Skip to main content

British authorities to set up guidelines for social media hate speech

Following numerous legal cases (or attempts to bring legal cases, in some situations) resulting from social media postings, the British Director of Public Prosecutions has announced the imminent release of official guidelines on when criminal charges should be brought against private individuals posting abusive comments on Facebook, Twitter and other social networks.

The announcement came from Keir Starmer, QC, as he announced that Welsh Premier League footballer Daniel Thomas would not be facing criminal charges for posting a homophobic message about British Olympic diver Tom Daley on Twitter.  Reporting that Thomas’ Tweet was both “not so grossly offensive that criminal charges need to be brought” and also “in essence, a one-off offensive Twitter message, intended for family and friends, which made its way into the public domain,” Starmer acknowledged that what was worthy of criminal prosecution and what wasn’t, in this arena, needed to be clarified moving forward.

Posted to Twitter following Daley and partner Pete Waterfield’s narrow missing out on a medal placement in this summer’s Olympic Games in London, Thomas’ message “was not intended to reach Mr Daley or Mr Waterfield [nor] part of a campaign, it was not intended to incite others and Mr Thomas removed it reasonably swiftly and has expressed remorse,” Starmer explained, and therefore needed no further action. However, he added, “The time has come for an informed debate about the boundaries of free speech in an age of social media… The recent increase in the use of social media has been profound. It is estimated that on Twitter alone there are 340 million messages sent daily. And the context in which this interactive social media dialogue takes place is quite different to the context in which other communications take place.”

Describing the problem of deciding what was and was not worthy of further action to be “very difficult” and “in… largely uncharted territory,” the DDP will, Starmer said, be issuing interim guidelines to help prosecutors decide whether or not criminal action is required in cases involving social media messages and bullying in the future. Simultaneously, the organization will be consulting with various experts – amongst them, “campaigners, media lawyers, academics, social media experts and law enforcement bodies,” Starmer explained – to create a more complete final set of guidelines “as fully informed as possible.”

However, even if Tweets, Facebook comments or other social media messages fall outside of the realm of criminal prosecution in future, Starmer said, that doesn’t mean that they’re okay to say: “”The fact that offensive remarks may not warrant a full criminal prosecution does not necessarily mean that no action should be taken,” he pointed out. “In my view, the time has come for an informed debate about the boundaries of free speech in an age of social media.”

Editors' Recommendations

Graeme McMillan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
A transplant from the west coast of Scotland to the west coast of America, Graeme is a freelance writer with a taste for pop…
Facebook’s automated hate speech detection is getting even better
fbi wants social media data facebook app mem2

Facebook’s proactive hate speech detection technology has gotten much better, according to a new report. 

The social network published the sixth edition of its Community Standards Enforcement Report on Tuesday, August 11. The big takeaway is that the company is getting better at detecting hate speech instances. The report looked at data from the second quarter of this year. 

Read more
Zuckerberg defends Facebook’s misinformation and hate policies in earnings call
mark zuckerberg shocked

Facebook founder and CEO Mark Zuckerberg defended his company's policies when it comes to moderating hate speech and misinformation in an earnings call Thursday, saying, "We do not profit from misinformation or hate.

"We do not want this content on our platforms," he continued. "As I told Congress yesterday, I am proud of the services we build."

Read more
Twitter will now censor links that promote hateful speech
twitter wants you to help it shape the future design of app

Twitter is updating its policies on unsafe links to patch one of its most abused loopholes. Starting Thursday, July 30, the social network will censor tweets that link to hate speech and violence.

In a tweet, Twitter added that accounts that frequently tweet links featuring hateful conduct may also be potentially suspended. The social network tends to take action on unsafe links in one of the two ways: It will either completely ban a particular link so that it can’t be tweeted at all or display a warning to anyone who clicks the link.

Read more