Skip to main content

Top game developers consider the question of why the D.I.C.E. Summit matters

DICE - Pool table

Attending the D.I.C.E. Summit as a member of the press is a fascinating experience. Most trade shows in the video game industry are focused on appealing to the media. Whether it’s the glamor of E3 or the nuts-and-bolts talk of GDC, press affiliation goes a long way. That isn’t the case with D.I.C.E., a place where the makers of gamers get to talk amongst themselves about their craft. Press presence is much more of the “fly on the wall” variety, providing a rare opportunity to step outside the “script” of game marketing and hear about the thoughts that go into making a game.

We spoke with a variety of D.I.C.E. participants over the course of our two days in Las Vegas, about what the event means to them and what they take from it. 343 Industries’ Frank O’Connor and Kiki Wolfkill offer the clearest and most straightforward definition of what D.I.C.E. actually is. “E3 is about marketing and commerce and amplification. That’s what it’s for and it’s all great, there’s nothing wrong with that. GDC is about process and detail,” O’Connor said.

O'Connor and Wolfkill“D.I.C.E. is nice because it gets to be about philosophy. You get to just take a step back from what it is that you’re doing and what it is that your peers are doing and think about how we’re doing it, or why we’re doing it. It’s always affirming to come here and share that experience and share those stories.”

Wolfkill agrees, adding that it’s easy to feel like you’re working in an echo chamber as a project comes together. “You’re so heads-down [during development],” she said. “I haven’t been to D.I.C.E. in four years and its always been one of my favorite conferences to attend. To be able to re-emerge and [see how our peers] have shared experiences and problems. To just sort of remember that you’re part of an industry and you’re part of this bigger whole than just the thing that you’re doing is a really refreshing perspective to be reminded of.”

“D.I.C.E. is nice because it gets to be about philosophy.”

Gearbox Software boss Randy Pitchford agrees with O’Connor’s assessment of D.I.C.E.-as-development philosophy discussion. “It’s intense, it’s vision, it’s the high level,” he said. “It’s about what drives us and motivates us and what’s going to inspire us and where we’re drawing vision from. So you get a lot of the high-level guys here sharing thoughts and drawing vision from each other. Trying to imagine where it will go and see through the discussion if we can simultaneously, naturally go in non-mutually exclusive directions but also be aware of where other people might go, so we can be part of an ecosystem. It’s kind of neat.”

The changing of the hardware guard that looms large over the industry right now was a major theme at D.I.C.E. this year. It wasn’t the subject of many talks, but you could feel an undercurrent of thought directed at the coming changes that most of the gathered attendees were probably aware of and thinking about already. Pitchford addressed this sentiment directly in our chat. Not to the point of spilling details on what’s to come, of course; rather, from more of a philosophical perspective.

Pitchford“On one level, [coming to the end of a hardware cycle] allows a wider view of what is possible,” he explained. “We have such a vibrant economy right now, with so many different paths, business models, thought forms, and we’re also just beginning the dreaming stage of what a whole new future is going to look like. So it creates a very wide-open spread. Some of the questions that we’ve dealt with over the years come back to the table, like how do Hollywood and video games mingle?

“There’s also an opportunity in some cases to vent and soapbox a bit. That’s always part of it. There’s a tiny bit of a post-mortem vibe [this year] since we are coming to the end of the cycle. But I think one of the neat things about D.I.C.E. is it doesn’t attempt to focus on just a narrow, singular objective. It actually wants to cover a spectrum, and that’s important because the spectrum of what the industry is is very wide.”

Supergiant Games founder Amir Rao brings along a different perspective in his first visit to D.I.C.E. as both a speaker and an attendee. Supergiant was in attendance at the D.I.C.E. Awards the previous year, but Rao reveled in the opportunity both to speak to his colleagues in game development and to hear what they had to say. “This has been awesome,” he said, grinning. “I think there have been some really amazing talks. I really enjoyed both [keynote] talks with Gabe Newell. There’s a lot of wisdom not just in the conference talks, but also in the conversations afterward with everyone. It’s all much tighter, more honest and direct than I was expecting in a lot of ways.”

Rao’s presentation covered the topic of “Multiplatformism,” considering the dirty concept of porting games and the ways that Supergiant went about sidestepping those issues in developing the different versions of Bastion. Fitting each version to each platform’s unique control mechanisms was a huge component there, and the small team chose to focus its efforts on one new version at a time, as opposed to simultaneously developing for all.

Bastion interview 2“Interface design speaks directly to almost every discipline involved in games,” Rao said. “Interfaces have art components, programming components, design components, usability components, they have sound to them that makes them feel reactive or not. In the case of a GamePad, they have a tactile feel, rumble tuning… all that kind of stuff. It’s a huge challenge, thinking about how you imagine your games across all of these different interfaces, and how you can put the same creative energy into solving the problems of each.”

