Skip to main content

A rift in the Rift: Why room-scale VR is about to split Oculus fans apart

While Oculus’ Touch controllers may not find their way into homes until the end of 2016, we’ve already been spending time with them, and have been impressed with their consistently sharp tracking and intuitive gesture and action controls. But Oculus has a big problem on its hands. With the standard two-camera configuration, the touch controllers only work when you’re facing forward. Once the headset is on, it’s hard to tell which way forward is.

The result can be unsettling. Turn around too far, and your hands will disappear, stick in place, or drift off in random directions. That’s in stark contrast to the HTC Vive, which sports a full 360 degrees of motion and control.

To solve that, Oculus has introduced a compromise. Setup a total of three constellation trackers – two in front, one behind – and you’re off and rolling in full, 360-degree room-scale. Except it’s not quite that simple.

What took so long?

There are two sides to every story, and that’s certainly true with Rift and room-scale.

The Oculus answer to questions about its lack of room-scale has always been simple – it’s not something users want to do. Clearing everything from a room except a computer desk and a tripod is a luxury that most people don’t have. According to a quote from Oculus founder Palmer Luckey obtained by Road to VR back in December of 2015, “You have people who have PCs that are powerful enough to run VR (or willing to buy one), then of that set, people who are interested in virtual reality.” Instead of trying to chase a market that might not exist, Oculus is first focusing on just putting headsets on faces.

There are two sides to every story, and that’s certainly true with Rift and room-scale.

To be fair, that’s a perfectly reasonable assumption. But it isn’t the whole story. The other major reason the Rift isn’t designed for room-scale VR is a technical limitation.

The Vive’s Lighthouse trackers are wireless. They send timing information back to the system as they blast the area with IR rays, and the headset and controllers have sensors that see those lines and report back their location to the computer. The Rift uses the opposite approach, with IR tags on the headset and controllers that the cameras see and send to the system. That means the Constellation trackers included with the Rift require a wired connection, and a fast one.

Why it won’t work

We’ve found that adding your own physical locomotion to the VR experience is a big deal for immersion, and it helps prevent nausea. But outside of a few games that have already been developed with room-scale in mind for the HTC Vive, like Job Simulator or Fantastic Contraption, it’s bound to fail. Luckey himself explains why in the very same interview.

“[Developers] don’t want to narrow it then down to people who want to clear out large spaces in their homes […] Most of the developers we’ve talked to don’t want to limit their beyond a subset of a subset of users.”

Luckey didn’t like the idea of room-scale VR because it meant splitting the user base. And that’s exactly what Oculus is now doing.

While many Rift owners will shell out $199 for the touch controllers, which include a second camera, there are some who won’t. That’s the first subset of Rift owners. Then, Oculus is charging $79 for an extra camera – not an unreasonable asking price at all, but one that a lot of users won’t bother with. That creates a third sub-set of users.

Suddenly, we have three categories of Rift owners, each of whom have a Rift with different capabilities. Developers are faced with a tough choice. They can either design for everyone, and drastically limit the experience. Or they can design for the more limited subsets of owners with Touch, or room-scale, and risk crippling their sales.

The way the news goes

It’s reminiscent of the Xbox Kinect. It was a well-intentioned peripheral with advanced capabilities, but without a large user base to draw from, few developers were tempted to build games or experiences that utilized it, much less relied on it. Had Microsoft included it at a low price as part of the Xbox 360 eco-system, it might have caught on. By adding it well into the Xbox 360’s life, and charging a high price, Microsoft hobbled Kinect before it had a chance.

Room-scale’s positive effect on the Touch controller can’t be overstated.

Oculus is staring down the barrel of the same virtual gun. A subset, of a subset, of a subset of users will have the time and space for room-scale, after a year of telling potential adopters that it’s a feature they don’t want. When they finally set it up and realize few games on the Rift store support it, they’ll warn fellow Rift users not to bother. And less room-scale owners means less developers working on games that support it.

