Welcome to the all-knowing, very searchable, saturated world of the hashtag

hashtag key

Hashtags are more mainstream than ever, but they’re morphing into something way weirder than the search and discovery tools they were meant to be. They can be super annoying when people clutter their posts with 15 different tags in a bid to gain followers (cough #followback cough cough #stopdoingthat cough) but they’re being used in interesting and unexpected ways, too. Depending on where and when you’re throwing down the shift-3, they can enhance or spoil your social media experience.

The good, the bad, and the ugly of the Twitter hashtag

Twitter users popularized the hashtag, but hashtags don’t operate on Twitter the way you may assume. People who load their tweets with hashtags aren’t usually upping their chances of gaining influence in any substantial way.

That doesn’t mean hashtags don’t work. They do work – in a big way. Companies have found all sorts of ingenious ways to use hashtags as branding tools – as evidenced during the SuperBowl, when campaigns from Budweiser, Audi, Volkswagon, Best Buy and Speed Stick all came with catchy hashtags.

And according to a survey taken by RadiumOne, an advertising company, people are interested in hashtag campaigns that involve perks (not surprising). Screen Shot 2013-04-01 at 1.06.13 PM

But what works for companies and Twitter users with larger followings doesn’t really apply to people who have smaller groups, since their posts get seen by less people.

When an average Twitter user uses a popular hashtag – for instance, #SXSW during the festival, or #Superbowl on game day – it is true that their posts will appear in searches for the hashtag. But since Twitter defaults to showing you the top users who tweeted with it, unless you’re Rob Delaney or Justin Bieber, you won’t pop up in the first results people see. 

Screen Shot 2013-04-01 at 9.58.11 AMEven if you switch to see all users instead of just the top, the sheer volume of tweets with the same tag mean the chances of someone noticing yours are about as good as the chances of Kim and Kanye’s baby having a chance at a normal life – #notgreat.

There were 4,000 tweets with the hashtag #Superbowl sent a second this year, so the chances of someone new seeing yours probably weren’t as good as you hoped.

If you want to make your Twitter hashtags possibly more useful, you can use Twitter analytics services to see which of your tweets tend to garner more attention – though since Twitter is developing its own analytics service, those third-party apps might not be long for this digital world. Maybe you get hit with crickets when you tried to live-tweet the Oscars, no matter how many #HathaHaters you threw out there. Twitter offers some advice about using hashtags, but even if you follow it, the results just aren’t always there. Screen Shot 2013-04-01 at 12.56.49 PM

Bottom line: if you think you can go from 30 followers to 3,000 just through hashtags, it will likely take longer than you thought.

But that doesn’t mean you should abandon the precious pound sign. You just have to think of it less as a means to get more people to click “follow” and more of a self-expression thing.

The many types of hashtags

Not all Twitter hashtags exist for solely utilitarian purposes, of course. A whole culture of hashtagging has evolved since that first #. You don’t even have to use them earnestly. Sarcastic hashtagging is an art form:

Or you can do a run-on hashtag, which is the opposite of hashtagging every single word. Instead, just use a long phrase that no one would ever search for. It’s generally a completely inefficient search tool but it can be extremely entertaining, especially if you’re talking about Frasier:

 And sometimes people take hashtags and bring them into the real world, which is awkward for everybody. TV shows try to engage with viewers with hashtags all the time. And British soul singer Robin Thicke took hashtags off the Internet and onto his music video (which you’re watching again on the Internet, so … circle of life):

Even when you’re not on social media or the Internet, you’re not completely safe from hashtags. Like “BRB” and “LOL,” it’s starting to creep into actual conversations. And people might pretend it’s ironic when they say things like “hashtag TGIF” but they kind of mean it. 

The strange – yet effective – Instagram hashtag

Even though Twitter is undoubtedly the central hub for hashtags, Instagram has used them to great effect for awhile. And if you’re an average social media user, you will probably have a much easier time gaining followers with hashtags on Instagram for two reasons: One, when you search for a hashtag there, it’s much easier to scroll through photos and click and add users you like than it is to read lots of individual tweets about a topic.

Secondly, though Instagram’s user base is growing rapidly, right now it’s still substantially smaller than Twitter’s, so the amount of people using the same hashtag at once is more manageable. Perhaps if Instagram keeps expanding – which is likely – it will suffer from the same content bottleneck as Twitter, where there are too many users doing the same thing to get noticed. But right now, you’ll probably get more out of Instagram analytics service Nitrogram’s new hashtag feature than you would trying to find the right ones to use on Twitter.

You can now use Instagram on desktop, but if you do, you need to use a service like Statigram to search for hashtags and trending topics.

Instagram is now owned by Facebook and it’s not a little underground networking app anymore, so people use it to push products and brand themselves just like every other social network. But it still looks like the little, intimate photo-sharing app it once was, so it’s kind of startling to see people aggressively label their personal travel photos with 12 hashtags in a bid to get a higher follower count. And it’s a good reminder that people use every form of social media to push the agenda of building their brand. It might be nice if Instagram actually limited the amount of hashtags people can put on a photo to something smaller than 30, which is how many you can add now (30!?). Please, whatever you do, #stop #doing #this #followmebackpleaseseriouslyrightnow #garbage. This is just terrible:

dog hashtags

Google+ gets it right, but does anyone care?

