Wikipedia editors are at war with paid PR ‘sockpuppets’

wikipedia text adventure game

Wikipedia editors have quietly gone to war this week with a company that promises to make its clients look good on the Internet’s encyclopedia.

The casualties so far include some 250 so-called “sockpuppet” users linked to the firm Wiki-PR. The users were banned for allegedly taking money to write and edit Wikipedia articles and for violating other site policies, according to the Wikipedia Foundation.

“Our readers know Wikipedia’s not perfect, but they also know that it has their best interests at heart, and is never trying to sell them a product or propagandize them in any way,” wrote Sue Gardner, executive director of the Wikipedia Foundation, in a blog post. “Our goal is to provide neutral, reliable information for our readers, and anything that threatens that is a serious problem.”

The Wikipedia Foundation’s response follows in-depth reports from The Daily Dot and Vice, both of which delved into Wiki-PR’s services. The company offers page creation and editing, page management, and other related services that stand up to “the scrutiny of Wikipedia’s community rules and guidelines.” According to Vice, one client paid Wiki-PR $1,500 to write and publish an entry about him on Wikipedia – and would have been charged another $800 for 30 days of “media relations efforts” offered by a related company, Scarsdale Media, had he taken the offer. Other clients paid up to $1000 for Wiki-PR’s services, reports The Daily Dot.

In an email to the Wall Street Journal, Wiki-PR CEO Jordan Michael French characterized his company as a “research and writing firm” that provides “paid editing” but “not paid advocacy.”

“We’re as boring as any other research firm,” writes French. “The ‘PR’ in Wiki-PR is a misnomer – we’re a research and writing firm. We counsel our clients on how to adhere to Wikipedia’s rules.”

Wikipedia’s rules are vast and all-encompassing. Its official “Policies and Guidelines” page, however, does not explicitly prohibit article promotion. For that, users must examine its “What Wikipedia is not” page, which forbids “advocacy,” “opinion pieces,” “scandal mongering,” “self-promotion,” and “advertising, marketing, or public relations” articles.

Members of the public relations industry have condemned Wiki-PR’s practices as counter productive. The UK-based PR industry group Chartered Institute of Public Relations (CIPR) says Wiki-PR services provide “zero gain” for the PR industry and its clients alike.

“There is zero gain to be had for any public relations firms or their clients in subverting the rules of any online community,” said Stephen Waddington, president of CIPR, in a statement. “Wikipedia’s rules on editing are clear. Paid-for advocates and those with a clear conflict of interest should not directly edit Wikipedia for an article for their client or employer.”

Wikipedia bans most – but not all – forms of paid editing. A common example of allowed paid editing is a university professor who, as part of her job, edits a Wikipedia article to expertly distill the findings of a recent relevant study. What’s not allowed is paid editors changing articles for promotional purposes – something Gardner describes as “extremely problematic.” 

“We consider it a ‘black hat’ practice,” wrote Gardner. “Paid advocacy editing violates the core principles that have made Wikipedia so valuable for so many people.”

The fight against Wiki-PR and any other paid “sockpuppets” highlights Wikipedia’s never-ending struggle to be a reliable source of relevant encyclopedic information. A 2005 study found Wikipedia’s peer-edited articles to be as trustworthy as Britannica print encyclopedias, the standard-bearer at the time. Britannica, which published new editions of its encyclopedia for 244 years, officially stopped printing physical volumes in 2012, due in part to competition from Wikipedia.

Updated with comment from CIPR and additional information about Wikipedia’s paid editing guidelines (10/23).


iPhone users are finding themselves randomly locked out of their Apple ID

According to posts on Reddit and Twitter, it looks like users on Reddit and Twitter having some issues with their Apple accounts. Specifically, it seems as though users are getting randomly locked out of their Apple IDs.

From Rolls-Royce to Lamborghini, these are the most expensive cars in the world

If you recently discovered an oil reserve in your backyard, you probably have some extra cash to spend. Look no further, because we’ve rounded up the most expensive cars in the world.

Data stolen from HealthCare.gov includes partial SSNs and immigration status

Around 75,000 users have had their user data stolen from government site healthcare.gov, including information on their immigration status, whether they were pregnant, and partial social security numbers.

The vast majority of YouTube users hit the site for how-to videos

Ever searched for a how-to video on YouTube? Of course you have. The streaming site is bursting with useful guides on how to do stuff, and a recent study has revealed that more users than ever are using it as a learning resource.

How to change your Gmail password in just a few quick steps

Regularly updating your passwords is a good way to stay secure online, but each site and service has their own way of doing it. Here's a quick guide on how to change your Gmail password in a few short steps.

Need a free alternative to Adobe Illustrator? Here are our favorites

Photoshop and other commercial tools can be expensive, but drawing software doesn't need to be. This list of the best free drawing software is just as powerful as some of the more expensive offerings.

Google honors Veterans Day by highlighting military service stories

For Veterans Day, Google is honoring the heroes that served the country with a new Google Doodle that highlights the stories of five veterans from the five different branches of the military.

Edit, sign, append, and save with 12 of the best PDF editors

There are plenty of PDF editors to be had online, and though the selection is robust, finding a solid solution with the tools you need can be tough. Here, we've rounded up best PDF editors, so you can edit no matter your budget or OS.
Emerging Tech

Alibaba’s Singles’ Day sale smashes online shopping records

The annual online shopping frenzy that is Singles' Day this year raked in $30.8 billion, up from $25 billion last time around. The Alibaba-organized event generates more in sales than Black Friday and Cyber Monday combined.

Apple to boost its Amazon presence with listings for iPhones, iPads, and more

Apple is about to start offering more of its kit on Amazon. The tech giant currently only has very limited listings on the shopping site, but the deal will see the arrival of the latest iPhones, iPads, MacBooks, and more.

If you've lost a software key, these handy tools can find it for you

Missing product keys getting you down? We've chosen some of the best software license and product key finders in existence, so you can locate and document your precious keys on your Windows or MacOS machine.

Will Chrome remain our favorite web browser with the arrival of newest version?

Choosing a web browser for surfing the web can be tough with all the great options available. Here we pit the latest versions of Chrome, Opera, Firefox, Edge, and Vivaldi against one another to find the best browsers for most users.

Zoom in on famous works through the Art Institute of Chicago’s new website

Art lovers, listen up. The Art Institute of Chicago has given its website a serious makeover with new features that let you get up close and personal with more than 50,000 artworks by famous (and not so famous) artists.

Over a million veterans now eligible for Comcast’s Internet Essentials program

Comcast's low-cost Internet Essentials program, which provides internet access for just $10 per month, has expanded to include U.S. veterans. One million veterans now qualify for the service.