Skip to main content

Even the FBI can’t defeat good encryption – here’s why it works

encryption bill underway protects your most private data
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Digital data is difficult to secure by nature. Once a person has access to a file, it’s trivial to move, copy or delete. A single breach can spread a file to literally millions of people across the globe, something that would never be possible with a document that only exists as a physical copy.

That will never change. The ease of accessing, moving, copying, altering, and deleting data is a key trait of all modern computers. Instead, digital data security focuses on creating barriers between the data and those seeking access, so a file never leaves its owner’s control.

Barriers like encryption. If you use the Internet, own a smartphone, or have a PC, then your data is at some point protected by encryption, though you may not know it. That’s why the FBI is having such a tough time getting into the phone of a mass shooter, and Apple is so reluctant to help. Defeating its own encryption for one iPhone could potentially defeat it for all iPhones, in the wrong hands.

It’s a complicated problem, but one that’s easier to understand if you know the basics of encryption. What is encryption, and how does it work? Hold on to your butts, because it’s time for some maths.

Child’s play

When I was a kid, I came up with a secret code that I thought was very clever. I’d write a message by substituting every letter with one six steps higher in the alphabet. So an A became G, and so on.

Silly as it may seem, this is a basic form of encryption. First, imagine each letter as a number. A corresponds to one, Z corresponds to 26, and so on. The cipher for my childhood code, mathematically speaking, became (x)+6, where (x) is the number corresponding to the letter I meant to communicate. Of course, the math loops above 26, since there’s only 26 letters in the alphabet. Thus, a Z became an F.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

So, to reiterate, my cipher turned an A to a G because that was the result of one (the number corresponding to A) plus six.

This is a very basic form of encryption. A set of data, in this case the letters of the alphabet, has a mathematical algorithm applied to it. It’s terrible encryption, since it wouldn’t take much effort to identify patterns in my garbled words, and then work out the code. Still, the example covers the basics.

Diving into the deep end

The code I came up is a bit like a code used in the Roman Empire called Ceaser’s Cipher. Modern encryption is a lot more complex. A number of techniques have been invented to further garble the data. That includes the literal key to modern encryption techniques – the encryption key. I’ll explain, using the popular AES standard as a basis.

No modern computer can break 256-bit AES, even if it’d started working on the problem at the beginning of the universe.

Understanding the encryption key in detail requires mathematical knowledge that most people simply don’t have, so I’m not going to try and cover every step. To put it as simply as possible, the original data goes through an “exclusive or” function alongside the value of the key. The function registers false if the inputs are the same, and true if they are not. If you’re familiar with computers, you’ll immediately recognize this false/true function is binary, and so it generates a new set of binary data from the input of the original data and the key.

Then, to make it even harder to crack, AES uses a number of additional steps such as confusion, the technique I used to make my childhood cipher. After those several additional steps, the encryption is complete. Decryption reverses the steps to find the original message, but only if the key is known, since it was used to complete the encryption functions.

You’ve probably at some point heard that encryption keys come in different types, like 64-bit, 128-bit, and 256-bit. The more bits in the key, the harder it becomes to decrypt, because the original data is more thoroughly muddled through the “exclusive or” and successive steps.

And when I say difficult, I mean difficult. You’ve likely heard that the FBI wants Apple to help it bypass the security of an iPhone used by a suspect in the San Bernardino terrorist attack. That phone is protected by 256-bit AES encryption. No computer currently in existence can break 256-bit AES through brute-force even if it’d started working on the problem at the beginning of the universe. In fact, it would take hundreds of billions of years for a modern supercomputer to crack 256-bit AES just by guessing.

Getting around the impossible

While impossible is a strong word, it’s applicable to current technology, and current forms of encryption. A brute force attack against today’s best algorithms isn’t feasible.

Yet you’ve probably heard, time and time again, of attackers taking down encryption. How can that be? Sometimes this occurs because of the use of an old encryption method that’s been cracked. In other cases, it’s due not to a weakness of the algorithm used, but instead a problem with how it was implemented.

