Skip to main content

Instagram’s IGTV contracts won’t allow creators to make political videos 

Instagram will pay for celebrities’ video production for IGTV, but its contract stipulates the performers “must not include content about social issues, elections, or politics,” according to Bloomberg News. IGTV is Instagram’s answer to YouTube, and the clause sounds different from what parent company Facebook’s CEO Mark Zuckerberg has said about banning political ads.

“There’s a pretty big difference between allowing political speech and funding it directly,” Adam Mosseri, the head of Instagram, tweeted in response to the Bloomberg News article. He added that the platform “welcomes all points of view.”

The contract would prohibit creators from making content about social issues including civil rights, immigration, education, health, and guns, according to reporter Sarah Frier. IGTV isn’t Facebook’s only video service, and Facebook Watch has contracts with news companies that cover politics. Facebook has come under fire for its role in spreading fake news across its services, including WhatsApp. One of Zuckerberg’s arguments against breaking up the company is its size means it can more effectively combat the problem with more resources. Yet its policies vary from platform to platform, making oversight more difficult.

IGTV began in June 2018 and has small viewership compared to YouTube. One recent high-performing video, a clip of Billy on the Street with Chris Evans, had about 166,000 views. On YouTube, the number was over 1 million. “In the last few years, we’ve offset small production costs for video creators on our platforms and have put certain guidelines in place,” a Facebook spokesperson told Bloomberg News. Some creators will make as much as $250,000 for over 20 posts. Perhaps one reason IGTV hasn’t caught on (its stand-alone app has about 1,100 reviews in iTunes, versus Instagram’s 14 million) is that it wasn’t willing to pay creators at all in the beginning.

Though both Facebook and Mosseri have insisted that there’s a difference between allowing political speech and funding it, by paying for political ads, that’s exactly what the company does. In the past, Zuckerberg has said of Facebook: “ Do we ban ads about health care, immigration, or women’s empowerment?” It’s difficult to see how Facebook will justify policing these issues in one arena and not another — especially because these issues are not just political but are personal as well. Could creators make videos about a steep hospital bill, their immigrant families, or interactions with law enforcement, for example, or would they have to upload those to YouTube?

Editors' Recommendations

Jenny McGrath
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Jenny McGrath is a senior writer at Digital Trends covering the intersection of tech and the arts and the environment. Before…
How to download Instagram photos (5 easy ways)
Instagram app running on the Samsung Galaxy Z Flip 5.

Instagram is amazing, and many of us use it as a record of our lives — uploading the best bits of our trips, adventures, and notable moments. But sometimes you can lose the original files of those moments, leaving the Instagram copy as the only available one . While you may be happy to leave it up there, it's a lot more convenient to have another version of it downloaded onto your phone or computer. While downloading directly from Instagram can be tricky, there are ways around it. Here are a few easy ways to download Instagram photos.

Read more
X seems to have deleted years of old Twitter images
The new X sign replacing the Twitter logo on the company's headquarters in San Francisco.

The social media platform formerly known as Twitter and recently rebranded as X appears to be having trouble showing images posted on the site between 2011 and 2014.

The issue came to widespread attention on Saturday when X user Tom Coates noted how the famous selfie posted by Ellen DeGeneres at the Oscars in 2014, which quickly broke the “most retweets” record, was no longer displaying. Later reports suggested the image had been restored, though, at the time of writing, we’re not seeing it.

Read more
X says it’s squashing the bug that deleted Twitter images and links
The new X sign replacing the Twitter logo on the company's headquarters in San Francisco.

X, formerly known as Twitter, says it’s working to restore potentially millions of images and links that suddenly and rather mysteriously disappeared from the platform in recent days.

“Over the weekend we had a bug that prevented us from displaying images from before 2014,” the company said in a post on its Support account on Monday. “No images or data were lost. We fixed the bug, and the issue will be fully resolved in the coming days.”

Read more