Skip to main content

Is Soundhalo a Spotify killer or just a concert-goer buzzkill?

thom yorke bittorent soundhalo atoms for peace

All Barry Palmer’s son Declan wanted to do was share a moment from a live concert with his dad. But he didn’t just want your run-of-the-mill iPhone footage; he wanted great video. He wanted high quality sound – he wanted it to be like his dad was actually there, experiencing the concert. The lights, the screaming, the musicians faces, the whole package. 

“Having struggled to share even half decent mobile phone footage of the concert, Declan imagined an app that would allow sharing HD quality videos in real time,” explains Palmer, an indie label music executive who is the CEO and co-founder (along with Liza Boston) of a service that aims to do exactly that: Soundhalo. Palmer employs an in-house production team that captures professional quality sound and video from concerts and provides them in a shareable format to fans. 

Related Videos

Soundhalo is trying to create a whole new catalog of unique, live experiences.

But maybe you already know Soundhalo as the service that Thom Yorke endorses. The Radiohead front man recently put Spotify in the spotlight by yanking tracks from his latest project, Atoms for Peace (as well as much of his solo work), from the streaming service. The choice prompted plenty of discussion about the economics of music streaming services and whether or not they can help artists or will only encourage a race to the bottom in terms of what musicians can make. 

This was followed by a rather surprising twist when Yorke and Atoms for Peace announced a partnership with Soundhalo. While Soundhalo says the deal was in the works before Yorke’s Spotify tirade, the announcement did make Yorke’s actions seem pretty PR stunt-like. So, what is it about Palmer’s digital music service that satisfies a streaming skeptic like Yorke? 

The main thing is the most obvious one: there’s no streaming. On Soundhalo, you pay for what you consume – around $1.60 per song or $16 for an entire concert – as opposed to a Spotify-style payment plan that gives you all you can eat, commercial free, for a flat monthly fee. Also, Soundhalo isn’t trying to license every track ever recorded the way Spotify does; it’s trying to create a whole new catalog of unique, live experiences. Soundhalo’s production team records video and audio from a concert that is then mixed and mastered by their “world class mastering engineers.” Then, this content is made available for users to download online almost immediately after the concert is over – as Soundhalo tells it, “just moments after the last note rings out on stage.”

Once you’ve purchased Soundhalo songs, they’re yours to store and sync however you want (they offer cloud storage if you don’t want to lose space by downloading), and the content is all shareable. You can Facebook it, tweet a link, whatever – you can even email the file itself to a friend.

Clearly, Spotify – or Rdio, iTunes, Google Music, whatever – Soundhalo is not. While “traditional” digital music services provide some live music, it’s limited; selection is limited by what the record labels have in their catalogs (and which of those the services can get rights to), and the offering itself is limited to sound and sound alone. Soundhalo looks to create the next best thing to attending a concert yourself – not just hearing a concert but seeing it, too, all in the highest quality format possible. 

It’s difficult to know how big a draw the live music gambit it, since none of the established services provide metrics on how popular their live offerings are. But there are some interesting things we do know: For starters, while album sales have dropped thanks to the digital music evolution, there’s been an increased demand for concerts. You could argue that, as our access to music increases, our interest in paying for the real deal – the live concert – increases, too.

Consumer interest in only one part of the equation; there’s also consumer behavior

And maybe that means Soundhalo is on to something. If we’re willing to pay for the ticket, maybe we’re willing to pay for the download, too. There’s something to be said for “the next best thing,” and this next best thing comes at a fraction of the cost of a concert ticket and gives you much more dynamic content than the audio of a live recording you’re listening to on Spotify or downloading from iTunes. There’s also information suggesting that the digital concert experience is something that will only become more popular in the future.

In the ultimate irony, research conducted in part by Spoitfy determined that live music events are leading to increased illegal downloads. “Our analysis uncovered some examples of torrents spiking immediately after festival performances,” says Spotify. “Festivals increase demand for artists’ music, [that] festival-goers mainly sample through unauthorized channels.”

But consumer interest is only one part of the equation; there’s also consumer behavior. The way Palmer talks about it, you’d think every concertgoer experiences the same frustrations as his son. “Put the phone down,” Palmer recently said about the tendency to self-document concerts. “We are on the cutting edge of the future. [Soundhalo] is about live videos straight from the stage direct to your smartphone.”

Yorke’s Atoms For Peace and Radiohead collaborator Nigel Godrich, for one, agrees: “Part of the reason Soundhalo was interesting to me was that I found myself wondering why, whenever you go to a gig, the next day there are a million shaky, horrible sounding YouTube videos already online,” he said in a release. 

