Kim Kardashian can get a deepfake taken off YouTube. It’s much harder for you

Axelle/Bauer-Griffin/Getty Images

YouTube took down an incredibly realistic — and fake — video purporting to show Kim Kardashian West discussing a shadowy organization called “Spectre” and mocking her fans for violating copyright. The takedown on Monday could give public figures a new weapon in the fight against deepfakes, but it won’t help much as fake videos increasingly target everyday people.

Deepfakes — or incredibly realistic fake videos — have grown from a nuisance to a worldwide problem as they’ve become harder and harder to detect. The videos can essentially make it look like someone said something when they never did, and could be used for all kinds of nefarious purposes, from pranks to politics.

The Kardashian deepfake, uploaded to YouTube on May 29 by anti-advertising activists Brandalism, was removed because of a copyright claim by publisher Condé Nast. The original video used to make the deepfake came from a video uploaded in April by the publisher’s Vogue magazine.

“It certainly shows how the existing legal infrastructure could help,” Henry Ajder, head of communications and research analysis at Deeptrace, told Digital Trends.  “But it seems to be available for the privileged few.”

Ajder said that Deeptrace, an organization building a system to detect deepfakes on the web, has noticed an increase in deepfakes being uploaded to YouTube, both from the U.S. and around the globe. The Kardashian copyright claim has the potential to set a new precedent for when and how these kinds of videos are taken down, he added. It’s a tricky problem, since no one has decided if the manipulated videos fall into the category of fair use. Taking videos like these down open up giant tech companies to accusations that they’re impinging on freedom of expression.

But if deepfakes are subject to copyright claims — like the Kardashian video apparently is — it could give sites a fairly simple way to take down misleading fake videos. We reached out to YouTube to see if this is part of a new policy for deepfakes, but have yet to hear back. Brandalism also did not respond to a request for comment.

While this gives some ammo in the fight against deepfakes, there’s still a long way to go. For one, Condé Nast is a huge company that can easily make a copyright claim on YouTube (and likely makes many every day). If someone made a deepfake of you, for example, it wouldn’t be quite so easy. Someone could record you, then manipulate the footage to make it look like you said or did something you never did. If they recorded the footage, they own it — so there’s no copyright claim.

The problem could be even worse than that, according to Ajder. “Someone could scrape images from Facebook and make a video of you doing something you never did,” he said.

That’s already happening, Ajder said. A huge amount of deepfake targets have been women including those subjected to fake revenge porn, with their faces pasted on the bodies of others. Once a video is out there, there’s not much someone can do to take it down.

“The legal recourse to take down deepfakes of individuals are sparse, “ Ajder said. “We don’t have the infrastructure in place to deal with these problems.”

Some are working to change that. Rep. Yvette Clarke (D-NY) recently introduced a bill that would impose rules on deepfakes, but they would be largely unenforceable in the Wild West of the web.

Not everyone seems to be following YouTube’s approach. Another Brandalism deepfake showing CEO Mark Zuckerberg praising Spectre has more than 100,00 views on Facebook-owned Instagram. That video, made from an interview with Zuckerberg on CBS News, remained online as of Monday morning despite CBS requesting Instagram remove it for an “unauthorized use of the CBSN” trademark, a CBS spokesperson said. The Kardashian video is still online on both Twitter and Instagram — and a Zuckerberg deepfake is still online on Brandalism’s YouTube page.

YouTube did take down a doctored video purporting to show Nancy Pelosi slurring her words, but it remained up on Facebook with a note saying that the video was fake. The Pelosi video seemed much more intentionally malicious than the Kardashian ones, which could be considered parody. YouTube will shut down misinformation when pushed, but Facebook would prefer not to be an arbiter of truth.

Neither of the massive tech companies seems prepared for the coming wave of deepfakes targeting individuals, however.

“There’s been pushback for public figures,” said Ajder. “But deepfakes are on track for an exponential increase in reputation damage or misinformation.”

Emerging Tech

Dark side of the moon: Why lunar landing conspiracies flourish online

Social media platforms seemed lovely at first, places to share dumb jokes and the minutiae of everyday life. Those sites have an underbelly, however, and have been a breeding ground for conspiracy theories.
Mobile

What's the difference between 4G and LTE ... and does it even matter?

Wireless standards are confusing -- it doesn't matter if you're talking about 4G, LTE, WiMax, or others. Here, we break down the differences between 4G and LTE so you can make sense of how they play out in real-world scenarios.
Emerging Tech

Stallone in Terminator 2? How one deepfake prankster is changing cinema history

Ever wanted to see The Shining with Jim Carrey instead of Jack Nicholson? How about Stallone in Terminator 2: Judgement Day instead of everyone's favorite governator? Thanks to deepfakes, it's now possible -- just ask YouTuber Ctrl Shift…
Movies & TV

Tired of Netflix? Here's where to find free movies online, legally

We've spent countless hours digging around the web to find the best sites for streaming free movies online. Not only are all of these sites completely free to use, they're also completely legal and trustworthy.
Social Media

Facebook now allows you to opt out of those ads that target your tastes

Tired of seeing Facebook ads that aren’t relevant to you? Now you can not only opt out of ads from that company, but you can also see why the ad was shown to you in the first place.
How-To

Stop Facebook from tracking you and using targeted ads with these tips

Facebook and businesses that use the site track what pages you like, your political affiliation, and even try to guess your race. All of this is done so the site can target you with relevant ads. Here's how to opt out.
Social Media

YouTube offers creators more ways to boost their bank accounts

Whether you're a top YouTube creator or just breaking into the game, the video-streaming site has some new features designed to help you please your fans and increase your bank balance.
News

President Trump attacks Facebook Libra, says it’s not dependable like the dollar

President Trump attacked Facebook's new Libra cryptocurrency on Thursday, claiming it will have "little standing or dependability" and that Facebook would need to seek a banking charter if it wanted to move forward.
Social Media

The FTC will hit Facebook with a $5 billion fine over privacy violations

Facebook has agreed to a $5 billion settlement with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) over its numerous “privacy missteps." Once it goes through, this would be the largest FTC fine for a major technology company – and a huge chunk of…
News

Lua uses animated emotions to help you keep your plants happy and healthy

The Lua Smart Planter is currently seeking funding on Indiegogo to make this smiling plant pot a reality. The device helps you take care of your plants by showing their needs through a series of animated faces.
Mobile

Flex your thumbs (and your brain) with these fun texting games

Gaming consoles keep getting more advanced, but you can still have fun with the good old Latin alphabet. Here are our picks for the best texting games, so you can make the most fun out of that limited data plan or basic cell phone.
News

Facebook says it won’t launch Libra until regulators are happy

Facebook says it won’t roll out its Libra cryptocurrency until it’s fully addressed regulatory concerns – though it added that regulation of the currency itself would largely happen in Switzerland, not the U.S.
Social Media

Twitter’s mobile-inspired dark mode desktop makeover isn’t just about looks

Twitter.com may have a new look, but it's one that already feels familiar. The new design for Twitter's desktop version borrows heavily from the platform's mobile apps, with a sleeker look, a new dark mode, and easier navigation.
Digital Trends Live

Digital Trends Live: Twitter’s redesign, Libra’s possible delay, Neuralink

On this episode of DT Live, we take a look at the biggest trending stories in tech, including a Twitter redesign, Facebook's delay of Libra, Neuralink's first public event, growing food in space, and the 50th anniversary of Apollo 11.