Skip to main content

Microsoft Can Keep Selling Word While Appealing Patent Ruling

Microsoft WordLast month, a Texas judge handed down some $290 million in fines against Microsoft Corporation for infringing on patents held by Canadian company i4i related to custom XML documents—and in addition to the financial penalty, the judge ordered Microsoft stop selling infringing products—in this case Microsoft Word 2004 and 2007—and gave Microsoft 60 days to comply.

Microsoft immediately appealed the ruling and, surprising almost nobody, U.s. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has found Microsoft has met the requirements to be granted a stay on the injunction—in other words, the company can continue selling Microsoft Word while its appeal on the patent infringement case wends its way through the courts. The appeals court also granted an expedited review of the case, and will hear arguments on September 23.

The initial infringement ruling against Microsoft was unexpectedly harsh, with east Texas judge Leonard Davis ordering Microsoft to pay $40 million for willful infringement, $37 million in pre-judgement interest, $21,102 for every day until a final judgement was reached, and some $144,060 per day until a final judgement on damages was reached.

For its part, i4i isn’t some patent troll with no other business than trying to milk money off Microsoft: the company has been in business since 1993 and develops collaborate content management systems, with clients in the pharmaceutical industry.

Editors' Recommendations

Geoff Duncan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
How to convert a PDF to a Word document
Young Adult Laptop Lifestyle

PDFs are a great way to share documents because the format can be read by mostly anyone. It's generally used with digital manuals, sales receipts, manuscripts, and so on — documents that aren't meant for editing. Think of PDFs as digital printouts with pretty designs.

Read more
Microsoft is bringing ChatGPT to your browser, and you can test it out right now
Microsoft's redesigned Bing search engine.

Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella confirmed in a private briefing with the press that a ChatGPT-powered version of the Edge browser and Bing search engine is available now. The overhauled search and web browsing experience is designed for natural-language questions, replacing critical aspects of the browser with AI tools.

That might sound familiar. Google and other search engines have been leveraging AI for several years to compile search results, but Microsoft's take is different. It's "your AI copilot for the web," offering up new search, answer, chat, and create functions.

Read more
Microsoft continues its unabashed embrace of ChatGPT and AI
OpenAI and MIcrosoft logos appear over a computer generated background.

Microsoft's race to integrate ChatGPT into its products took some big steps forward today.

As per an announcement from Microsoft, OpenAI technology is officially coming to Teams Premium, while a new recent report suggests that a new version of ChatGPT, based on an updated GPT-4 model, might supercharge Bing search soon.

Read more