Skip to main content

Facebook is a ‘monster’ that obstructs terror investigations, says Israel’s Interior Minister

facebook trending fake news blunders mobile
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Facebook’s approach to extremist content is once again in the spotlight following a damning interview by Israel’s Public Minister for Security Gilad Erdan.

Speaking on his country’s domestic TV station Channel 2, Erdan claimed that the social network was “sabotaging” the work of the Israeli police force. He also accused Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg of not doing enough to prevent incitement against Israel on his platform, reports Reuters.

“Facebook today, which brought an amazing, positive revolution to the world, sadly, we see this since the rise of ISIS and the wave of terror, it has simply become a monster,” said Erdan.

“Facebook today sabotages, it should be known, sabotages the work of the Israeli police, because when the Israeli police approach them, and it is regarding a resident of Judea and Samaria, Facebook does not cooperate,” he added. “It also sets a very high bar for removing inciteful content and posts.”

Erdan also urged viewers to lobby Facebook (and Zuckerberg) for change, calling on “the citizens of Israel to flood him in every possible place with the demand to monitor the platform he established and from which he earns billions.”

Israel has issued similar statements in the past, targeting not only Facebook, but also YouTube and Twitter as outlets used to encourage attacks on its citizens.

Following a spate of fatal street attacks on Israelis by perpetrators identified as Palestinians, who are often teenagers, the country has stepped up its scrutiny of social media. Israel claims it is drafting legislation that will permit it to issue takedown notices to social media platforms regarding content deemed as inciting hate or terrorism.

A total of 34 Israelis and two visiting U.S. citizens have been killed since October. Israeli forces have shot dead 201 Palestinians, 137 of whom were believed to be assailants. Palestinian officials claim the killings were the result of a growing desperation among its youth over the collapse of peace talks in 2014, and Israeli settlement expansion into occupied territory, which many countries view as illegal.

Facebook has indirectly denied Erdan’s allegations by declaring that it works closely with Israel, and other countries, to remove content that incites terrorism from its platform.

“We work regularly with safety organizations and policymakers around the world, including Israel, to ensure that people know how to make safe use of Facebook. There is no room for content that promotes violence, direct threats, [or] terrorist or hate speeches on our platform,” the statement said.

“We have a set of community standards designed to help people understand what’s allowed on Facebook, and we call on people to use our report if they find content they believe violates these rules, so that we can examine each case and take quick action.”

It was recently revealed that Facebook, and Google, are moving away from their current content monitoring systems — which rely on users to report policy violations in order for action to be taken — toward an automated takedown process.

Editors' Recommendations

Saqib Shah
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Saqib Shah is a Twitter addict and film fan with an obsessive interest in pop culture trends. In his spare time he can be…
Period-tracking apps are sharing people’s intimate data with Facebook
Facebook Logo

Some period-tracking apps are sending Facebook personal information about the women who use them.
In order to work, the apps require women to enter information about their menstrual cycle as well as information about their sexual activity. According to a report released Monday by the United Kingdom-based advocacy group Privacy International, a number of those apps then share that information with Facebook, Buzzfeed reports.
Specifically, the group said the apps MIA Fem and Maya sent information about women’s use of contraception, when their monthly periods were, and whether or not they experienced symptoms like cramps and swelling to the social network. 
For some perspective, the app Maya currently has over 5 million downloads. The makers of MIA say that it has more than 2 million users around the world. We've reached out to the developers of both apps for comment and additional details on how they use user data, but have yet to receive a response. Maya's owner, Plackal Tech, told Buzzfeed that it doesn't share any personally identifiable data or medical data with Facebook. 
Data is being shared with Facebook through the social network’s Software Developer Kit (SDK). The SDK allows developers to collect user data so Facebook can show users targeted ads. Beyond being used for advertising, the data can also be collected by Facebook and used outside of the social network.
Facebook has reportedly reached out to the developers of both apps to discuss how they are potentially violating the company’s terms of service. Facebook requires app developers to disclosed to users what information -- if any -- is being shared with Facebook. In the case of the two apps, it seems like that is not happening. The fault in this particular situation appears to be with the app developers, not the social network.
Privacy, in general, has been a growing concern as it pertains to Facebook, specifically following the Cambridge Analytica scandal. The Federal Trade Commission fined Facebook $5 billion over its use of private data in the wake of the scandal.
During court proceedings for a class-action lawsuit focused on Cambridge Analytica, the company’s lawyer, Orin Snyder, said that there is “no expectation of privacy” on Facebook.
“There is no invasion of privacy at all, because there is no privacy,” Snyder said while trying to convince U.S. District Court Judge Vince Chhabria toss out the lawsuit. Snyder argued that users had given consent to share their data with third parties. “You have to closely guard something to have a reasonable expectation of privacy,” he said.
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg has made a number of statements over the past year stressing the company’s desire to make a privacy-focused social platform.

Read more
Deepfake or fake news? Zuckerberg says Facebook might treat them differently
mark zuckerberg deepfakes aspen ideas festival gettyimages 1146087210 cropped

(Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images) Justin Sullivan / Getty Images

Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg says that his company is considering treating deepfakes differently from traditional fake news and misinformation, which could make it easier for Facebook to delete the altered videos before they spread.

Read more
Bluesky barrels toward 1 million new sign-ups in a day
Bluesky social media app logo.

Social media app Bluesky has picked nearly a million new users just a day after exiting its invitation-only beta and opening to everyone.

In a post on its main rival -- X (formerly Twitter) -- Bluesky shared a chart showing a sudden boost in usage on the app, which can now be downloaded for free for iPhone and Android devices.

Read more