Consumer Reports still believes in the accuracy of the Fitbit

FitBit Surge
Bill Roberson/Digital Trends
The public may not be on Fitbit’s side, but Consumer Reports sure is. Following a class-action lawsuit filed against the health tracker by consumer plaintiffs in California, Colorado, and Wisconsin, the well-regarded outlet retested the devices in their labs, and determined, “Both the Fitbit Charge HR and Fitbit Surge passed our tests handily, accurately recording heart rates at everything from a leisurely walk up to a fast run.” This, of course, is a far cry from the experiences everyday users have noted, with many accusing Fitbit of providing faulty heart rate data, particularly during more intense exercise.

Fitbit has already disputed these claims, stating that the company “strongly disagrees with the statements made in the complaint,” and further noting that its heart rate technology, known as PurePulse, “provides better overall heart rate tracking than cardio machines at the gym.” Even so, the wearables company further reminded users that its devices are not replacements for medical devices, nor are they intended to be employed as scientific monitors.

According to the lawsuit, certain models of the Fitbit provided vastly inaccurate information when subjects engaged in strenuous exercise. “We went and had a board-certified cardiologist put some folks through different levels of exercise and test the different models,” said Jonathan Selbin, the lead partner for the plaintiffs’ law firm. “And, sure enough, particularly at high intensity levels, they are wildly inaccurate,” to the tune of 24.34 beats per minute (bpm). In extreme cases, the Fitbit data differed by 75 bpm.

But this simply was not the case when Consumer Reports ran its own parallel test. Both a male and female volunteer ran on a treadmill with a Polar H7 (a monitor with well-proven accuracy) strapped to their chests. They also each wore the Fitbit Charge HR and Fitbit Surge, one right on the wrist, and the other a few inches higher.

“For our new test, we recorded our subjects’ heart rates at four levels of intensity: at rest, a walking pace (110 bpm), a jogging pace (130 bpm), and a running pace (150 bpm),” Patrick Austin of Consumer Reports writes. “All tests were conducted twice. A total of 64 heart rate measurements were recorded.”

Ultimately, the outlet determined, “The new testing confirmed our earlier results: Both the Charge HR and Surge were very accurate when compared to the reference Polar H7 ECG monitor. During nearly every trial, the variance between the chest strap and the Fitbit devices amounted to no more than three heartbeats per minute.”

There was, however, one notable exception, and it had to do with where the Fitbit was worn. When the female volunteer wore the Charge HR on her wrist and began the more strenuous portion of the test, the Fitbit was indeed off by a wider margin. “During one run, when the chest strap read 150 bpm, the Fitbit Charge HR read 144 bpm,” Austin said. “During the second run, the device read only 139 bpm.”

That said, this was no longer an issue when the Charge was worn on her forearm, and the Fitbit Surge showed itself to be fairly consistent regardless of where it was on the body.

So there you have it, friends. According to a lab test of two individuals, the Fitbit seems perfectly fine. But if you’re having issues, maybe try moving your device up a few inches, and then see where things stand.

Product Review

Montblanc Summit 2 offers smart functionality but still looks good with a suit

Montblanc’s Summit 2 is the first smartwatch to use Qualcomm’s Snapdragon Wear 3100 processor. It’s feature packed, with GPS, NFC for Google Pay, and a heart rate sensor, but it also has the classic timepiece look.

These fitness deals come just in time to work off those holiday calories

Finding the motivation to work out is one thing. Finding space at home to get in a few sets and reps can be an entire challenge in itself. Luckily for you, Walmart and Amazon both have space saving fitness machines and tools on sale right…

Crush your next workout with the best Fitbit for every activity

Fitbits are amazingly helpful tools for setting fitness goals and tracking progress. However, different activities require different metrics. We've gathered a list of the best Fitbits for running, swimming, biking, and other activities.

The best Apple Watch deals for December 2018

The Apple Watch has surged to prominence in recent years. If you're in the market for an iOS wearable, we've sniffed out the best Apple Watch deals available right now for all three models of this great smartwatch.

Built to take a beating and still perform, these are the best hiking watches

A proper hiking watch should track exercise metrics and act as a navigational co-pilot during any kind of hike. Ideally, it'll even have a built-in GPS system and sensors. Here are five of the best hiking watches.

Beddit Sleep Monitor 3.5 now available on the Apple Store

The Beddit Sleep Monitor 3.5 is now available on the Apple Store for $150. The sensor strip, which is only 2 millimeters thin, automatically tracks a wide array of sleep data when placed under the user's sheets.
Emerging Tech

Awesome Tech You Can’t Buy Yet: Folding canoes and ultra-fast water filters

Check out our roundup of the best new crowdfunding projects and product announcements that hit the web this week. You may not be able to buy this stuff yet, but it sure is fun to gawk!

Conquer the cold season with the best heated clothing and outdoor apparel

If you're thinking about going outside this winter, heated apparel is a must. Luckily, we've rounded up some of the best heated clothing, whether you're looking for battery-powered gloves or heated insoles.

Check out the best Green Monday deals for those last-minute gifts

Black Friday and Cyber Monday have come and gone, but that doesn't mean you've missed your chance of finding a great deal. We're talking about Green Monday, of course, and it falls on December 10.

Google Fit app finally gets a widget, among other new features

Google Fit hasn't received any new features since its redesign. This week, the company is rolling some new tools; users will be able to add a widget to their Android home screen, adjust the intensity of their workouts, and more.

Best Products of 2018

Our reception desk has so many brown boxes stacked up, it looks like a loading dock. We’re on a first-name basis with the UPS guy. We get new dishwashers more frequently than most people get new shoes. What we’re trying to say is: We…

New Apple Watch begins saving lives one week after getting EKG feature

The Apple Watch Series 4 was updated almost a week ago with a new feature that allows users to take electrocardiogram tests -- and already it seems like the new feature is saving lives.

These are the best smartwatches for everything from fashion to fitness

Tempted to buy a smartwatch? If so, then the growing number of great models available means you've got plenty to choose from. But which one should you pick? Here is our list of the best smartwatches.

How to use the ECG app, set up irregular rhythm notifications on the Apple Watch

The Apple Watch Series 4 is the best smartwatch iPhone owners can own, and it just got even better with the addition of the ECG app and ability to identify irregular heart rhythms. Here's how to set it all up.