Report: Google+ user numbers tell an incomplete story

google plus

At a Google event in San Francisco on Tuesday, Senior Vice President of Engineering Vic Gundotra took the stage to talk about Google+, and he painted a surprisingly rosy picture. Over 300 million active monthly users, up from 190 million in May of this year. Google+ is a growing network, and Gundotra’s cited statistics make it sound like the network is flourishing. 

Except Gundotra’s stats stem from a fishy way of measuring how many people use Google+. Many outlets have been skeptical of Google’s claims that Plus is used as widely as it says, and AllThingsD received confirmation that Google tallies its active users by measuring how many people click on the notification bell or the share icons that Google provides on all of its properties. 

As Google explained it to AllThingsD: “Yes, clicking on the notifications bell does count in our monthly actives metric for the Stream. If you click anywhere which leads to the Stream being loaded and displayed, we count you as viewing the Stream. The Stream is rendered on mobile (Android and iOS), on the Web at plus.google.com, and when you click and open a notification view of the Stream on desktop properties.”

Google hasn’t provided any further information breaking down how the 300 million active monthly users go about their Google+ activities, meaning that a substantial chunk of these users could just be occasionally clicking on the notification bell to clear their Google+ activity, not regularly sharing content or engaging in conversation. I know I only click on that red bell to make it stop being red, and I suspect there are others like me.

Since there’s no information on who is just getting rid of their notification and who is actually updating their Circles about their lives on Google+, it is difficult to tell how popular the service actually is. According to audience measure firm Nielson, Time reported earlier this month, people only spend 5.5 minutes on Google+ per month through desktop, and 12 minutes through the mobile app. Facebook users log a whopping 6.5 hours a month on desktop and 7 hours through mobile.

In other words, I’ve used Facebook, and Google+, you, sir, are no Facebook. 

Google+ has a lot of good things going for it: Hangouts are a fantastic option for video chatting, especially with groups, and I’m always impressed by its roster of photography tools. The UI is clean and easy to navigate, and upgrades announced on Tuesday make both Hangouts and photo and video editing better than before. And probably the most telling number given about Google+ at Tuesday’s event was photo-related: according to Google, over 1.5 billion photos are uploaded to Google+ every week, which seems like a crazy-high amount, but considering how excellent the service’s photo editing is, it underlines that Google made a good decision to fold its Picasa editing software into Google+ as a way to sway users. 

But for all of its positives and all of the effort Google’s expending trying to make its social network engaging and useful and all sorts of good things, it’s still not coming close to Facebook in terms of people actually spending time on it, and futzing the numbers isn’t going to make anyone suddenly decide to become a Plusser. 

Google+ is like that rich girl with all of the coolest toys who tries to throw a party but everyone’s already made plans to hang out at their usual place and besides, she’s getting a little too eager. And although the numbers do indicate that there is a growing interest in using the network, they may be grossly exaggerating how many people consider Google+ a social media destination. 

Mobile

Google tracks your location — even when you deny it permission

Google is tracking your location -- even when you tell it not to. According to an investigation by the Associated Press, Google services on both Android and iPhones store location data, regardless of whether privacy settings claim…
Mobile

The 100 best Android apps turn your phone into a jack-of-all-trades

Choosing which apps to download is tricky, especially given how enormous and cluttered the Google Play Store has become. We rounded up 100 of the best Android apps and divided them neatly, each suited for a different occasion.
Computing

Google Chrome now shows browser notifications in Windows 10 Action Center

Google's switch to displaying Chrome notifications inside Windows 10's Action Center gives users more control. Now, Windows 10's Focus Assist, a do not disturb function, can also be applied to Chrome notifications.
Mobile

Find your way around Google Maps with these handy tips and tricks

How good are your navigation skills? We've got a delectable menu of Google Maps tips and tricks for you right here, to take the pain out of your trips. Go from newbie to mapping master and learn how to use Google Maps.
Social Media

Facebook dismantles fake accounts that had thousands interested in a rally

A group of coordinated fake Facebook accounts created a rally that had thousands of users interested in attending. Facebook removed the Pages and accounts, shared data with law enforcement and is notifying users that followed the event.
Social Media

Time alerts put the brakes on your Facebook and Instagram consumption

Just how much time do you spend scrolling through the Facebook and Instagram feeds? Facebook is about to tell you. The new features also include daily alerts that tell users when they've spent too much time on the social networks.
Social Media

It’s over: Tinder won the dating wars. Swipe or stay home

From OKCupid to Bumble, a variety of online dating apps still elbow for superiority, but look at the numbers and the verdict is clear: Tinder wins by a mile. Here’s why the swiping model can’t be beat.
Social Media

Snapchat now uses speech recognition to animate your face

Get your tongue back in your mouth -- Snapchat's latest Lenses react instead to a specific keyword. The new Lenses animate after hearing a specific keyword, which Snapchat displays on the screen.
Mobile

Here’s how to hide your active status on Instagram

The Activity Status mode on Instagram shows people whenever you are online, similar to Facebook Messenger. If that annoys you, here's how to hide your active status on Instagram with a quick settings change.
Computing

The Facebook dating service will be free of charge and free of ads

Facebook is getting into the dating game. While the feature was one of the surprises from this year's F8, new details suggest what the feature may entail, including a few screenshots from a computer programmer.
Social Media

Three million people quit Snapchat after the redesign

After a million users signed petitions to get the old Snapchat back, the network's user count is showing the early results of the changes with a three-million-user drop in daily active users.
Social Media

Facebook wants to help you find a mentor with its latest Groups feature

Facebook is designed for connecting to other people -- so why not mentors? Today, Facebook launched a program inside Groups that allows for two users to go through a mentorship program together.
Social Media

Facebook’s less cluttered friend list feeds are no more

Facebook friend feeds created a more curated news feed -- but not anymore. Facebook discontinued the feature, saying it wasn't widely used. The move will help the network focus on improving the news feed, the company says.
Photography

Starting a vlog? Here are the best cameras to buy

Any camera that shoots video can be used to vlog, but a few models stand out from the crowd thanks to superior image quality, ergonomics, and usability.