Skip to main content

Despite design changes, Apple has not fixed problems with MacBook keyboards

MacBook Keyboard
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Apple is once again facing some criticism for the keyboard design on its lineup of laptops. Despite the recent introduction of a new and improved third-generation butterfly keyboard on new 2018 MacBooks, the company is now apologizing to a “small number” of users who are still complaining about non-responsive and sticking keys.

Recommended Videos

The apology originally comes from a report from The Wall Street Journal. They find that both the E and R keys on their new MacBook Air 2018 were occasionally faulty. In fact, the Journal wrote an entire article about the problems without using the letters E or R (but includes toggle switches to turn the letters on). Furthermore, the report finds that other users have experienced similar issues where both of these keys and W and T would double-press. In response, Apple acknowledged these issues but also claimed that most MacBook users aren’t experiencing problems.

“We are aware that a small number of users are having issues with their third-generation butterfly keyboard and for that we are sorry. The vast majority of Mac notebook customers are having a positive experience with the new keyboard. If you have a problem, contact Apple customer service,” Apple said in a statement.

Apple originally introduced the problematic butterfly keyboard mechanism with a new MacBook model in April 2015 and a second-generation keyboard then came later in October 2016 with the MacBook Pro. Though the new keyboard was intended to maximize key travel and improve stability, many had experienced issues with certain letters and characters not appearing on the screen when typing. Facing pressure, the company eventually launched a repair program for users with concerns.

To help address these problems, the third-generation butterfly keyboard on the 2018 MacBook Pro and MacBook Air uses silicone membranes to help prevent debris and other objects from damaging the internal mechanisms. Keyboard issues are just one problem plaguing some MacBook users. There is also an ongoing separate issue with the display on other models of the MacBook. Dubbed as “Flexgate,” the problem could result in a situation where the backlighting on the notebook would give out and cause the bottom of the display to become slightly distorted.

Arif Bacchus
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Arif Bacchus is a native New Yorker and a fan of all things technology. Arif works as a freelance writer at Digital Trends…
I finally found the perfect mechanical keyboard to go with my Mac, and it’s a lot cheaper
Angled view of a person typing on the Satechi SM3 Slim mechanical keyboard.

My experience with Apple’s Magic Keyboard for the Mac has been a love-hate situation, at best. It is slim, sleek, offers a fantastic scissor-switch, and serves the Touch ID convenience. What’s not to love? 

Well, for starters, the asking price is a steep $200, which is too much for a non-mechanical keyboard. There is no backlight. It is not ergonomic. The looks, though understated, are bland.  

Read more
I used a free app to fix my biggest problem with macOS
Depicting of the Maccy clipboard app for macOS on a laptop with letters inb the background.

I recently found myself assisting my sister with a research project. Writing a science paper is a notoriously taxing process because it is excruciatingly drab to write one,  but at the same time, you have to be meticulous with every single statement. Citations are a crucial element, and depending on the topic you have picked, you may have to sprinkle a few links in every line.

In my case, my citation list had over 140 links, a healthy few of which were open across different tabs and pushing Chrome to its limits. Yet, the most arduous part was not the struggling web browser, but the chore of cycling through tabs, merely to copy the URL or citation details from each research paper.

Read more
I can recommend the M4 MacBook Air for its battery life alone
Rear view of lid on M4 MacBook Air.

Over the course of the past few months, I’ve tried a handful of Windows on Arm machines. The biggest takeaway is that if you buy a slim and light Windows laptop in 2025, you don’t need to hunt for a seat near a wall outlet. The battery life figures I’ve got from Qualcomm Snapdragon X-powered laptops have been pretty amazing. 

For the first time, I feel Windows laptops have reached a point where they can reach the high benchmark set by the MacBook Air. My most recent tryst was with the Asus Zenbook A14, and the Dell XPS 13 before that. I loved the thin and lightweight form factors, and the progress Windows on Arm has made with the app compatibility situation. 

Read more