Skip to main content

Enterprise or Millennium Falcon? For Neil deGrasse Tyson, the choice is easy

Famed astronomer Neil deGrasse Tyson weighed in on one of geekdom’s longest-running debates this past Friday, answering a question that pits sci-fi franchises Star Wars and Star Trek against each other: Millennium Falcon, or USS Enterprise?

The unofficial Ambassador of Astronomy made quick work of his initial answer before going into detail, saying, “Oh, that’s easy. The Enterprise, there’s no question!”

The query came during the “fan questions” segment of the famed scientist’s National Geographic series StarTalk, a science-themed talk show based off of the host’s podcast of the same name.

The astronomer is no stranger to film and tv-based debates, often weighing in on the scientific realism of various aspects of Hollywood’s projects once they hit theaters. In fact, deGrasse Tyson once convinced James Cameron to change the star patterns that appeared in the sky during a nighttime scene in Titanic, because the original release had the “wrong sky.”

Despite immediately siding with Star Trek, deGrasse Tyson’s reasoning behind choosing the Enterprise was more evolved than typical fanboy love. The ship, he says, revolutionized that way that popular culture thought about space travel.

“The Enterprise is the first spaceship represented in storytelling that was not designed to go from one place to another; It was only designed to explore. Think about that. Every movie, every show that preceded that, built it to go to a destination,” he said, “that was revolutionary in terms of what we would think space would and should be about.”

But his love for the Enterprise also extends beyond what the ship represents in pop culture. As an imaginary technical marvel, the Enterprise is also much less made-up than the Millennium Falcon.

“The Enterprise has the benefit of being real in the sense that there are real scientists and real engineers on staff on the ship monitoring its engines, its warp drives, its photon torpedoes,” he said, “It’s fake real as opposed to the Millennium Falcon, which is just fake fake.”

Editors' Recommendations

Parker Hall
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Parker Hall is a writer and musician from Portland, OR. He is a graduate of the Oberlin Conservatory of Music in Oberlin…
Where to watch The Real Housewives of Orange County season 17
The real housewives of orange county pose for the poster of the new season.

The Real Housewives of Orange County, the series that sparked a reality TV empire, is returning for its 17th season. RHOC first premiered in March 2006. Since then, Real Housewives has become one of Bravo's premier reality franchises, with 11 American installments and over 20 spinoffs.

Tamra Judge, who left after season 14, returns to the series after a two-season hiatus. Joining Judge this season will be Heather Dubrow, Gina Kirschenheiter, Shannon Storms Beador, Emily Simpson, and new housewife Jennifer Pedranti. Taylor Armstrong, who starred in three seasons of The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills, will serve as a friend of the housewives, becoming the first person to cross cities in the franchise's history. RHOC legend Vicki Gunvalson will make a guest appearance in season 17 as well.
Watch The Real Housewives of Orange County season 17 on Bravo

Read more
Nicolas Cage embraces chaos in Sympathy for the Devil trailer
Nicolas Cage in Sympathy for the Devil.

As an actor, Nicolas Cage has had a wildly eclectic career that ranges from would-be Superman to an occasional vampire in Renfield. For his next movie, Sympathy for the Devil, Cage is playing to his strengths as an enigmatic passenger who holds Joel Kinnamen's driver at gunpoint. In the trailer below, Cage is completely convincing as an off-the-wall and violent hit man who could kill the driver at any time. However, it also appears that the passenger did not hijack the driver at random. Instead, he seems to have a purpose in mind.


Read more
The best movies on Max right now
Poster for Moonlight featuring the protagonist's face split among three phases of his life.

Though Warner Bros. Discovery's streaming app has been rebranded, Max (formerly HBO Max) still has some of the best movies to stream right now thanks to its diverse catalog. The platform provides excellent variety in its movies across every genre imaginable, ensuring that subscribers will find at least a handful of content to match their needs.

That's an exceptional strength for any streamer to have considering how competitive -- as well as how increasingly expensive -- the market is. Even so, we've sifted through the platform's offerings to curate a consistently updated guide to help you find the best movies to stream on Max right now.

Read more