Is Vine really being killed off by video for Instagram?

instagram vineWe knew that Instagram video would be a problem for Vine. But is it actually chewing up and spitting out Twitter’s looping video service as swiftly as some are suggesting?

If you use Topsy’s free analytics tool, it sure seems like Vine is in an unstoppable free fall of doom. Looking at the graph that pops up when you compare shares of instagram.com links versus vine.co links, you’ll see that Vine shares started dropping the day of the Instagram video announcement, to the tune of a 40 percent decline. And Marketing Land reports that Vine continued to lose momentum over the weekend, with shares dropping even further, to a 70 percent decline from a week after Instagram’s video launch. Yowza. Screen Shot 2013-07-01 at 1.08.26 PM

That looks like a really bad sign for Vine, especially since it is owned by Twitter and previously enjoyed more frequent shares than Instagram photographs. After Vine debuted on Android, the share count looked very different on Topsy, with the six-second videos besting Instagram’s filtered videos just a few weeks prior to the Instagram video launch.

 vine instagram

And Vine’s struggles are compounded by a few different factors. Flipboard just added an update to enable Instagram videos, while it still lacks the same capability to show Vines. The positive buzz Vine enjoyed after adding Android was largely nullified by Instagram’s news, since getting a whole new feature set is more exciting than expanding to a different operating system. And Instagram’s esteemed place in the social network word gives it an obvious leg up over Vine, which is still relatively new and working toward establishing itself. Simply Measured looked at how brands are using Vine and Instagram video and found that twice as many Top 100 brands were using the new Instagram video feature compared to Vine, which underscores how Instagram has a huge advantage thanks to its larger audience and the fact that brands were already using the photo service.

But the coverage of Vine’s demise is both overblown and unfair. Yes, if you look at the Topsy graph, it seems like everyone decided Vine was rotting at once. But that wasn’t the only graph that Topsy released. In a blog post, Topsy included a second graph available for their Pro users that tells a different story. The first Topsy graph culled data from top “influencers” on Twitter, while their Pro tool lets you look at all Twitter users, which gives a more complete picture of what’s going on. And if you look at all of the mentions and shares for Vines and Instagram videos, the decline of Vine doesn’t appear as swift or certain – and even Topsy agrees.

Jamie de Guerre, the senior Vice President of Product and Marketing at Topsy, explains why the second graph is more accurate. “The second graph is based on exact counts of Instagram photo and video sharing versus Vine video sharing, so it’s not an apples to apples comparison. It’s also important to note that these counts are of photos and videos shared directly through Twitter only, and they don’t take into account sharing through other social networks.”

Screen Shot 2013-07-01 at 1.30.08 PMAs you can see, Instagram is definitely way more popular than Vine. There was never a point where it wasn’t more popular. And Vine mentions do dip at the end of the graph after the introduction of Instagram video. But it doesn’t look like Instagram video killed Vine. It looks like Instagram always dominated Vine in terms of popularity and the video feature put a dent in Vine’s fledgling status. But that drop followed a spike created by Vine appearing on Android, so it’s not really fair to say Instagram video started vacuum-sucking all of Vine’s fans away.

Looking at Google Trends, you can see that interest in Vine and Instagram more accurately resembles Topsy’s second graph, not its first.

Screen Shot 2013-07-01 at 1.22.04 PMInstagram is just a bigger, more popular service. Some comedians and musicians are on Vine, but everyone and the First Lady are on Instagram. It’s a more versatile and better established. You can look at Instagram from your desktop. Of course the fact that it introduced a service that many see as extremely similar to what Vine offers would hurt Vine. When a competitor appears on the scene, especially one with a better pedigree, that generally spells trouble.

This all isn’t to say Vine is about to fall off the face of the earth. Sure, Instagram video has fancy filters, a longer run time, and camera-steadying technology built into a service people already use. But Vine’s experienced a viral beginning for a reason.

