Skip to main content

Utah’s proposed anti-doxxing law draws criticism

social-media_magicatwork_flickr
magicatwork/Flickr
As technology changes the way we interact with others around us, lawmakers are given the undesirable task of making sure that legislation can keep pace with the latest developments. A bill proposed in the Utah State House of Representatives earlier this week is one attempt to add legal consequences to the act of doxxing.

For the uninitiated, doxxing has come to refer to the practice of distributing personally identifiable information via the Internet, most often as a means of harassing or bullying the target. Perpetrators range from controversial activist group Anonymous to current Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump.

In a bill titled Cybercrime Amendments, Utah State Representative David Lifferth adds “distributing personal identifying information” to the forms of electronic communication that are punishable if executed with certain intent. These purposes are listed as “to annoy, alarm, intimidate, offend, abuse, threaten, harass, frighten, or disrupt the electronic communications of another.”

While action certainly needs to be taken, Lifferth’s H.B. 225 is being criticized as heavy-handed. Staff Attorney for the Electronic Frontier Foundation Nate Cardozo described this kind of legislature as “trendy” and the proposal itself as “extremely poorly worded and poorly thought-through” in an interview with Ars Technica.

Cardozo’s criticism stems from the fact that much could be interpreted as an act of doxxing, given the definition stated in Lifferth’s bill. Publishing any reference to someone’s name with the intent to annoy that individual would be considered an infraction of the proposed law.

Online harassment is not a problem that’s going to go away by itself, but it seems that this bill in particular has not been developed with the required intent. The end result of any such law would hopefully make it easier for all of us to engage with one another online, rather than having the potential to cut down on free speech like H.B. 225.

Editors' Recommendations

Brad Jones
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Brad is an English-born writer currently splitting his time between Edinburgh and Pennsylvania. You can find him on Twitter…
It’s time to stop believing these PC building myths
Hyte's Thicc Q60 all-in-one liquid cooler.

As far as hobbies go, PC hardware is neither the cheapest nor the easiest one to get into. That's precisely why you may often run into various misconceptions and myths.

These myths have been circulating for so long now that many accept them as a universal truth, even though they're anything but. Below, I'll walk you through some PC beliefs that have been debunked over and over, and, yet, are still prevalent.
Liquid cooling is high-maintenance (and scary)

Read more
AMD’s next-gen CPUs are much closer than we thought
AMD Ryzen 7 7800X3D held between fingertips.

We already knew that AMD would launch its Zen 5 CPUs this year, but recent motherboard updates hint that a release is imminent. Both MSI and Asus have released updates for their 600-series motherboards that explicitly add support for "next-generation AMD Ryzen processors," setting the stage for AMD's next-gen CPUs.

This saga started a few days ago when hardware leaker 9550pro spotted an MSI BIOS update, which they shared on X (formerly Twitter). Since then, Asus has followed suit with BIOS updates of its own featuring a new AMD Generic Encapsulated Software Architecture (AGESA) -- the firmware responsible for starting the CPU -- that brings support for next-gen CPUs (spotted by VideoCardz).

Read more
AMD Zen 5: Everything we know about AMD’s next-gen CPUs
The AMD Ryzen 5 8600G APU installed in a motherboard.

AMD Zen 5 is the next-generation Ryzen CPU architecture for Team Red and is slated for a launch sometime in 2024. We've been hearing tantalizing rumors for a while now and promises of big leaps in performance. In short, Zen 5 could be very exciting indeed.

We don't have all the details, but what we're hearing is very promising. Here's what we know about Zen 5 so far.
Zen 5 release date and availability
AMD confirmed in January 2024 that it was on track to launch Zen 5 sometime in the "second half of the year." Considering the launch of Zen 4 was in September 2022, we would expect to see Zen 5 desktop processors debut around the same timeframe, possibly with an announcement in the summer at Computex.

Read more