Skip to main content

A 2012 article proposed a smarter version of Facebook Shared Albums

this study totally called facebooks shared photo albums and has some ideas to improve them polaroids
Image used with permission by copyright holder

This week Facebook quietly rolled out Shared Albums, which lets you co-create massive galleries with your friends. The idea is that all those collective pictures from birthdays, trips, weddings, parties, etc that get spread out between the bunch of you will now have one home. The album’s max photo limit? 10,000 photos. Talk about comprehensive. 

It’s a smart feature for Facebook to roll out, especially considering that more than a couple third party apps had solutions out there to fill the void. So why the wait? All Facebook told us was that the update came after a hackathon earlier this year and that it was a popular user request. 

Apparently, these researchers knew things were heading in Shared Albums direction – and maybe even have a few upgrades that could improve it. An article titled Analyzing Facebook features to support event detection for photo-based Facebook applications was published in 2012 at a German University and basically hits the sharing albums nail on the head. 

“Until now there is no easy way to detect and link photos that are related to the same events, which are usually distributed between between friends and albums. In this work, we introduce an approach that exploits Facebook feature to link photos related to the same event.” 

Sound familiar? The article, however, goes on to suggest methods for taking things up a notch: 

“In the current situation where the EXIF header of photos is missing in Facebook, we extract visual-based, tagged areas-based, friendship-based and structure-based features. We evaluate each of these features and use the results in our approach. We introduce and evaluate a semi-supervised probabilistic approach that takes into account the evaluation of these features.”

So basically, instead of having to request people get in on the album sharing business and manually upload the photos from whatever fun group activity you guys did not invite me to, this proposed system would analyze data points like what the photos looked like, if they were location tags, and if similar people were in them. It sound as if a shared album would just be auto-created if you and you’re friends all uploaded images from the same event because the service could tell that the place was the same, the people were the same, etc. Given that Facebook is expanding it’s already massive facial recognition database, it certainly seems possible. 

And sure, while Facebook pre-determining these elements means things could be hit or miss (we’ve all seen the social network pull a drunken, “Is this you?” face tag request indicating it thinks you’re an elbow), it’s also intriguing. Imagine seeing a photo album of your hiking trip, full of everyone’s photos, the minute those images are uploaded. 

Maybe these features will be added to Shared Albums in the future? “In this approach we create a look-up table of the initialization values of our model variables and make it available for other Facebook applications or researchers to use. The evaluation of our approach showed promising results.”

Editors' Recommendations

Molly McHugh
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Before coming to Digital Trends, Molly worked as a freelance writer, occasional photographer, and general technical lackey…
Period-tracking apps are sharing people’s intimate data with Facebook
Facebook Logo

Some period-tracking apps are sending Facebook personal information about the women who use them.
In order to work, the apps require women to enter information about their menstrual cycle as well as information about their sexual activity. According to a report released Monday by the United Kingdom-based advocacy group Privacy International, a number of those apps then share that information with Facebook, Buzzfeed reports.
Specifically, the group said the apps MIA Fem and Maya sent information about women’s use of contraception, when their monthly periods were, and whether or not they experienced symptoms like cramps and swelling to the social network. 
For some perspective, the app Maya currently has over 5 million downloads. The makers of MIA say that it has more than 2 million users around the world. We've reached out to the developers of both apps for comment and additional details on how they use user data, but have yet to receive a response. Maya's owner, Plackal Tech, told Buzzfeed that it doesn't share any personally identifiable data or medical data with Facebook. 
Data is being shared with Facebook through the social network’s Software Developer Kit (SDK). The SDK allows developers to collect user data so Facebook can show users targeted ads. Beyond being used for advertising, the data can also be collected by Facebook and used outside of the social network.
Facebook has reportedly reached out to the developers of both apps to discuss how they are potentially violating the company’s terms of service. Facebook requires app developers to disclosed to users what information -- if any -- is being shared with Facebook. In the case of the two apps, it seems like that is not happening. The fault in this particular situation appears to be with the app developers, not the social network.
Privacy, in general, has been a growing concern as it pertains to Facebook, specifically following the Cambridge Analytica scandal. The Federal Trade Commission fined Facebook $5 billion over its use of private data in the wake of the scandal.
During court proceedings for a class-action lawsuit focused on Cambridge Analytica, the company’s lawyer, Orin Snyder, said that there is “no expectation of privacy” on Facebook.
“There is no invasion of privacy at all, because there is no privacy,” Snyder said while trying to convince U.S. District Court Judge Vince Chhabria toss out the lawsuit. Snyder argued that users had given consent to share their data with third parties. “You have to closely guard something to have a reasonable expectation of privacy,” he said.
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg has made a number of statements over the past year stressing the company’s desire to make a privacy-focused social platform.

Read more
Off-Facebook Activity: How to control the private data apps and sites share with Facebook
mark zuckerberg deepfakes aspen ideas festival facebook hosts annual f8 developer conference in san jose

Facebook finally introduced a tool that allows you to control and limit the data that third-party apps and websites share with the social media giant -- a feature that should help improve Facebook's much-criticized stance on privacy.

While not quite the “Clear History” tool that CEO Mark Zuckerberg promised in 2018, the new Off-Facebook Activity tool should help you disable some of the ways that Facebook and advertisers track your activity around the web.

Read more
Federal investigation digs into Facebook’s data-sharing deals

Another day, another Facebook data scandal but the latest one could bring criminal charges. According to The New York Times, federal prosecutors are investigating the social network’s deals that shared user data with smartphone manufacturers. Facebook said they are cooperating with the investigation in a statement.

A grand jury in the Eastern District of New York subpoenaed records from at least two smartphone companies concerning deals the companies made with Facebook for data sharing. The investigation comes after reports last year of the social network sharing personal data with smartphone and tablet companies and developers.

Read more