There is space for both Vine and Instagram video to exist and succeed, and just because people paid more attention to Instagram video than Vine immediately after the former debuted doesn’t mean Vine is done. Instagram will likely continue to be a more popular platform, since it offers both photo and video capabilities. But I’d wager that Instagram’s video capability will not take off and become as well-liked or oft-used as its photo feature. The fun of Instagram is scrolling through moments in your friends’ lives, not pausing and watching little video snippets. As it is now, the video snippets on Instagram are less interesting and take more effort to create than photographs – anytime a feature launches there’s an experimentation period and this one could die down. 

Vine will certainly need to keep improving and taking steps to attract and keep fans to remain relevant (how about introducing an easy way to make silent clips?) but the so-called death grip Instagram has over it is nothing more than an exaggeration of initial excitement over Instagram video.

News

President Trump is no longer allowed to block people on Twitter, court rules

President Donald Trump cannot block critics from viewing his Twitter feed, a federal appeals court ruled. The court said that Trump violated the First Amendment by blocking people who were critical of him and his policies and that his…
News

Twitter finally banned hate speech against religious groups. Will it help?

Twitter will expand its rules to ban hateful conduct made against religious groups. The new rules will require the company to remove any tweet which “dehumanizes whole religious groups,” but it's not clear whether it will solve…
Social Media

Looking to share some content? Here's how to repost on Instagram

Have you ever seen a cool picture on Instagram that you wanted to share? There's no official means of reposting content on Instagram, but there are a few workarounds. We break down the two most logical choices for getting the job done.
Mobile

Bitmoji lets you create personalized emojis to spice up your online chats

Looking for more interesting ways to use emoji when chatting? Bitmoji are personalized emoji that you design to look just like you -- and then create a whole keyboard of stickers that you can use with them. Here's what you should know.
News

Facebook no longer lets you save your friends’ birthdays to your own calendar

Facebook quietly removed a feature that allowed users to export and sync their friends’ birthdays to an external calendar like iCal or Google Calendar. While you can still export upcoming events -- parties, get-togethers, and the like --…
Social Media

Your Twitter name can change with the times, just like you do — here's how

Despite what you may or may not have heard, Twitter names aren't actually set in stone. Check out our quick-hit guide on how to change your Twitter username and display name in less than five minutes.
News

Reddit is finally back online after an hours-long desktop outage

Reddit is back online for desktop users after an hours-long outage early Thursday morning. Reddit's status page said it was still investigating some residual issues, so users may still have some trouble accessing the site. 
Social Media

Here’s why Twitter went down for an hour earlier on Thursday

Twitter is finally back online after going down for users around the globe late Thursday morning. The hour-long disruption made Twitter the latest major social media network to go offline over the past month
Social Media

Facebook now allows you to opt out of those ads that target your tastes

Tired of seeing Facebook ads that aren’t relevant to you? Now you can not only opt out of ads from that company, but you can also see why the ad was shown to you in the first place.
How-To

Stop Facebook from tracking you and using targeted ads with these tips

Facebook and businesses that use the site track what pages you like, your political affiliation, and even try to guess your race. All of this is done so the site can target you with relevant ads. Here's how to opt out.
Social Media

YouTube offers creators more ways to boost their bank accounts

Whether you're a top YouTube creator or just breaking into the game, the video-streaming site has some new features designed to help you please your fans and increase your bank balance.
News

President Trump attacks Facebook Libra, says it’s not dependable like the dollar

President Trump attacked Facebook's new Libra cryptocurrency on Thursday, claiming it will have "little standing or dependability" and that Facebook would need to seek a banking charter if it wanted to move forward.
Social Media

The FTC will hit Facebook with a $5 billion fine over privacy violations

Facebook has agreed to a $5 billion settlement with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) over its numerous “privacy missteps." Once it goes through, this would be the largest FTC fine for a major technology company – and a huge chunk of…
News

Lua uses animated emotions to help you keep your plants happy and healthy

The Lua Smart Planter is currently seeking funding on Indiegogo to make this smiling plant pot a reality. The device helps you take care of your plants by showing their needs through a series of animated faces.