to main content

Anything you say publicly on Twitter can be used against you in a court of law

OWS Brooklyn Bridge
Image used with permission by copyright holder

A New York City judge ruled on Monday that Twitter must abide by a subpoena to turn over deleted tweets posted by Occupy Wall Street protester Malcolm Harris, reports The New York Times. The decision could have far-reaching consequences for how online speech is treated under U.S. law.

According to Manhattan Criminal Court Judge Sciarrino, publicly-posted tweets do not enjoy the same protection as private speech.

“The Constitution gives you the right to post, but as numerous people have learned, there are still consequences for your public posts,” wrote Sciarrino in his ruling. “What you give to the public belongs to the public. What you keep to yourself belongs only to you.”

Harris, who was arrested in October for walking on the roadway of the Brooklyn Bridge along with about 700 other protesters, deleted some of his tweets posted prior to the protest. Prosecutors in the case believe that some of those tweets may contain evidence that contradicts a potential argument of Harris’s defense: That the police, not the protesters, led the march down the roadway of the bridge rather than down the pedestrian walkway.

In May, Twitter went to bat for Harris, filing a motion to quash the subpoena for his tweets, arguing that obtaining such information should require a search warrant, which the prosecution did not have. Twitter further argued that its users “retain rights to any Content [they] submit, post, or display on or through” the micro-blogging network. Judge Sciarrino’s decision rules that Twitter users do not in fact “own” their tweets — the “public” does.

So, what does this mean for the average Internet user? Well, if you are never arrested or involved in a legal proceeding during which the courts want access to information you’ve posted online, then this decision will have no consequence for your life. If, however, your tweets, blog posts, or public Facebook updates become a matter of interest to the courts, Judge Sciarrino’s decision means that law enforcement can gain access to those posts — even if you’ve deleted them — without a search warrant. So, as always, be careful what you say online — it can and will be used against you in a court of law.

Editors' Recommendations

Andrew Couts
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Features Editor for Digital Trends, Andrew Couts covers a wide swath of consumer technology topics, with particular focus on…
How to make a GIF from a YouTube video
woman sitting and using laptop

Sometimes, whether you're chatting with friends or posting on social media, words just aren't enough -- you need a GIF to fully convey your feelings. If there's a moment from a YouTube video that you want to snip into a GIF, the good news is that you don't need complex software to so it. There are now a bunch of ways to make a GIF from a YouTube video right in your browser.

If you want to use desktop software like Photoshop to make a GIF, then you'll need to download the YouTube video first before you can start making a GIF. However, if you don't want to go through that bother then there are several ways you can make a GIF right in your browser, without the need to download anything. That's ideal if you're working with a low-specced laptop or on a phone, as all the processing to make the GIF is done in the cloud rather than on your machine. With these options you can make quick and fun GIFs from YouTube videos in just a few minutes.
Use GIFs.com for great customization
Step 1: Find the YouTube video that you want to turn into a GIF (perhaps a NASA archive?) and copy its URL.

Read more
I paid Meta to ‘verify’ me — here’s what actually happened
An Instagram profile on an iPhone.

In the fall of 2023 I decided to do a little experiment in the height of the “blue check” hysteria. Twitter had shifted from verifying accounts based (more or less) on merit or importance and instead would let users pay for a blue checkmark. That obviously went (and still goes) badly. Meanwhile, Meta opened its own verification service earlier in the year, called Meta Verified.

Mostly aimed at “creators,” Meta Verified costs $15 a month and helps you “establish your account authenticity and help[s] your community know it’s the real us with a verified badge." It also gives you “proactive account protection” to help fight impersonation by (in part) requiring you to use two-factor authentication. You’ll also get direct account support “from a real person,” and exclusive features like stickers and stars.

Read more
Here’s how to delete your YouTube account on any device
How to delete your YouTube account

Wanting to get out of the YouTube business? If you want to delete your YouTube account, all you need to do is go to your YouTube Studio page, go to the Advanced Settings, and follow the section that will guide you to permanently delete your account. If you need help with these steps, or want to do so on a platform that isn't your computer, you can follow the steps below.

Note that the following steps will delete your YouTube channel, not your associated Google account.

Read more