Members of the press aren’t the only D.I.C.E. outsiders. This year saw Infocom co-founders Dave Lebling and Marc Blank in attendance to be honored with a Pioneer Award from the Academy of Interactive Arts and Sciences. We asked Lebling what it was like to dive deeply with all of this high-minded development discussion, given that he’s been an industry outsider since Infocom shuttered in 1989. Surprisingly, Lebling found that many of the conversation topics were familiar.

“The underlying development stuff is so much more high-tech, so much more capable of doing things [than we were able to at Infocom]. On the other hand, what we were doing was as high-tech as you could be back then. We thought we were pretty advanced. What has been most interesting to me: they are talking about the same things that we talked about,” he said.

When Blank arrived late in Las Vegas and expressed disappointment to his former Infocom colleague about missing a number of the first day’s talks, Lebling offered some reassurance. “I said, ‘Oh, you don’t have to worry. You went to all the Imp lunches; you heard exactly the same talk.’ The same things they are talking about are the things we were talking about 30 years ago at Infocom. How do you do a story that is a story without constraining the player? Alternatively, if the player is not constrained, how is it a story?

Infocom - Dave Lebling and Marc Blank“Gabe said [during his keynote with JJ Abrams] that if you give the player too many choices, it paralyzes them. I can remember that we had a little of that. We had so many things you could do because of the English language parser. Every object in the game could be referenced; if it was in the room, you could reference it. If you were a machine, you could iterate on every verb with every noun. Give the sword to the troll, give the sword to the chair, give the sword to the tree, eat the sword, eat the sword with ketchup. All this kind of stuff… these kinds of things existed and we worried a lot about making them make sense.”

Whether you’re an accomplished developer, an up-and-coming-indie, or a fly on the wall with a passion for games and a press card tucked snugly into your cap, D.I.C.E. is a one-of-a-kind experience. As O’Connor said, it’s about philosophy. Considering the big questions that continue to be fundamental to the evolving medium. You’re not hearing about the new guns that the next Halo game will offer or what’s next for the minds behind Bastion, but you’re getting so, so much more as long as you’re receptive to hearing it.

Editors' Recommendations

The best PS5 games for 2023
Leon parries a chainsaw villager in Resident Evil 4.

The PlayStation 4's success was largely due to its stellar game library, which featured some of the best titles of the past generation. Now, the PlayStation 5 is looking to repeat that success, though it's going to have to overcome some initial bumps in the road to reach that point.

Sony suffered some road bumps bringing major titles to market over the course of 2022 but new hit games are finally punching through. God of War Ragnarok, Call of Duty: Modern Warfare II, and Overwatch 2 are the most recent top titles to hit PS5, but there are plenty of other killer games for every kind of gamer out on the platform. As always, there's a running list of great upcoming PS5 games. Currently, there's no shortage of incredible experiences to be had right now on PS5.

Read more
The best Nintendo Switch games for 2023
Samus stares down Thardus in Metroid Prime Remastered.

The Nintendo Switch has had a lot of success in the nearly six years since its release. The console-handheld hybrid has been on the market since 2017, and a slew of fantastic games from first- and third-party developers launched over the course of the system's life cycle. Recently, heavy hitters such as Metroid Dread, Pokémon Scarlet and Violet, and Kirby and the Forgotten Land have boosted the system's appeal, while a healthy list of upcoming games continues to drum up excitement.

There are plenty of incredible games to enjoy on the Switch right now. But which ones should you check out? These are the best Nintendo Switch games (including free-to-play titles) for 2023.

Read more
The best Xbox Series X games for 2023
Two Spartans side by side in Halo Infinite.

After an uneven console cycle with the Xbox One, Microsoft's latest consoles are aimed at getting the ship back on course. The Xbox Series X is a next-generation powerhouse that rivals gaming PCs, while the Xbox Series S is an affordable stopgap for those who are curious about trying new games.

There's no shortage of games to play on either console thanks to Xbox Game Pass, which gives players immediate access to a library of titles old and new. That built-in catalog is an extra value on top of all the new games available on the system that take advantage of its impressive technical specs. When it comes to first-party exclusives, the Series X is still growing. Halo Infinite and Forza Horizon 5 gave a good boost to the console's library following a somewhat sparse first year. More games are also on the way. Microsoft's Bethesda acquisition will bring exclusives like Starfield and Redfall, and the potential addition of all Activision Blizzard games would further bolster that list, but the console's real strength lies in third-party support.

Read more