Crossover conundrum: Should cars be good at everything, or great at one thing?

Range Rover Evoke

What happens when you combine the chassis of a car, the body of an SUV, and (sometimes) the seating flexibility of a minivan? You get a crossover, a vehicle with utility that puts Humvees and Firefly-class transports to shame.

By combining the most useful attributes of many vehicle types, the crossover has become the de facto family car, replacing sedans, station wagons, minivans, and traditional SUVs. It’s all-wheel drive also makes it popular with people looking to live a more “rugged” lifestyle.

That all sounds very nice, but there are drawbacks. Like a Swiss Army Knife (or even a smartphone), a crossover combines several formerly discrete functions, but it can’t necessarily perform those functions as well as vehicles designed with a singular purpose.

So, is it better to have a car that can do many things well, or a car that can do one thing perfectly?

First, the good news

What makes crossovers so appealing in the first place? For the answer to that question, we have to go back to the 1990s.

In 1990, Ford came out with the Explorer, which unleashed a flood of SUVs. People loved their high driving positions, four-wheel drive, and the utility that came with those boxy bodies. They were also much cooler than any Chrysler Town & Country or Toyota Camry. A lot cooler.

There were a few drawbacks, though. Because traditional SUVs are based on trucks, they tend to ride and handle like trucks. They also have the fuel economy of trucks, guzzling down gas with wanton abandon.

Enter the crossover, a vehicle with the jacked-up ride height and styling of an SUV, the civility of a car, and reasonable fuel economy. By placing an SUV-like body on the chassis of a normal sedan, carmakers hoped to create the best of both worlds.

At first, crossovers were disguised as truck-based SUVs to satisfy people’s desire to have a vehicle that could maintain the rugged image of an off-roader. The original Honda CRV may have had a spare tire on its tailgate, but it was actually based on the Civic. Soon, however, they began taking on new and distinct shapes. Some, like the Range Rover Evoque, have virtually no stylistic ties to their off-roading forebears.

The crossover was also a boon for luxury manufacturers looking to cash in on the SUV craze without sacrificing their brands’ reputations for refinement. The Range Rover was arguably the first luxury SUV, but the Mercedes-Benz M-Class took the concept mainstream.

Today, the vast majority of SUVs are crossovers, but the development of this segment isn’t stopping there. BMW is on its way to creating a parallel lineup of crossovers in multiple sizes, complementing its luxury sedans. It’s even developed the X4 and X6 “coupes” to fill the roster. Mercedes looks to be following suit with its compact GLA concept, and a rumored coupe version of the GLK.

BMW X5 on a beachThe difference

However, stuffing the qualities of many vehicles into one box means that box has to be pretty big. When it comes to cars, that’s never a good thing.

People love a crossover’s high driving position because it gives them a commanding view of the road, but it also creates a high center of gravity. That means that, while crossovers may offer smooth rides, these sport-utilities are rarely sporty.

It’s a simple matter of physics: a crossover is heavier than a conventional car, and that weight is carried higher off the ground. Even performance oriented vehicles like the Porsche Cayenne can’t defeat Isaac Newton. Now a zombie Isaac Newton might be a different story …

The difference is especially stark in the luxury segment. BMW, Mercedes, and Audi build some of the best handling sedans around, but that liveliness does not translate to their crossovers.

The same is true of most crossovers’ styling. There are a few lookers out there, like the Evoque, but many crossovers suffer from an awkward mix of familial styling cues stretched over a too-large frame.

The Audi A6 and A7 are great looking cars, but the Q5 and Q7 are not. BMW’s X1, X3, and X5 look freakish compared to the restrained 3 Series and 5 Series.

In the ‘90s, SUVs at least had some character compared to the cookie cutter sedans of the time. Now that carmakers have figured out how to style their cars again, having a bodacious body isn’t an advantage in the looks department.

Crossover buyers can also expect a small drop in fuel economy. A 2013 BMW 535i with xDrive all-wheel drive gets 21 mpg city, 30 mpg highway, and 24 mpg combined. A 2013 BMW X5 with the same 3.0-liter turbocharged inline-six returns 16 mpg city, 23 mpg highway, and 19 mpg combined.

BMW 328i wagon front three quarterAlternatives

It’s interesting that crossovers like the BMW X4 or Range Rover Evoque are being used to exploit new market niches, because they’ve eliminated a virtual galaxy of car types in their rise to dominance. So what should you buy if you don’t want a crossover?

For the brutally practical, the minivan is the best choice for hauling people. They’re roomier than most midsize crossovers, more fuel efficient than most large ones, and they’re easy to get in and out of.

However, buyers looking for a luxury car need not apply: you won’t find a minivan wearing a premium badge. They’re also terminally uncool.

