Skip to main content

Tumblr makes its first appearance in the Supreme Court

A Tumblr account could change United States politics.

On October 8, Tumblr will come into play when the court hears McCutcheon v. Federal Election Commission. The case challenges campaign finance rules, and argues that limits on aggregate political contributions are unconstitutional. If the FEC loses, caps on political contributions could be lifted, and politicians could receive more donations directly. Like Citizens United, the case would flood politicians with money if McCutcheon wins. The Republican National Committee doesn’t see a problem with this, but anti-corruption activists do.

Recommended Videos

Lawrence Lessig, a political activist and well-known legal scholar, has turned his attention to curbing government corruption. Lessig believes lifting this ban would facilitate corruption. Working with the Constitutional Accountability Center, he is participating in this case as an outside expert. People who are not directly involved in a case can submit what is called an “amicus brief” to introduce valuable testimony to the court. 

As part of his amicus brief, Lessig submitted a Tumblr called “‘Corruption’ originally.” The blog showcases what the term “corruption” meant to the Founding Fathers. Many conservative court members, including Justice Scalia, are originalists, who believe in a strict interpretation of the constitution based on the words and intentions of the people who wrote it. Lessig believes the case hinges on the definition of corruption, since the campaign limits are in place to stop politicians from becoming swayed by their contributors. If he can convince the originalists that his definition of corruption will occur if they lift campaign finance limits, he could sway the court’s decision and impact U.S. politics.

corruption
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The Tumblr attempts to collect every mention of corruption by the people who framed the Constitution, like James Madison and Patrick Henry. In amassing this collection, Lessig hopes to prove to the court that these Framers had a more inclusive idea of corruption, one that would prohibit political contributions that made politicians dependent on their donors.

Lessig explains his rationale on his blog:

“If they look to the original meaning of “corruption,” they would see that they have no legitimate sanction for restricting the meaning of “corruption” to “quid pro quo” corruption alone (as some recent cases suggest at least some believe). And if they did not restrict it to “quid pro quo” corruption alone, then the regulation in McCutcheon, which limits aggregate contributions, could be justified: it’s purpose is to limit dependence upon large donors; that purpose is a perfect valid “anti-corruption” purpose, at least in the view of the Framers.”

The Supreme Court aren’t exactly the most plugged-in bunch — the youngest Justice, Elena Kagan, said they don’t really use email. So it will be interesting to see how they respond to Tumblr. Who knows? We may have Clarence Thomas reblogging #TCOT posts before we know it.

The Atlantic’s Robinson Meyer finds it fitting that Lessig used Tumblr in this instance, noting “Tumblr’s whole design ethos and structure may be a kind of intentional synecdoche for how discourse — scholarly, legal, hypertextual — works.” An astute observation, and if Scotus is receptive to Lessig’s amicus, this may not be the last of Tumblr the Supreme Court sees.

Kate Knibbs
Former Contributor
Kate Knibbs is a writer from Chicago. She is very happy that her borderline-unhealthy Internet habits are rewarded with a…
Bluesky finally adds a feature many had been waiting for
A blue sky with clouds.

Bluesky has been making a lot of progress in recent months by simplifying the process to sign up while at the same time rolling out a steady stream of new features.

As part of those continuing efforts, the social media app has just announced that users can now send direct messages (DMs).

Read more
Reddit just achieved something for the first time in its 20-year history
The Reddit logo.

Reddit’s on a roll. The social media platform has just turned a profit for the first time in its 20-year history, and now boasts a record 97.2 million daily active users, marking a year-over-year increase of 47%. A few times during the quarter, the figure topped 100 million, which Reddit CEO and co-founder Steve Huffman said in a letter to shareholders had been a “long-standing milestone” for the site.

The company, which went public in March, announced the news in its third-quarter earnings results on Tuesday.

Read more
Worried about the TikTok ban? This is how it might look on your phone
TikTok splash screen on an Android phone.

The US Supreme Court has decided to uphold a law that would see TikTok banned in the country on January 19. Now, the platform has issued an official statement, confirming that it will indeed shut down unless it gets some emergency relief from the outgoing president.

“Unless the Biden Administration immediately provides a definitive statement to satisfy the most critical service providers assuring non-enforcement, unfortunately TikTok will be forced to go dark on January 19,” said the company soon after the court’s verdict.
So, what does going dark mean?
So, far, there is no official statement on what exactly TikTok means by “going dark.” There is a lot of speculation out there on how exactly the app or website will look once TikTok shutters in the US.

Read more