Skip to main content

YouTube changes its tune, will now defend select channels against DMCA takedowns

youtube videos 2015 popular on a tablet
Image used with permission by copyright holder
YouTube has announced a new plan to protect content creators hit by copyright takedown requests that don’t check for fair use. The new plan will compensate channels up to $1 million in legal fees and will keep the video live while court proceedings take place.

This is the first move by the Google-owned video service to make channels feel more comfortable using content from other sources under the Fair Use Act.

In the past, content creators hit with a Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) takedown would have to fund their own legal team, and the video would be taken offline until a court issued a favorable ruling. Three DMCA takedown requests result in YouTube blocking the channel — forcing some content creators away from more controversial topics.

YouTube will get in touch with any channel it suspects has been wronged by a DMCA claim, but not all channels will receive legal protection. And the videos will only remain active in the U.S., meaning most of the world will be unable to see the video regardless of the legal outcome.

YouTube will also add all active videos hit with DMCA takedown requests into its ‘Copyright Center,’ where content creators and copyright holders can get an idea about what types of content are permitted on the video service.

“We’re doing this because we recognize that creators can be intimidated by the DMCA’s counter notification process, and the potential for litigation that comes with it,” said YouTube in a blog post.

The move follows a lawsuit against Universal Music Group (UMG) by the Electronic Frontier Foundation and Stephanie Lenz. A 29-second video of Lenz’s child dancing to Prince song Let’s Go Crazy in 2007 was caught by UMG’s content ID system, which pressed for the video to be removed from YouTube. The court case was settled earlier this year, with a federal district court confirming that Universal must look into fair use before sending a DMCA takedown.

Plenty of commentators have called for a more robust content ID system on YouTube, and a less restrictive ruleset regarding copyright. While this new legal protection isn’t a rule change, it shows that YouTube will assert itself in some cases to defend the rights of content creators against overzealous organizations.

Editors' Recommendations

David Curry
Former Digital Trends Contributor
David has been writing about technology for several years, following the latest trends and covering the largest events. He is…
Multiview almost fixes one of the biggest problems with YouTube TV
Three college football games (and one ad) seen on a large TV on YouTube TV.

Flipping through the myriad college football games on a recent weekend, I was struck by a revelation: Multiview on YouTube TV — even in its imperfect, inflexible form — nearly fixes one of my biggest gripes about the leading live streaming platform.

The "problem" really isn't a problem insofar as anything is actually broken. It's just the way YouTube TV works, and it's almost certainly something done by design. If you're a habitual channel-flipper, you already know full well how streaming services like YouTube TV, Hulu With Live TV, and other options aren't exactly known for making it quick to fly through the channels, one after another.

Read more
YouTube TV in 4K: Everything you need to know
YouTube TV 4K streams settings and user options.

When it comes to streaming live TV in the U.S. (or streaming any kind of video anywhere, for that matter), resolution and bit rate remain as important as ever. And you're now able to enjoy YouTube TV in 4K. Some of it, at least. And if it seems like it's taken forever for that to happen, you're not wrong.

The basic fact is that it takes a lot of bandwidth to stream video — and that's even more difficult when you're talking linear TV, (and more so still if it's a live event like sports). So it's not really that much of a surprise to learn that most live channels stream at 720p resolution — or maybe 1080p if you're lucky. (We'll leave frame rate out of the equation for a minute, but it's a thing, too, especially for sports.)

Read more
YouTube with a blank home screen is a beautiful place
The YouTube app on an iPhone.

I knew it was coming, but it still came as a little bit of a surprise. I opened the YouTube app on my phone and was greeted by … nothing. No Mr. Beast, a video creator whose videos I have never watched -- and never will. No tech tips from an overcaffeinated Peanuts character. (I think. Given my advanced age and inability to find entertainment value in someone trying to sell me something, I may not have that quite right.) No random recipes from someone who somehow managed to hide a full kitchen just off camera in the middle of the woods and preps ingredients using only a hand-carved stone hatchet.

This is YouTube without recommendations. And it is wonderful.

Read more