The iPhone that the FBI can’t crack is an example of well implemented encryption. A PIN is used to secure the phone, but it rejects unsuccessful attempts with a lockout time that becomes longer and longer after the fourth try. After ten unsuccessful attempts the phone wipes itself clean. It’s not possible to get around the PIN by loading new software, because firmware can only be loaded onto an iPhone if it’s signed with a specific code only Apple knows. And encryption is applied by a chip that’s between the phone’s flash storage and the main system memory, so it’s not possible to physically hijack the data.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

That’s a lot of security, and each barrier represents a potential hole. It’d be possible to simply re-try the PIN until the correct one was found if the iPhone did not reject successive attempts. The phone’s memory might be transplanted to a different device if it wasn’t encrypted by a chip within the phone. Firmware that’s not properly secured would let a hacker load their own custom firmware to disable the phone’s security features. And so on.

Encryption is effective, but sensitive. If the key used to execute it can be discovered, or the software and hardware used to conduct the encryption can be fooled, it’s easily defeated. Key-logging software is a good example. It can “defeat” even the toughest encryption by logging the user’s password. Once that’s compromised, an attacker doesn’t need the slightest technical skill to proceed.


The iPhone is also a great example of encryption because most people don’t realize it’s encrypted while using it. This is true of its implementation more often than not. HTTPS uses encryption to send data securely over the Web. All the major cloud storage providers use encryption to protect data. Even your cell phone’s data voice and data connections are encrypted.

Opaque operation is ideal. Encryption shouldn’t be obvious – at least not when applied to everyday consumer devices. If it were, it might become annoying, and users would seek ways to circumvent it. You’ll find it’s rare that you must do anything to enable encryption.

But it’s still important to know what it is, and how it works, so you can judge the devices you use and be careful about how you use them. User error causes encryption failure far more often than an actual breach of an algorithm. Knowledge can help you shore up the weak spot – you.

Editors' Recommendations

Matthew S. Smith
Matthew S. Smith is the former Lead Editor, Reviews at Digital Trends. He previously guided the Products Team, which dives…
Last chance to get the Dell XPS 17 laptop while it’s $500 off
Dell XPS 17 9370 front angled view showing display and keyboard deck.

If you want to buy a thin and light laptop but don't want to go for something like the MacBook Air, which is both expensive and puts you into the Apple ecosystem, the Dell XPS lineup is a great alternative. The XPS laptops are Dell's answer to the need for thin laptops that aren't from Apple, and, even better, there are a lot more configurations and sizes you can pick from. While this XPS 17 is bigger than a MacBook Air, there's a great deal on it from Dell that brings it down to $1,699 from $2,199, which is a significant $500 discount and well worth grabbing if you want a thin and light laptop with a large screen.

Why you should buy the Dell XPS 17
This configuration of the Dell XPS 17 has a lot of standout features, the most interesting of which is likely the inclusion of the RTX 4050 graphics card. While the XPS 17 is not really meant as a thin gaming laptop, the fact that it includes an entry-level GPU means you can certainly get a bit of gaming out of it, although don't expect to be playing the latest AAA games. More importantly, it comes with a mid-to-high end 13th Gen Intel Core i7-13700H processor, which will easily handle most productivity and day-to-day tasks without an issue, and you might even be able to get some editing done.

Read more
Best VPN deals: Save on NordVPN, ExpressVPN, and Surfshark
A close-up of a computer monitor displaying a generic VPN.

There are a lot of good reasons to grab a VPN, whether it's for security and privacy purposes or whether you just want to access content that would otherwise be geo-locked. Luckily, over the past few years, the number of VPNs out there has boomed massively, and you have a huge selection of them to pick from. There's also a lot of work that's gone into creating more secure and encrypted protocols, and some VPNs even do a double-server bounce to make absolutely sure nobody can see what you are doing, which is essential if you're going to be going somewhere with privacy and security issues. Regardless of why you want to get a VPN, we've collected some of our favorite VPN deals below, so you don't have to go looking.

Best VPN Deal

Read more
Best router deals: Save on mesh networks and Wi-Fi 6 routers
The Netgear Nighthawk AXE11000 Tri-Band Wi-Fi 6E Router on a table.

Strangely enough, routers have had a huge technological bump in the last few years due to the number of devices that need to be connected to the internet. That's one of the main aspects of the new Wi-Fi 6, a standard that not only increases speeds and quality of the connection but addresses the issue with ten devices or more needing to connect to the internet constantly without impacting quality. To that end, if you haven't upgraded your router or mesh network in three to five or more years but are increasingly buying more smart-home products, grabbing a modern router with the latest technology is probably a good idea.

Best Router Deals

Read more