Skip to main content

Rambus Patents Ruled Unenforceable

Rambus Patents Ruled Unenforceable
Image used with permission by copyright holder

In a closely watched intellectual property case, U.S. District Judge Sue L. Robinson has ruled that Rambus employees had destroyed email and other documents related to the company’s patents, litigation, and marketing strategies between 1998 and 1999, and, as such, a dozen DRAM-related patents held by Rambus cannot be enforced against memory maker Micron. The two companies have patent-infringement lawsuits filed against each other in the Delaware court; however, Judge Robinson’s ruling would appear to take most of the wind out of Rambus’ case, with the judge characterizing Rambus’ bad faith “clear and convincing.”

“The spoliation conduct was extensive, including within its scope the destruction of innumerable documents relating to all aspects of Rambus’ business,” Judge Robinson wrote. “Therefore, the court concludes that the appropriate sanction for the conduct of record is to declare the patents in suit unenforceable against Micron.”

Recommended Videos

Rambus had established a three-month retention policy on email, and conducted two “document shred days” at times, according to Robinson, company officials should have known patent litigation was likely.

“We respectfully, but strongly, disagree with this opinion, and at the appropriate juncture plan to appeal,” said Rambus’s senior VP and general counsel Tom Lavelle, in a statement. “This opinion is highly inconsistent with the findings of the Court in the Northern District of California which looked at the same conduct and found there was nothing improper with our document retention practices.”

Micron, for its part, applauded the decision: “We believe that the decision is applicable to other pending cases, and we are reviewing the ruling to determine its potential impact,” said MIcron VP of legal affairs Rod Lewis, in a statement.

The California case Rambus refers to in its statement also names Hynix, Samsung, and Nanya as defendants; the case is still pending.

The case originates over ten years ago, when Rambus began marketing patented technology to improve performance of DRAM used in computers. Rambus attempted to get DRAM manufacturers and systems makers to license its technology; however, in 1998 chipmaker Intel decided to go with Micron’s technology, rather than Rambus’s. The FTC has also become involved in the dispute, accusing Rambus of deceiving a standards-setting body by failing to disclose its DRAM patents; the FTC’s case is currently being appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Geoff Duncan
Former Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
Upgrade to the Alienware 18 Area-51 gaming laptop with RTX 5070 Ti — $500 off!
The Alienware 18 Area-51 Gaming Laptop on a white background.

You should be ready to spend a lot if you want a powerful gaming laptop, but you should also be on the lookout for potential savings. Now's a great time to check out Alienware deals because of Dell's Black Friday in July sale, which includes a fantastic offer for the Alienware 18 Area-51 gaming laptop. This configuration with the Nvidia GeForce RTX 5070 Ti graphics card is down from $3,300 to $2,800, which is still expensive, but you wouldn't want to miss this chance at $500 in savings. You have to hurry though, as stocks may run out at any moment!

Buy Now

Read more
Save $100 on our pick for the best printer
HP includes full ink bottles with the Smart Tank 7602.

What do we need to print these days? Tax forms, student essays, and clearly-legible letters? Not so much. Bright invites, pictures, and presentation accompaniments? Yes, yes, and yes! In today's world, the typical person's needs in an inkjet printer are far different than the last time you were likely to have bought a printer. And the industry is catching up. Right now, our pick for the overall best printer of 2025 is $100 off as part of early Prime Day deals. That makes the $450 printer just $350 if you buy now. Plus, it comes with two years of HP's ink included. So, tap the button below to go check out the HP Smart Tank 7602 for yourself or keep reading to see what we like about it and what we found out during our review.

BUY NOW

Read more
Apple’s work-from-home powerhouse is 24% off… and about to go extinct
The MacBook Air on a table in front of a window.

Hard-hitting MacBook deals are rare. People love their products and will happily buy them at full price, so sales aren't as incentivized as with other products. So, when we see a $400 savings on the most powerful version (the 24GB of RAM one) of the MacBook Air M3, dropping its price from $1,699 to $1,299, we love it. And that's exactly what's happening as part of this early Prime Day deal and one of the most exciting laptop deals in recent dates. Tap the button below to see it for yourself, or keep reading to get all of the details about the MacBook Air M3, what we discovered when we used it ourself, and why this deal may be the last of its kind.

BUY NOW

Read more