Skip to main content

The biggest challenge for the Silent Hills dream team? Getting stuck in a small town

kojima silent hills removed street scene
Image used with permission by copyright holder
When news of Silent Hills broke last night, I did what I always do with monumental moments in gaming: Picked up my phone and immediately shot off an excited text to dear friend, colleague, Joystiq community manager, regular Digital Trends contributor, and suspected superhero Anthony Agnello.

Anthony Agnello, compatriot and verbal sparring partner
Anthony Agnello, compatriot and verbal sparring partner Image used with permission by copyright holder

After the obligatory round of fanboy squees — it’s impossible to reign in the kneejerk excitement when seeing names like Hideo Kojima, Guillermo del Toro, and Norman Reedus assembled for a new effort in the Silent Hill horror series — Anthony surprised me.

Recommended Videos

“I just wish they were calling it something else though,” he texted.

Wait, what? Was he really not happy that these three creative forces had aligned around a Silent Hill game?

“Yeah, I’d rather it be something totally original. They could still do the same themes and weird town s–t.”

The conversation pretty much ended there. I fired back with a brief explanation of why I’m so personally excited that this trio is venturing into the town of Silent Hill, but the more I think about Anthony’s doubts, the more I understand where he’s coming from: Big franchises come with big baggage.

Silent-Hills-logo
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Silent Hill is not a new series, and there’s a lot of lore surrounding it. Since it first launched in 1999, we’ve learned about the history of the town and the surrounding region. We’ve also glimpsed into the lives of a wide assortment of key players, many of whom are connected in surprising ways. Amidst all of horror, gore, and supernatural underpinnings, the fiction has further extended to include a secret cult and even aliens. That’s a lot of baggage to carry into a new game led by three fresh faces.

Related: Silent Hill: Book of Memories‘ failed experiments in dungeon-crawling (review)

This is why the world is overrun with reboots right now. We live in an age of deeply developed serial narratives, the product of efforts like HBO’s “It’s not TV” philosophy and Marvel Studios’ stunningly vast “Cinematic Universe.” Creative forces are focusing lots of effort on crafting new stories within this cultural framework, stories that start at square one for the sake of attracting fans new and old alike, then growing with them. It’s still so new, one has to wonder: When Marvel reaches its 2020 slate of films, will the powers-that-be at the studio be considering a reboot of a cinematic universe that’s spanned more than a decade?

Probably. Yeah.

It’s worth noting here that we’re operating under the assumption that Silent Hills is not a reboot. The title alone suggests that the upcoming game builds on top of the established mythos. And in that context, I can understand Anthony’s hesitation. Why send this trio of blockbuster names off to work on a project that has built-in baggage?

If Silent Hills were just Random Horror Game From Creative Super-Team, we could all feel free to geek out about the possibilities. Anchoring these three men to Silent Hill gives gamers a touchstone, sure, but there’s a cost too, measured in titles like Silent Hill: Origins and Silent Hill: Book of Memories. Outcasts from a long-lived series, informing opinions even while this new project is in its embryonic stages. Not a position you want to start in when you’re throwing blockbuster appeal at a genre that isn’t traditionally a force for mainstream sales.

“I’d rather it be something totally original. They could still do the same themes and weird town s–t.”

The strongest efforts in video gaming’s horror catalog, commercially speaking, cross over with other genres (see also: BioShockDead Island). Traditional survival horror though? Silent Hill 2, widely regarded as the best entry in the series, barely eked out 1 million in sales. Meanwhile, BioShock moved around 4 million copies by 2010, two years after its release, and it’s poised to sell more with the upcoming mobile port.

Granted, Silent Hill has grown considerably as a franchise since 2001, with two commercially successful film adaptations. But survival horror has taken some notable hits in recent years. Resident Evil 6 was a megalithic debacle, so overstuffed with play-changing approaches that it felt unhinged and disorienting. The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct, which brought in Reedus to play his Daryl role from the TV series, was a cheap, uninspired cash-in.

Related: See BioShock (the full game) running on iPadSilent-Hills-Norman-ReedusBanner names like Guillermo del Toro, Hideo Kojima, and Norman Reedus count for something, but there’s no way Konami doesn’t have a safety net in place for what must be a sizable investment. Something that sidesteps the danger of becoming another Book of Memories.

That’s where Anthony’s worry comes from. What’s going to change? When all is said and done, will this game even resemble the foundational survival horror experience that the first Silent Hill delivered? How much creative control do Kojima, del Toro, et al have, and how much are they at the mercy of publisher Konami’s investor-minded meddling?

These are valid questions to ask. Why revive Silent Hill now? Because talented creative minds behind multiple games and films have aligned to make it so. Yes, great, but why Silent Hill specifically? Name recognition combined with brand loyalty.

The math here all adds up, but the intangibles weigh heavy. Even if it’s all speculation at this point, I’ve got to wonder if Anthony’s onto something. Don’t ask if Kojima, del Toro, and Reedus can deliver a horror game that’s worth our time; ask instead why they’re calling it Silent Hill in the first place.

Adam Rosenberg
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Previously, Adam worked in the games press as a freelance writer and critic for a range of outlets, including Digital Trends…
Yes, the Nintendo lawsuit against Palworld devs is about throwing Poke Balls
Pokemon Scarlet and Violet protagonist holding glowing Poke Ball

We finally know the patents at the center of a massive Nintendo lawsuit against Palworld maker Pocketpair, and they refer to patents specific to the Pokémon games.

When Nintendo announced that it had filed a lawsuit against Pocketpair over Palworld -- aka "Pokémon with guns" -- it did not reveal which patents were allegedly being infringed upon, and Pocketpair said it didn't know either. However, there were some good educated guesses, like one that pertained to throwing a Poké Ball at a creature in a virtual world.

Read more
The best Faction to pick in Dragon Age: The Veilguard
Two Antivan Crows in Dragon Age: The Veilguard.

After taking way too long in character creation making your perfect Rook in Dragon Age: The Veilguard, you're still left with some tough decisions. Choosing a class is one thing, but then there are six different Factions to decide on as well. Each Faction comes with its own perks, and your choice also alters certain dialogue moments and relationships, as it plays a part in how Rook came to be a part of Varric's group.

While your Faction choice may entirely depend on what you want to role-play as, the perks can affect your gameplay experience depending on your class as well. We'll help you figure out the best Faction to pick for your Rook in Dragon Age: The Veilguard so you can finally leave that character creation menu and start the actual game.
All Faction perks in Dragon Age: The Veilguard

Read more
Sony commits to single-player games in wake of Concord failure
Astro Bot dresses up as Kratos.

Sony is not giving up on single-player games despite investing a lot into live-service games over the past few years, with plans to release at least one "major" single-player game every year "from next fiscal year onwards."

The company released its Q2 2024 financial report on Friday, and there was a lot of good news for the video game division despite the high-profile failure of live-service title Concord. Earlier this year. The hero shooter only wracked up a few hundred players on Steam at launch -- only 697 concurrent users at peak, according to SteamDB. Sony Interactive Entertainment took the game offline two weeks after launch before eventually sunsetting it and shutting down developer Firewalk Studios.

Read more