Skip to main content

Google’s new search layout melds paid ads with real search results

Google is always testing new tweaks to even their most successful products, but there’s one change to Google search rolling out to the public as we speak that may benefit the tech giant in the short term, but come back to bite them in the long run. The new layout changes the way Google presents paid search results, while also making it more difficult to differentiate between ad-supporting links and real search results.

To this point, Google search results were placed directly below paid URLs set against a yellow background. With the new layout, searches still yield the same set of paid ads, but instead of setting them apart with a colored background, paid ad links now feature a yellow “Ad” button next to each link. Similarly, when a search generates a sidebar of paid results, the links are distinguished with a single “Ads” button at the top of the list.

Recommended Videos

Whether this is intentional or not, Google has seemingly made it much easier for users to click on paid search results by mistake. Anyone who takes the time to read their results will clearly recognize which ads are paid and which are organic, but users scanning results quickly may not pick out the sponsored URLs as easily without their distinctive color-coating.

According to PCWorld, Google began publicly testing the paid search buttons late last year as part of larger refresh of their mobile layout, which also added a larger font and removed underlines for search results.

Even a relatively increase in paid clicks would generate a huge windfall for Google, but they may do so at the cost of their consumers’ trust if users feel they’re being tricked into engaging advertisers. Leo Dalakos, VP of Performance Media at digital marketing agency Perfomics, told PCWorld that he’s weary of how the change could affect Google’s reputation: “Does Google want to increase its click-through rates as much as possible? Yes.”

Whether this could come back to bite Google and result in a significant decrease in user trust and confidence remains to be seen.

Do you think people will have more trouble telling the difference between paid and organic search results when using Google? Let us know in the comments below.

Mike Epstein
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Michael is a New York-based tech and culture reporter, and a graduate of Northwestwern University’s Medill School of…
ChatGPT prototypes its next strike against Google Search: browsers
ChatGPT on a laptop

ChatGPT developer OpenAI may be one step closer to creating a third-party search tool that integrates the chatbot into other websites as primary feature. If the project comes to fruition, OpenAI could target Google as both a search engine and web browser.

A source told The Information the project is a search tool called NLWeb, Natural Language Web, and that it is currently in a prototype phase. OpenAI has showcased the prototype to several potential partners in travel, retail, real estate, and food industries, with Conde Nast, Redfin, Eventbrite, and Priceline being named by brand. The tool would enable ChatGPT search features onto the websites of these brands' products and services.

Read more
ChatGPT Search is here to battle both Google and Perplexity
The ChatGPT Search icon on the prompt window

ChatGPT is receiving its second new search feature of the week, the company announced on Thursday. Dubbed ChatGPT Search, this tool will deliver real-time data from the internet in response to your chat prompts.

ChatGPT Search appears to be both OpenAI's answer to Perplexity and a shot across Google's bow.

Read more
Ancient Mayan city discovered via page 16 of Google search results
A Google logo sign at the top of a building.

Proceeding to even the second page of Google search results is rare enough, but going all the way to page 16 and then selecting an entry that leads to the discovery of a huge Mayan city that was lost for centuries under a jungle canopy ... well, that’s really something.

“I was on something like page 16 of Google search and found a laser survey done by a Mexican organization for environmental monitoring,” Luke Auld-Thomas, a Ph.D. student at Tulane University in Louisiana, said in comments reported by the BBC.

Read more