Google+ lets its users tag their posts with hashtags, too, and even though people aren’t as active on G+ as they are on Twitter, it’s definitely the easiest hashtag experience because it comes with auto-complete, so you can see some of the hashtags people have used in the past. Since they’re boxed off, they’re less aesthetically jarring than the hashtags on Twitter, so you can get away with adding more at the end without looking spammy and play around with different variations.

google plus hashtag example

And while Google+ separates the posts into “Best of” and “Most recent” (similar to Twitter’s “Top” and “All” categories), the site design looks cleaner and integrates media better, so you can scroll through and pick out what you like from other random users more easily – which means they can do the same to you.

The future of the hashtag

Facebook recently announced it is optimizing for hashtags, which might be useful, but is also deeply unfortunate for those of us who like to make fun of everyone uselessly using it on the social network.

And even though Facebook doesn’t have hashtags yet, they’re still more exciting than Google+.

When Twitter users started adopting hashtags, it didn’t seem like the feature would work on Facebook – while Twitter focused on public updates, Facebook was more involved with communications between semi-closed social circles, so it seemed like hashtags wouldn’t work well there.

But Facebook is changing. Mark Zuckerberg wants it to be more like a personalized newspaper than a private message board, and since many companies, media, and public figures use Facebook as a place to post public messages, hashtags may work – and they may encourage users with strict privacy settings to change some of their posts to “public.” And since Facebook just introduced its Search Graph, it may also debut some interesting methods for pinpointing helpful hashtags in search. It would also mean the photos you push to Instagram with hashtags would become searchable.

Since Facebook’s hashtag implementation is still in development, we don’t know how it work exactly, but what is fairly clear is that they are meant to push us toward making more public updates – because a hashtag is only useful if it’s seen. They might even try something like automatically making a hashtagged post searchable to some extent.

Facebook’s hashtags are still in development, but other social networks are already adopting the feature. Flickr got hashtags last month – perhaps a way for the photo-sharing service to stay competitive with Instagram. And messaging app Path just got the feature as well, though its functionality will be curtailed because Path works kind of how Facebook used to, where people only share with smaller circles, not the general public.

However you feel about the hashtag, it certainly isn’t going anywhere. If you can’t take the over-hashtaggified tweets or the real-life use of the term, just remember that for all of the pound sign-saturation, it’s a very useful discovery tool. And when it comes to the social Web, you get what you give. 

Social Media

Facebook wants to help you find a mentor with its latest Groups feature

Facebook is designed for connecting to other people -- so why not mentors? Today, Facebook launched a program inside Groups that allows for two users to go through a mentorship program together.
Home Theater

Keep those albums sounding great by converting your vinyl to a digital format

There are all sorts of reasons for ripping records and storing them digitally, but what's the best way to do it? We cover the different types of equipment and software available for ripping records at any price in this guide.
Movies & TV

Latest 'John Wick 3' photo confirms the return of two powerful characters

The third installment of the wildly successful action series that stars Keanu Reeves as a deadly assassin forced out of retirement, John Wick 3: Parabellum, hits theaters in May 2019. Here's everything we know about the movie so far.

Spotify vs. Pandora: Which music streaming service is better for you?

Which music streaming platform is best for you? We pit Spotify versus Pandora, two mighty streaming services with on-demand music and massive catalogs, comparing every facet of the two services to help you decide which is best.

Marco? Polo! Let's explore the app known as the 'video walkie-talkie'

Marco Polo has been dubbed the "video walkie-talkie," but how does the video messaging app stack up against competitors like Snapchat and Instagram? From unique filters to personalized video messages, we explore the Marco Polo app.
Social Media

Facebook’s less cluttered friend list feeds are no more

Facebook friend feeds created a more curated news feed -- but not anymore. Facebook discontinued the feature, saying it wasn't widely used. The move will help the network focus on improving the news feed, the company says.

The numbers don’t lie: Facebook is faltering. So what will eventually replace it?

Facebook is faltering, and the data prove it. User growth is slowing, employee outlooks are dipping, and young people are looking elsewhere. But for Facebook to fail, an alternative must arise. Who will it be?

Starting a vlog? Here are the best cameras to buy

Any camera that shoots video can be used to vlog, but a few models stand out from the crowd thanks to superior image quality, ergonomics, and usability.

For Monaris, it’s a photography career launched on an iPhone and Instagram

On Instagram, she's known just as Monaris. But street photographer Paola Franqui has built a following largely with an iPhone and a smile. We sat down with her to talk photography, style, and Instagram, of course.
Social Media

Kids can now initiate a friend request on Messenger Kids by using a password

Facebook's messaging app for the under-13 crowd required parents, not kids, to initiate the process of adding a friend. Now kids can start the process by using a unique passphrase -- a feature that still requires parental approval.

The Nixplay Iris might just make digital picture frames cool again

The digital picture frame's popularity has fizzled because of time-consuming updates and low quality -- but can a Wi-Fi connected frame change that? The Nixplay Iris is an 8-inch smart digital picture frame that wireless updates photos.
Social Media

Instagram hackers are changing account info into Russian email addresses

Have you logged in to your Instagram lately? A hack circulating this month has Instagram users locked out of their accounts because a hacker changed all the profile data, according to a report.
Social Media

New deal suggests Facebook is looking to add sweet interactive tools for Live

Facebook now owns a company that specializes in creating interactive live video experiences with polls, viewer comments, and more. Vidpresso says the change will help it bring the interactive tools to more users.
Social Media

How to use Adobe Spark Post to spice up your social media images

Images are proven to get more likes than plain text -- but only if those images are good. Adobe Spark post is an AI-powered design program for non-designers. Here's how to use it to take your social media feeds to the next level.