Smarter search: Why ‘semantic search’ will finally let Google understand you


The Wall Street Journal’s Amir Efrati has raised eyebrows with an article (subscription required) saying Google is working to stay ahead of its rivals in Internet search by introducing more so-called “semantic search” technology. The idea is the Google’s search box wouldn’t just be a place for users to type keywords or specifically-formed queries, but a box that had an actual understanding of many of the terms, names, verbs, and references people type in — and could apply that knowledge to users’ searches. In theory, semantic search should be able to return results that reflect a searcher’s intent, and in some cases improve Google’s ability to give an answer right away without referring users off to another site.

But wait — is this anything new? Doesn’t Google already put some answers right up front? And how could semantic search potentially help Google maintain its lead in the Internet search business?

What is semantic search?

In a nutshell, semantic has much more in common with Watson, the IBM supercomputing application that handily defeated humans at Jeopardy! than it does with the Find dialog in Microsoft Word.

Loosely speaking, the world of computerized searching breaks down into two types:

Literal search (sometimes called navigational search) looks for exact matches for some or all of the terms entered, and returns matching items — whether files, Web pages, products, or some other discrete unit of information. Literal search can be augmented with things like stem-matching, conjugates, and association that expand or restrict the search in useful ways — so searching for “fly” might also hit “flight.” Literal search is what we’re most familiar with today, in part because it’s the easiest for computers to perform.

Semantic search differs from literal search in two ways. First, semantic search tries to understand what a user is asking in a query by placing it in context through analysis of the query’s terms and language. This analysis is conducted against tightly pre-compiled pools of knowledge, potentially including knowledge about the user. Second, instead of returning a set of files, Web pages, products, or other items, semantic search tries to provide a direct answer to a question. If you ask a semantic search engine “When was Pluto discovered?” it might answer “Pluto was discovered on February 18, 1930 by Clyde Tombaugh*,” where a literal search engine would most likely return links to Web pages that contain the words “discovered” and “Pluto.”

It turns out literal search and semantic search are good for different tasks. Literal search is great when a user is looking for a specific thing, whether that be a file, Web page, document, product, album, or other discrete item. Semantic search, on the other hand, turns out to be more useful when a user is looking for specific information — like a date, number, time, place, or name.

Thanks in part to the proliferation of literal search technology in everything from word processors to Web search engines, we’re most accustomed to literal search. Most of us already know how to manipulate literal search to get us closer to what we want on the first try. However, according to Efrati’s WSJ article, Google believes semantic search technology could provide direct answers to between 10 and 20 percent of Web searches. According to Comscore, Google handled 11.7 billion searches in the United States alone in February 2012. With semantic search capabilities, more than 2.3 billion of those searches could have been answered directly, instead of sending people off to other Web pages and sites.

Doesn’t Google already do this?

If you’ve used Google Web search at all you’re probably thinking “But wait, Google already does this!” Type “current time in Tokyo” or “how tall is Mount Everest” and Google will put its best guess at a precise answer at the top of its search results. Google even cites sources for its response, and some of those sources will be in the classic “ten blue links” below the answer. (Google reports Mount Everest is 8,848 meters tall, by the way.)

To be fair, this is one of just many useful capabilities Google has built into its search bar: It’ll do (sophisticated) math, perform unit and currency conversions, and pull up things like flight information and local movie show times — no need to type out a complicated query. It can also tap into some public data sources. For instance, typing “population Mexico” into the search box will display data from the World Bank. The response today is 113,423,047 people.

However, Google’s efforts to provide direct answers to some types of questions falls down pretty quickly, because those features are largely implemented as special cases to Google’s literal search engine, rather than as a semantic search that tries to understand what the user wants. Type “how tall is mt everest” (note the spelling) into the search box, and Google doesn’t even attempt to provide an answer: Google search doesn’t know “mt” means “mount.” Similarly, if Google has determined your current location is not in Mexico (and, if Google doesn’t have your location, it’ll guess by your IP address and, no, you can’t opt out) searching for “population mexico city” might return some unexpected results. Surely Mexico City is home to more than 10,852 people, right?


Microsoft could split up search and Cortana in the next Windows 10 release

In the latest Insider preview build, Microsoft is exploring ways to split up Cortana and search on Windows 10. If Microsoft moves ahead with this change, we could see separate search and Cortana options in the Spring 2019 Update.

No more wild goose chase: ‘’ now leads to DuckDuckGo instead of Google

DuckDuckGo recently acquired a shorter domain name from fellow search engine competitor Google. As a result, longtime and new DuckDuckGo users can now access the privacy-focused search engine by going to

The best air fryer deals you can still snag before Christmas

Christmas is closing in on us fast, but you still have a little bit of time left for last-minute kitchen gifts. We've searched the depths of Amazon and Walmart to bring you the best air fryer deals going on right now.

The best 4K TV deals under $500 and over 50 inches

Big-screen TVs with high-resolution displays and 4K color have dropped so far in price that you can find highly rated 50 to 55-inch models under $500. We searched major retailers for the best deals on 4K UHD TVs.

Not just for Lightroom anymore, Loupedeck+ now works with Photoshop

Loupedeck+ can now help photographers edit in Photoshop too, thanks to physical controls for swapping tools, running actions, and more. The photo-editing console expanded to include Photoshop in the list of compatible editing programs.

Turn your Raspberry Pi into a Steam streaming hub with Valve’s Steam Link app

Valve's Steam Link app is now fully supported by Raspberry PI hardware, meaning that just about anyone with a few dollars to spare can build their own Steam streaming box in a matter of minutes.

Amazon takes $300 off Intel Core i7 Surface Pro 6 in latest sale

If you're looking for savings on the Surface Pro 6, Amazon is the place to shop. It currently is discounting the Intel Core i7 variant of Microsoft's latest 2-in-1 by $300, though no Type Cover is included.

Here's our head-to-head comparison of Pandora and Spotify

Which music streaming platform is best for you? We pit Spotify versus Pandora, two mighty streaming services with on-demand music and massive catalogs, comparing every facet of the two services to help you decide which is best.

Our favorite Chrome themes add some much-needed pizzazz to your boring browser

Sometimes you just want Chrome to show a little personality and ditch the grayscale for something a little more lively. Lucky for you, we've sorted through the Chrome Web Store to find best Chrome themes available.

Don't keep typing the same thing -- learn to copy and paste with these shortcuts!

Looking for useful Windows keyboard shortcuts? The most common are the cut, copy, paste and undo shortcuts compatible with all kinds of tasks. They can save you an awful lot of time if you learn how to use them.

Latest Facebook bug exposed up to 6.8 million users’ private photos

An API bug recently left an impact on Facebook users. Though the issue has since been fixed, some of the apps on the platform had a wrongful access to consumers photos for 12 days between September 13 and September 25. 

You can now get a Surface Laptop 2 for $800 at the Microsoft Store

Along with deals on other variants, starting configurations of Microsoft's Surface Laptop 2 are now going for $800 online at its retail store, cutting $200 from its usual $1,000 starting price. 

Need a monitor for professional photo-editing? These are the very best

Looking for the best monitor for photo editing? You'll need to factor in brightness, color accuracy, color gamut support and more. Fortunately, we've rounded up the best ones for you, to help you make an educated purchase.

HDR monitors are beginning to have an impact. Here are the best you can buy

HDR isn't the most common of PC monitor features and is often charged at a premium, but the list of available options is growing. These are the best HDR monitors you can buy right now.
1 of 2