Skip to main content

Facebook employees wrangled with execs to remove Trump’s posts as hate speech

ask trump backfires donald
Albert H. Teich /
Employees at Facebook have reportedly been engaged in an intense debate over the past year to remove certain posts by presidential candidate Donald Trump, which they claim break the site’s rules on hate speech.

The posts in question, identified by unnamed sources close to the matter, included Trump’s statements about placing a ban on Muslims from entering the U.S., reports The Wall Street Journal.

The argument was taken directly to management, with Facebook founder and CEO Mark Zuckerberg ruling in December 2015 that any censorship of Trump’s posts would be inappropriate. The decision reportedly caused much outrage, prompting employees to voice their disagreements with their boss on the company’s internal messaging service and in person with Zuckerberg and other Facebook executives. The same sources claim that certain staff members within the company’s content review team threatened to quit over the matter.

A Facebook spokesperson said in a statement that the platform’s reviews process takes into consideration the context of a post, which can include “the value of political discourse,” before judging whether it should be removed.

“Many people are voicing opinions about this particular content and it has become an important part of the conversation around who the next U.S. president will be,” added the spokesperson.

Social media has become the primary news source for the majority of American adults, according to a Pew Research Study published earlier in 2016. As the biggest social network in the world, Facebook inevitably came out on top as the prominent service for news. However, nuance in regard to the news has been a tricky balancing act for the social network, leading to doubts over its reliability as a media provider.

Facebook recently came under fire in Norway for removing an award-winning photo uploaded by a local journalist — and later by the country’s Prime Minister — forcing it to backtrack after the international press picked up the story. Media pressure previously saw the company launch an internal investigation over accusations of bias in regard to its Trending Topics section — an issue that continues to generate controversy due to the feed’s reliance on an algorithm to surface relevant news.

On the other hand, Facebook’s decision on the Trump issue arguably works in its favor, in light of the company being labelled as having an alleged liberal bias. Alongside the reported live video assistance it has given to both Trump and Hilary Clinton’s respective campaigns, the news may finally put to bed such damaging accusations of favoritism.

Editors' Recommendations

Saqib Shah
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Saqib Shah is a Twitter addict and film fan with an obsessive interest in pop culture trends. In his spare time he can be…
Mark Zuckerberg explains why Facebook didn’t block Trump’s Minnesota post
trump versus mark zuckerberg

Facebook founder and CEO Mark Zuckerberg addressed criticism Friday about why the social network did not block or remove President Donald Trump's post about the protests in Minneapolis over the murder of George Floyd -- the same post Twitter said it hid because the tweet "glorified violence."

Unlike Twitter, Facebook did not make it a point to preface Trump's posts with a fact-check label or public interest notice.

Read more
Zuckerberg: Facebook wouldn’t have fact-checked Trump
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg speaking on a panel at the Paley Center for Media

As President Donald Trump lashes out at Twitter for fact-checking two of his tweets and prepares an executive order targeting social media companies, Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg has weighed in — on Trump's side.

In an interview with Fox News set to air Thursday, May 28, Zuckerberg said that his social media company has "a different policy than Twitter on this."
“I just believe strongly that Facebook shouldn’t be the arbiter of truth," Zuckerberg told The Five co-host Dana Perino. "I think in general private companies — especially these platform companies — shouldn’t be in the position of doing that.”
Trump and many Republicans have criticized Twitter over the fact-check messages on Trump's tweets about mail-in voting, which alerted users to "get the facts" after Trump made an unsubstantiated claim that mail-in voting would lead to rampant voter fraud. Trump accused Twitter of censoring him and other conservative voices and vowed to take action against social media companies.

Read more
Facebook gives employees $1,000 each to help them deal with coronavirus crisis
mark zuckerberg deepfakes aspen ideas festival facebook hosts annual f8 developer conference in san jose

As a way to help employees amid the COVID-19 coronavirus outbreak, Facebook announced it would give each of its 45,000 full-time workers a $1,000 bonus. 

The Information first reported that Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg made the announcement via an internal company memo on Tuesday, March 17. Zuckerberg also told workers that alongside the cash bonus, they would also each get an “exceeds” rating for their six-month 2020 review, meaning a further bonus down the road. 

Read more