Skip to main content

Microsoft Denied Re-Hearing On i4i Infringement Case

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Remember last month when Microsoft lost its second attempt to appeal the patent infringement case it lost to Canada’s i4i over custom XML support in Microsoft Office? Well, now the Redmond software giant has suffered another blow: a federal court has rejected Microsoft’s request for a rehearing of the patent infringement case. The rejection means that Microsoft won’t be able to start this case over from the ground up…although it still has the option of attempting to appeal the original case to the Supreme Court.

“This has been a long and arduous process, but this decision is a powerful reinforcement of the message that smaller enterprises and inventors who own intellectual property can and will be protected,” said i4i chairman Owen Louden, in a statement.

The i4i infringement case has been a thorn in Microsoft’s side: Canada’s i4i brought the suit in 2007, alleging custom XML support in Microsoft Word infringed on their patent 5,787,449, and claimed Microsoft knew about i4i’s technology before rolling out the feature in Office…which meant the company was willfully infringing on the patent. Microsoft claimed it had done nothing wrong, but a Texas jury disagreed, awarding i4i a $200 million judgement and ordering Microsoft stop selling Microsoft Word unless it removed the infringing technology. Microsoft stripped the capability out of Microsoft Word 2007: that means the program can no longer open documents that contain custom XML.

“We’re disappointed with the decision,” said Microsoft director of public affairs Kevin Kutz, in a statement. “As far as next steps, we continue to believe there are important matters of patent law that still need to be properly addressed, and we are considering our options for going forward.”

Editors' Recommendations

Geoff Duncan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
Microsoft Surface Pro 9 vs. Lenovo IdeaPad Duet 5i: which 2-in-1 is best?
The screen of the Surface Pro 9 on a table.

Microsoft's Surface Pro 9 represents the latest version of what's become the industry standard for detachable tablet 2-in-1s. It's also one of the best laptops, period. Meanwhile, Lenovo's IdeaPad Duet 5i is an audacious new competitor, going up against an established machine.

There's one major factor differentiating the two: the price. The IdeaPad Duet 5i is significantly less expensive (and configurable) than the Surface Pro 9. Does that give it enough of a leg to stand on?
Specs and configurations

Read more
This lifetime Microsoft Office license is $50 off for Black Friday
Computer user touching on Microsoft word icon to open the program.

Today is the day we've all been waiting for, and as the Black Friday deals keep rolling out, people are scooping up laptops left and right. To complement all of the Black Friday laptop deals, Best Buy is offering an incredible deal on Microsoft Office 2021 Home & Student Edition. Originally priced at $150, you can currently purchase a lifetime license today for only $100, saving you $50, or 33%, off this must-have productivity software package. This deal is one of the Best Buy Black Friday deals you definitely won't want to miss, especially if you've got students or someone who works from home on your 2022 holiday shopping list.

This deal is without a doubt one of the best Microsoft Office deals we've seen all year. Microsoft Office is the industry standard when it comes to productivity software and that has been the case for decades. As part of this software package, you'll gain lifetime access to the essential Microsoft Office classics: Microsoft Word, Microsoft Excel, and Microsoft PowerPoint. The one-time purchase comes with one license that can be installed on one device, but can be transferred to another device should you decide to upgrade your computer in the future.

Read more
Microsoft Surface Laptop 5 vs. Surface Laptop 4: Is the upgrade worth it?
Using a Microsoft Surface Laptop 4 sitting on a couch with a dog.

Microsoft's Surface Laptop 5 is here, ready to replace the ultrathin Surface Laptop 4. Announced at the annual fall Surface event, the laptop brings some changes to the lineup, but most of the differences are on the inside.

Seeing as Microsoft decided to drop AMD in the Surface Laptop 5, the battle between the Surface Laptop 5 and the Surface Laptop 4 could be fiercer than one might expect. Intel versus AMD debates are always spicy. Let's see how these two laptops compare.
Specs

Read more