Skip to main content

FCC’s Genachowski outlines net neutrality plan

Image used with permission by copyright holder

The net neutrality debate is about to come to a head: Federal Communications Commission Chairman Julius Genachowski has circulated a proposed framework of rules intended to preserve an “open Internet”—and, if the chairman has his way, the rules will be adopted later this month in an open FCC meeting as an Open Internet Order.” The FCC’s proposed rules fall along the lines of the openness principles adopted by the FCC back in 2005, and Genachowski says the proposal has already garnered broad support from many stakeholders in the net neutrality debate.

“This framework [..] would advance a set of core goals,” Genachowski said in a statement. “It would ensure that the Internet remains a powerful platform for innovation and job creation; it would empower consumers and entrepreneurs; it would protect free expression; it would increase certainty in the marketplace, and spur investment both at the edge and in the core of our broadband networks.”

The policy proposal includes a transparency requirement, so that network operators would be required to disclose how they manage their networks so consumers and “innovators” can make informed decisions about signing up for broadband access. The proposal would also enshrine a right to send and receive “lawful” Internet traffic and devices: Internet providers would be prohibited from blocking lawful content, applications, services, and devices. The proposed rules would also bar “unreasonable” discrimination in transmitting lawful network traffic.

However, the policy proposal also gives ground to network operators, granting them the ability to deal with traffic that harmful to the network or unwanted by users, and to address effects of network congestion. The policy is aimed at enabling providers to manage their networks, as well as provide incentive to build out broadband infrastructure.

Unlike a network neutrality proposal put forward earlier this year by Google and Verizon, the FCC’s policy proposal would extend transparency and a “basic” no-blocking rule to mobile broadband, noting that the FCC will be keeping a close eye on the mobile broadband market as it continues to develop and may take further steps to guard against anti-competitive or anti-consumer conduct. The proposed framework would give mobile operators more flexibility in managing their networks and dealing with bandwidth scarcity.

Significantly, the policy proposal would “not necessarily” re-categorize broadband as a Title II telecommunications service, meaning broadband operators may be exempt from rate regulations and facilities-sharing requirements applied to phone operators. The proposal would also enable broadband providers to create managed services separate from the open Internet—potentially for security systems, health care, and smart grid applications—so long as those services do not impinge on the public Internet. Similar proposal for allowing differentiated network services separate from the Internet drew rounds of criticism from public interest groups and consumer advocates when it surfaced in Google and Verizon’s policy proposal.

Genachowski indicates he is confident the FCC has a sound legal basis for its approach, and has the legal authority to enforce the framework if it is adopted. This is a key point, since a court decision of Comcast’s blocking of P2P file sharing traffic on its network effectively ruled the FCC did not have the authority to enforce its 2005 openness principles.

The FCC is facing a time crunch on its proposed rules. Net neutrality frameworks have run into opposition from Republican lawmakers concerned that net neutrality policies amount to burdensome regulation that stifles innovation and discourages providers from building out broadband infrastructure. And, beginning in January, the Republican party takes control of the House of Representatives.

Editors' Recommendations

Geoff Duncan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
9 best desktop computers of 2023: tested and reviewed
A top-down view of the Mac Mini.

There are several great options if you're searching for the best desktop computer, but Dell's XPS Desktop (8960) still takes the crown in 2023. It's highly flexible, decently priced, and comes with super powerful hardware. There are desktop PCs to pick from, though.

We've reviewed hundreds of desktop PCs from brands like Dell, Apple, Lenovo, and HP, but only a few truly stand out. These are the computers to look for when making your next upgrade. For our picks, we tried to balance price, performance, build quality, and our experience actually using the desktop. Make sure to read our explainer about how we review desktops to get an inside look at our evaluation process.

Read more
This new GPU connector may finally kill the melting 12VHPWR
A hand holding the RTX 4090 GPU.

The 12VHPWR graphics card connector has made a name for itself for all the wrong reasons, with the component frequently melting and causing the death of many a GPU. Now, graphics card manufacturers are apparently testing a replacement that could finally put an end to the sorry saga.

The new version, dubbed 12V-2x6, can reportedly deliver up to 660W of power to a graphics card -- 10% more than the 12VHPWR. Despite that, testing has apparently shown it to be much safer than its predecessor.

Read more
Best MacBook deals: Apple laptops starting at $159
A MacBook Pro M2 sits on a wooden table with a nice bokeh background.

If you're keen to find all the best Apple deals with an eye on awesome MacBook discounts, we're here to help. We've picked out some of the best MacBook deals going on right now and that includes some devices that cost just $159. That's for an older refurbished model but we also have the latest MacBook Pros and Airs listed below too. Basically, there's something for everyone here. Keep reading while we take you through the highlights when it comes to MacBook deals. Shopping on a shoestring budget? Perhaps check out our list of the best refurbished MacBook deals instead.
MacBook Air 11.6-inch (2015) -- from $159

Once the latest MacBook Air but now eight years old and still competent, the MacBook Air 11.6-inch (2015) is a great starting point for anyone new to macOS or who just needs something financially on par with a Chromebook. It's a refurbished model but it comes with a one-year warranty so there's peace of mind here. It won't run the latest macOS unfortunately, but its Intel Core i5 processor, 4GB of memory and 128GB of SSD storage helps you perform the basics. It still has all the style of a MacBook so we're thinking this could be a good entry point as your child's first MacBook or if you want a project.

Read more