If you need to tow something, or live somewhere that doesn’t have roads, there are still a few traditional, truck-based SUVs on the market. However, they tend to be gigantic (think Range Rover or Cadillac Escalade) and thirsty. Driving one will also make you look incredibly out of touch.

That brings us to the original family car: the station wagon. Station wagons are based on sedans, so they have the driving prowess, fuel economy, and style of the most obsessively engineered cars on the market.

Drawbacks? Third row seating is out, and tall items may require a call to your friend with the pickup truck. Like minivans, choice is also an issue: the only non-luxury wagon currently available is the truckified Subaru Outback. Audi, BMW, Mercedes, Acura, and Volvo all offer fine wagons, though.

So while carmakers are looking to create new market niches with crossbred crossovers, it might be better to look back instead. After all, what is a crossover but a taller version of a wagon?

Crossing over

There’s nothing terribly wrong with crossovers, but there’s nothing great about them either. Some, like the Evoque and Cayenne, stand out because they actually excel at things, but most are just acceptable. The choice for buyers, then, is between a car that does everything acceptably well, and a car that does some things extremely well.

Product Review

The all-new 3 Series proves BMW can still build a compelling sport sedan

Seat time in the entry-level BMW 330i ($41,425) and M340i xDrive ($54,995) will test the German automaker’s commitment to driving dynamics, powertrain refinement, and cutting edge technology.
Product Review

Inside Maserati's Levante SUV beats the heart of a Ferrari

Maserati’s luxury SUV gets a shot in the arm by way of Ferrari-derived V8 power, but is it enough to go toe-to-toe with the established players in the high performance sport-utility segment? Let’s find out.
Cars

Thinking of opting for a car with a diesel engine? Here's what you need to know

Modern diesel-powered models prove that it is possible to build a clean, efficient diesel engine without sacrificing performance. Here's what you need to know about diesel cars, and how they differ from gasoline-powered models.
Product Review

The 2019 Porsche Macan S is a luxurious and quick SUV, but it's no road tripper

The roster of models challenging the Porsche Macan grows annually. The German firm updated its smallest, most affordable SUV with a new engine, more tech features, and subtle design tweaks to keep it looking fresh.
Cars

Bosch’s CES-bound shuttle concept takes us on a trip to a not-too-distant future

Bosch envisions a future in which driverless shuttles occupy their own market segment. The German firm won't build the shuttles, but it wants to provide everything else, ranging from the drive system to the apps used to hail them.
Emerging Tech

A lidar-equipped truck knows exactly how much de-icer to apply on roads

Lidar is best known as the laser-based technology that helps self-driving cars sense their surroundings. But the city of Knoxville has another, more seasonal use for it: De-icing roads.
Cars

Driving a prototype 2020 Passat at Volkswagen’s Arizona Proving Ground

Volkswagen’s Arizona Proving Ground is where new cars are tested to the breaking point, including the 2020 Passat midsize sedan. Ride along as the new Passat completes testing ahead of its 2019 launch.
Product Review

Boring takes a back seat as 2019 Corolla Hatchback mixes fun with practicality

We drive the 2019 Toyota Corolla Hatchback, the latest hatchback to bear the Corolla name. As the best-selling nameplate in automotive history, Toyota has high expectations to meet. This model mostly lives up to the legacy.
Cars

Hertz speeds up car rentals with biometric scan technology

Biometric security technology that uses face, fingerprint, and voice recognition is gaining traction, with Hertz emerging as the latest company to incorporate it into its daily operations.
Mobile

McLaren puts the pedal to the metal in special-edition OnePlus 6T

The OnePlus 6T is yet another flagship killer smartphone, bringing powerful specifications to a much lower price than the competition. Now, OnePlus has teamed up with McLaren for the OnePlus 6T McLaren Edition.
Cars

Aston Martin’s 1,000-hp Valkyrie will boast the Mona Lisa of the engine world

Aston Martin has released new details about its F1-inspired Valkyrie hypercar. Co-developed with Red Bull Racing, the Valkyrie will be one of the most aerodynamic production cars ever made.
Cars

The redesigned 2020 Passat shows Volkswagen still believes in sedans

The sedan segment in America is shrinking, but Volkswagen still believes in it. The German firm has released a teaser sketch to preview the redesigned 2020 Passat it will introduce during the 2019 Detroit Auto Show.
Cars

Infiniti previews its leap into one of the hottest industry segments

Infiniti has released a teaser image to preview a concept it will unveil at the 2019 Detroit Auto Show. The yet-unnamed design study is an electric crossover shaped by Infiniti's newest design language.
Cars

What’s next for in-car entertainment? Audi believes it knows

Audi is bringing two technologies to CES 2019. The first turns a car -- a luxury sedan, in this case -- into a drive-in movie theater. The second is presented as a new entertainment format that turns the journey into the destination.