Arizona ‘cyberbullying’ bill threatens free speech online, critics warn


Bullying has suddenly shot to the forefront of American politics, and has simmered into a hotbed of recent discussion. The debate has become so widespread that it has motivated Arizona’s lawmakers to take action. Unfortunately, critics say the state may have just unleashed one of the worst Internet censorship bills in American history.

On Thursday, the Arizona legislation passed amendments to Arizona House Bill 2549, sending the bill to the governor’s desk for approval or veto. The controversial amendments revise the state’s telephone harassment law to apply to a wide variety of crude language transmitted over “any electronic or digital communications.” Of course, this category includes landline phones, mobile phones, television, tablets, radio and, yes, the Internet.

The amended part of H.B. 2549 reads as follows:

“It is unlawful for any person, with intent to terrify, intimidate, threaten, harass, annoy or offend, to use a telephone ANY ELECTRONIC OR DIGITAL DEVICE and use any obscene, lewd or profane language or suggest any lewd or lascivious act, or threaten to inflict physical harm to the person or property of any person. It is also unlawful to otherwise disturb by repeated anonymous telephone calls ELECTRONIC OR DIGITAL COMMUNICATIONS the peace, quiet or right of privacy of any person at the place where the telephone call or calls COMMUNICATIONS were received.”

The bill’s effort is perhaps good-intentioned — but it’s also woefully flawed. Yes, cyberbullying has time and again been at the crux of countless teenage suicide cases, with many occurring on social networking sites, including Facebook, Twitter and Myspace. But if you look at the bill closely, it’s a jarringly ill-constructed form of legislation, riddled with holes. Due to the bill’s broadness, critics warn that it can be used implicate just about anyone who uses “lewd or profane language,” or says anything that is intended to “terrify, intimidate, threaten, harass, annoy, or offend” anyone over an electronic communication. In short, this could make much of the things people say online illegal in the state of Arizona.

If passed, the legislation will apply to any implicating language that was sent or posted in the state of Arizona, or directed at an individual in the state of Arizona. While it is most likely that authorities will only pursue cases where individuals are maliciously targeted, a growing chorus of critics argue that the bill’s broad language poses a threat to the First Amendment, which provides US citizens with a Freedom of Religion, Freedom of the Press, and Freedom of Expression. The bill is worded so dangerously, in fact, that even organizations that supported the contentious Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA) and the PROTECT IP Act (PIPA) have come out against the legislation.

“Speech protected by the First Amendment is often intended to offend, annoy or scare but could be prosecuted under this law,” wrote Media Coalition, a group backed by the MPAA and the RIAA, in a letter to Arizona Governor Jan Brewer (pdf). “When a Danish newspaper posted pictures of Muhammad, they were intended to be offensive to Muslims to make a point about religion but this could be a crime if a Muslim in Arizona viewed the pictures online and considered them profane.” 

Media Coalition goes on to explain that a near-infinite number of comments could fall under the bill’s definition of unlawful language, from books promoting religion or atheism, to the comments of entertainers like Rush Limbaugh or Jon Stewart.

“While protecting people from harassment is a worth goal,” the letter reads, “legislators cannot do so by criminalizing speech protected by the Constitution.”

Considering the uproar that surrounded  PIPA and SOPA, it’s entirely possible that the bill will end up back in the hands of legislatures. But even if it doesn’t, some experts believe that the law would be essentially unenforceable, and therefore, meaningless.

Janet Sternberg, a professor of communications and media studies at Fordham University, believes that such an attempt by lawmakers is, in fact, a ‘moot point.’

“Anything that relates to the Internet in trying to enforce things, and this is a state attempt, is unenforceable,” Sternberg told Digital Trends. “This is the pattern we’ve seen from any real effect from legal action regarding anything that happens on the Internet. The only people who are going to be happy about this are the lawyers because they get paid by the hour.”

We’re just amazed about just how lackadaisical lawmakers are to have edited a bill intended for telephones in this day and age when our means of communication has not been restricted to telephones for over two decades. 

[Image via Mark Hayes/Shutterstock]

Edit: The correct spelling of the Fordham University professor’s last name is “Sternberg,” not “Steinberg.” The correction has been reflected in the article.


Google honors Veterans Day by highlighting military service stories

For Veterans Day, Google is honoring the heroes that served the country with a new Google Doodle that highlights the stories of five veterans from the five different branches of the military.
Movies & TV

The best movies on Amazon Prime right now (November 2018)

Prime Video provides subscribers with access to a host of fantastic films, but sorting through the catalog can be an undertaking. Luckily, we've done the work for you. Here are the best movies on Amazon Prime Video right now.

How to change your Gmail password in just a few quick steps

Regularly updating your passwords is a good way to stay secure online, but each site and service has their own way of doing it. Here's a quick guide on how to change your Gmail password in a few short steps.

Need a free alternative to Adobe Illustrator? Here are our favorites

Photoshop and other commercial tools can be expensive, but drawing software doesn't need to be. This list of the best free drawing software is just as powerful as some of the more expensive offerings.

Edit, sign, append, and save with 12 of the best PDF editors

There are plenty of PDF editors to be had online, and though the selection is robust, finding a solid solution with the tools you need can be tough. Here, we've rounded up best PDF editors, so you can edit no matter your budget or OS.
Emerging Tech

Alibaba’s Singles’ Day sale smashes online shopping records

The annual online shopping frenzy that is Singles' Day this year raked in $30.8 billion, up from $25 billion last time around. The Alibaba-organized event generates more in sales than Black Friday and Cyber Monday combined.

Apple to boost its Amazon presence with listings for iPhones, iPads, and more

Apple is about to start offering more of its kit on Amazon. The tech giant currently only has very limited listings on the shopping site, but the deal will see the arrival of the latest iPhones, iPads, MacBooks, and more.

If you've lost a software key, these handy tools can find it for you

Missing product keys getting you down? We've chosen some of the best software license and product key finders in existence, so you can locate and document your precious keys on your Windows or MacOS machine.

Will Chrome remain our favorite web browser with the arrival of newest version?

Choosing a web browser for surfing the web can be tough with all the great options available. Here we pit the latest versions of Chrome, Opera, Firefox, Edge, and Vivaldi against one another to find the best browsers for most users.

Zoom in on famous works through the Art Institute of Chicago’s new website

Art lovers, listen up. The Art Institute of Chicago has given its website a serious makeover with new features that let you get up close and personal with more than 50,000 artworks by famous (and not so famous) artists.

Over a million veterans now eligible for Comcast’s Internet Essentials program

Comcast's low-cost Internet Essentials program, which provides internet access for just $10 per month, has expanded to include U.S. veterans. One million veterans now qualify for the service.

Google’s Squoosh will get an image web-ready with in-browser compression

Google's latest web app development is an image editing and compression tool, Squoosh. In just a few clicks, it can take a huge image and make it much lighter and web-friendly, all in your browser.

Want to save a webpage as a PDF? Just follow these steps

Need to quickly save and share a webpage? The best way is to learn how to save a webpage as a PDF file, as they're fully featured and can handle images and text with ease. Here's how.
Social Media

‘Superwoman’ YouTuber Lilly Singh taking a break for her mental health

Claiming to be "mentally, physically, emotionally, and spiritually exhausted," popular YouTuber Lilly Singh has told her millions of fans she's taking a break from making videos in order to recuperate.