Skip to main content

Appeals Court Guts FCC Authority on Net Neutrality

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Remember when Comcast took a major public relations blow—and drew sanctions from the Federal Communications Commission—for forging traffic that deliberately shut down P2P sharing applications like BitTorrent and Gnutella, ostensibly in the name of “network management?” Comcast has just struck a major blow back at the FCC: a federal appeals court has ruled (PDF) that the FCC does not have the authority to impose so-called “net neutrality” requirements on Internet providers.

Comcast’s appeal was based on the notion that the FCC’s Internet Policy statement—which specifies ISPs treat all traffic and applications equally—does not have the legal authority of an actual federal regulation because it is not tied to law(s) enacted by Congress.

“The Commission may exercise this ‘ancillary’ authority only if it demonstrates that its action—here barring Comcast from interfering with its customers’ use of peer-to-peer networking applications—is ‘reasonably ancillary to the […] effective performance of its statutorily mandated responsibilities,'” Judge David Tatel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit wrote in the court’s opinion.

The FCC’s recently unveiled national broadband plan relies on the agency’s authority to regulate the Internet and ISPs’ responsibilities.

The FCC has not yet indicated how it intends to pursue the matter. Options include appealing the Comcast victory and adopting the Internet Policy statement as formal regulations—however, that process would require action by Congress, and would be likely to become mired in political debate, potentially stalling the already under-the-gun national broadband plan.

Privacy advocates, consumer groups, and larger Internet businesses like Google have warned that lack of net neutrality requirements could rapidly lead to a fractured, multi-tiered Internet, where “preferred” traffic receives better service than others. Providers could potentially require companies like Google or Netflix to pay them for preferred service; alternatively, they could choose to block their customers’ services like Google or Netflix for any reason.

Editors' Recommendations

Geoff Duncan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
What is an RSS feed? Here’s why you should still use one
A person using a HP ENVY x360 2-in-1 15.6-inch Touch-Screen Laptop sitting on a bed.

With so much new content on the web added daily, it can be tough to keep up with what's happening online. People try several different ways, including visiting specific websites every day, doing Google searches, or relying on social media to keep them informed. One solution that sometimes gets overlooked is an old-school one: The RSS feed.

What is an RSS feed? It's a technology that has influenced many modern internet tools you're familiar with, and its streamlined, algorithm-free format could make it your next great tool for reading what you want online.
What is RSS?

Read more
Best laptop deals: Save on HP, Lenovo, Dell and Apple
Asus ROG Zephyrus M16 playing Cyberpunk 2077.

Buying a new laptop can be very daunting, especially with how saturated the market is with dozens of options from nearly a dozen brands and various configurations of each of those laptops. Even worse is trying to navigate the maze of available laptop deals across various retailers, and for those who don't want to do all that legwork, you're in luck! We've used our experience to collect the best deals in various categories to ensure you get the best bang for your buck. All you need to do is have a general sense of what specs or brand you want, and we'll likely have a deal for it listed below.

Best Laptop Deals

Read more
M2 MacBook Air vs. M1 MacBook Air: things have changed
A man holds the new Macbook Air (2022) in his hands.

The Apple MacBook Air M1 has been among our favorite MacBooks for some time now, and it's even held a place on our list of the best laptops overall. The new MacBook Air M2 is a significant redesign, bringing with it a new chassis and Apple's latest M2 processor.

Sometimes, it's easy to recommend the new model over the old one, especially when the new model brings significant improvements. The M2 MacBook Air qualifies, as it feels a lot more like a completely new model than a simple replacement of the old one. While Apple continues to sell the original M1 MacBook Air at a lower price, the M2 MacBook Air can often be had for only a little more money. That makes the choice between them a lot easier.
Specs
 

Read more