Which is not to say that isn’t the right move for Oculus. The lack of 360-degree support only becomes more obvious as SteamVR games leverage the Vive’s unified hardware base, and its positive effect on the Touch controller experience can’t be overstated. But whether developers bother to enable Touch support in Rift games remains to be seen.

Editors' Recommendations

Brad Bourque
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Brad Bourque is a native Portlander, devout nerd, and craft beer enthusiast. He studied creative writing at Willamette…
HP Envy deals: HP’s most popular laptop starts at $630
An HP Envy 17-inch laptop sits on an office desk.

A great computer brand to shop if you’re in the market for a new laptop is HP, which is consistently among the best laptop brands. It has several different model lineups to choose from, with the HP Envy laptop lineup offering a good balance of hardware options and pricing. The HP Envy lineup is also a good one to shop because it regularly turns out some impressive laptop deals. That’s certainly the case right now, as there are a lot of HP Envy deals to shop. We’ve rounded up what we feel are the best HP Envy deals currently taking place, so read onward for more information on how to land some savings.
HP Envy x360 2-in-1 laptop 15Z-FH000 — $630, was $900

The HP Envy x360 convertible laptop is a great option for just about anyone, particularly anyone who enjoys the touchscreen functionality of a tablet. It’s well designed and super slim, making it a truly go-anywhere device. Despite its portability, it still has an immersive 15.6-inch touchscreen that’s great for creators, note-takers, and binge watchers. Top notch build quality and durability, fast charging technology, a fingerprint reader, and great battery life round out the top features of the HP Envy x360 convertible touchscreen laptop. It competes well with the best 2-in-1 laptops. Its versatility and all-around capability make it a worthy companion on any desk, and on any lap.

Read more
Best Surface Laptop and Surface Pro deals: From $450
Microsoft Surface Go 3 sitting on table.

If you want a thin and light laptop that's similar to the MacBook Air but not in the Apple ecosystem, then the Microsoft Surface lineup of laptops is absolutely the way to go. In fact, if you've seen the recent unwrapping of the business version of the Surface Pro 10 and Surface Laptop 6, you might be fired up and ready to grab your own surface. Unfortunately, the Surface lineup can be quite expensive, which is why we've gone out and scoured the retailers for the best deals we could find and collected them below. So, be sure to check out everything, as well as some of these other great laptop deals if you aren't fully committed to the Microsoft Surface lineup.
Microsoft Surface Go 3 -- $450, was $550

Functioning as a 2-in-1 laptop that can switch between tablet mode and laptop mode, the Microsoft Surface Go 3 won't have trouble dealing with basic tasks as it's equipped with the Intel Pentium Gold 6500Y processor and 8GB of RAM. The 10.5-inch touchscreen with 1920 x 1080 resolution is bright and colorful, and its 128GB SSD is more than enough for your documents. The Microsoft Surface Go 3 ships with Windows 11 Home in Mode, so you can start using it as soon as you unbox it. The device also promises up to 11 hours of battery life before requiring a recharge.

Read more
Best GPU deals: MSI, XFX, EVGA
An AMD graphics card in an external GPU enclosure.

If you're building a new PC from scratch, or upgrading an old one, then a new GPU is probably one of the biggest upgrades you can make, at least if you're looking for great gaming performance. Unfortunately, the last generation of RTX 40-series cards really amped the prices up, and even if you're going for AMD, you're going to be paying a pretty penny to get your hands on a good GPU. That said, there are some good deals to be had; whether you want something budget-friendly or high-end, you can always put that extra money you save into more RAM or a better CPU. Also, be sure to check out some of these gaming PC deals if you'd rather just grab something already pre-built.
MSI AMD Radeon RX 6500 XT Mech 2X 4GB GDDR6 -- $175, was $190

If you're looking for something that is ultra-budget, then this RX 6500 XT is a good option in the lower range and should let you handle at least some of the main free-to-play games like CS:GO and Rocket League, although you will have to play with graphical compromises. It should also handle indie and casual games, especially older ones like the ones you might find on emulators, so it's also a good option for that sort of budget build. the 4GB of VRAM is not a lot, but again, if you're not planning to play any modern AAA or AA games, then this isn't a bad option.

Read more