Soundhalo sales

But this is where Soundhalo starts to sound potentially out of step with its own potential customers. The videos Godrich complains about are all over the internet because, by all accounts, we – the listeners – want them there. Apps focusing on documenting the live event and specifically the concert experience are coming out of the woodwork, and don’t appear to be going anywhere. Instagram, Vine, Viddy, they are a staple at every concert; they’re the reason for all those lit up screens thrust into the air throughout entire performances. They exploit one of the truest things we know people want to do with social media: Brag. Brag about our music choices, the fact we’re at a live event and an interesting place, that we’re experiencing something unique. (Much to Beyonce’s dismay.)

soundhalo Atoms for Peace drummer

When Soundhalo is described as a “sharing” app, this isn’t sharing the way many people currently think of it, as it relates to their own concert-going experiences. Your friends aren’t recording and sharing the event with you, Soundhalo – and the artists it’s working with – is. And while you can share what they’ve created with your social circle, it’s not something you made or experienced in the narrative sense that drives so much of what we post to our various social channels. Does cutting out the “I was here and I did this” element in favor of super high quality sound and video sound awesome or awful to you,? Soundhalo needs the answer to be the former. 

Of course, before it ever gets an answer to that question, there’s lots to do. The app is still in beta and Soundhalo isn’t releasing details on the other artists it’s working with or how it intends to scale up what sounds like a pretty expensive production model to capture anything beyond a tiny number of concerts on any given day or week. Whatever happens, there’s about to be a whole new way to consume and share music digitally, which can only benefit us, the fans. Then again, ever since music went digital, hasn’t that always been the case?

Editors' Recommendations

Facebook’s Music Stories allows iPhone users to share snippets on News Feeds
facebook music stories adds more services listen scroll

Facebook unveiled a new feature in its iOS app that will integrate 30-second clips of songs from streamers like Spotify and Apple Music on News Feeds. Called Music Stories, the feature allows users to stream clips directly from their feeds, follow links to add songs to their Apple Music or Spotify accounts, and purchase the song via iTunes.

To use Music Stories, users simply click “share song” on the streaming service of their choice and then paste the link to their status on Facebook’s iOS app. The social network will then format it to play a 30-second preview. When the song pops up on a friend’s News Feed, he or she can play the 30-second clip directly on Facebook before being prompted to stream more music through the third-party streamer or to purchase the track from iTunes.

Read more
Spotify acquires The Echo Nest, buffs up its musical expertise
echonest and spotify

A few years ago, The Echo Nest, a self-proclaimed "music intelligence company," integrated its APIs with Spotify, the music service we know and (might) love. It looks like Spotify didn't want a slice of the pie, but the entire thing, because it just announced its plans to acquire the service.
Headquartered in Somerville, Massachusetts, The Echo Nest gives developers the ability to determine what recommendations to make for listeners of their respective streaming radio services. While Spotify currently makes recommendations, this acquisition will further strengthen its "music intelligence," with Spotify's strategy to increase revenue for the music industry and increase global music consumption.
"We are hyper focused on creating the best user experience and it starts with building the best music intelligence platform on the planet," said Spotify founder and CEO Daniel Ek. "With The Echo Nest joining Spotify, we will make a big leap forward in our quest to play you the best music possible."
The Echo Nest CEO Jim Lucchese echoed Ek's sentiments. "Joining forces with Spotify gives us the opportunity to continue [to help fans discover more music] as part of the fastest-growing service in the world," said Ek. "We're thrilled to be part of a team equally as passionate about connecting more people with more music."
Even though The Echo Nest will be acquired by Spotify, it will remain headquartered in Somerville, while its office in San Francisco will continue to operate. Also, for developers wanting to use the company's API, it will remain free.
This is good for competing music services, such as Rdio, that uses The Echo Nest's services to power its music recommendations. Now that The Echo Nest is under Spotify, though, we'll wait and see how long that will last.

Read more
Forgotify – the service that brings you unplayed Spotify tracks

Recent data from Spotify showed that there are a lot of very lonely tracks on its servers. Tracks that just sit there, passing the time of day, doing nothing. Absolutely nothing. Never searched for. Never accessed. Never played.
The music streaming giant even put a figure on it, revealing that about four million of its tracks – that's about 20 percent of its entire catalog – have never been streamed.
Feeling a bit sorry for these solitary songs, a small team of music lovers set up Forgotify, a service that seeks out never-visited Spotify music and gives those lonely tracks a chance to know what it's like to feel wanted.

The set-up is simple enough. Once you're logged in to Spotify, you just head over to where you'll be presented with a track that's never been streamed. Then it's just a matter of hitting the play button and having a listen. If you like it, you can share it. If not, just hit the 'next' button for another unplayed track.
You might come across Ayre Rayde's funky Sock It To Me, or possibly Barry and Holly Tashian's tuneful Heaven With You (recorded live in Holland), or even Mahir Burekovic's remarkable Ti si mi zena najdraza. The tracks cover a huge variety of genres and appear to be a varied mix of established artists from around the world to newer bands and singers looking to make it big.
Forgotify is the brainchlid of Lane Jordan, J Hausmann, and Nate Gagnon, who say on their website that it's nothing short of  "a musical travesty" that so many songs sit silently on Spotify's servers, although after listening to some of them, the term "musical travesty" may come to mind once again.
To remedy the situation, the trio set out to "give these neglected songs another way to reach your ear holes."

Read more