Skip to main content

Baldur’s Gate 3’s character creation limits stifle its RPG potential

Larian Studios has done something remarkable with Baldur’s Gate 3. This is the studio’s third game (in a row, I might add!) that has perfectly married the rules and systems of a tabletop RPG into the language of video games. Many developers have done this to varying degrees of success, but Larian fundamentally understands what makes a pen and paper RPG enjoyable and how to properly show that off in the digital world.

I have been playing Dungeons and Dragons for over 15 years now and video games for even longer than that, and I’m always on the hunt for games that come close to that spark — that fire you can find at a table surrounded by your friends and stale chips. Freedom is an integral mechanic of pen and paper RPGs and, for the most part, Larian gives players so many choices and options.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

However, there is still one aspect of pen and paper RPGs that Larian Studios hasn’t nailed down. Baldur’s Gate 3 does not have an option for players to jump into an ongoing campaign with their own custom character. This forces newcomers to play as characters that they have no connection to and disincentives them from joining their friends in an existing campaign.

Late to the party

You can have a rotating cast of players in Baldur’s Gate 3, however custom characters can only be introduced at the start of the game. Anyone joining afterward must either play as one of the premade NPC characters that Larian Studios have provided or play as someone else’s character.

That doesn’t sit right with me as a tabletop player. When playing RPGs both on and off the computer, it’s vital that a player can immerse themself into a character. That allows players to invest in the personal story of your character, as well as the progression of spells, skills, and gear. That character growth is what makes RPGs incredibly enjoyable.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

This is all still technically possible in Baldur’s Gate 3 for four players who all start the campaign at the same time, but that’s not always the case. In my 15 years of playing D&D, I have been a dungeon master for 12 of them. Knowing feats and enemy stats isn’t as difficult as managing the schedules of disparate players.

That’s always a challenge in both tabletop games and virtual ones. Be it because of life getting in the way or the fact that they no longer stand cheeseballs staining up their Player’s Handbook, gathering a party up is incredibly daunting and it’s only inevitable that one or two players will drop out. It doesn’t matter why; what does matter is that there is now a hole in the group that must be filled.

For tabletop or pen-and-paper RPGs, there’s a simple solution: Just invite more people. Have a quick session with them to create their character, give them some items, a brief summary of the plot, and they are set to go with a character that they want to play as.

That’s not possible in Baldur’s Gate 3 currently. New players can’t jump into an ongoing campaign with a character that they created and that they want to play as. All that is left are hand-me-downs whose identities cannot be divorced from their creators.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

This puts someone like me in an awkward position. How can I talk about a game that I thoroughly love, but cannot properly invite my friends to play with? I have plenty of friends who will not jump into games like Baldur’s Gate 3 alone, but absolutely would if we did it together. Do I start a new campaign if they want to create their own character? Are they forced to play as a character they have no investment in? I just don’t understand why there isn’t a system in place to encourage more people to play together.

The game could benefit from an inn, stables, or even something like Bill’s PC from Pokémon that gives players an option to create custom characters during the campaign. Perhaps it could be relegated to a menu so Larian Studios doesn’t have to worry about having the campsite filled with pink-haired druids and balding warlocks. Their level can be whatever the level the host’s character is. For the question of gear: There are shops, there are dungeons, and there are rogues who are itching to steal. This seems like a problem that fixes itself.

I am a huge fan of games like Baldur’s Gate 3. I want more people to play games like it with me. But it’s too hard to encourage people to play if they cannot create their own character midway through a game. RPGs are an excellent medium to express yourself in, so why should we punish players and restrict them from that expression just because they are late to the party?

Editors' Recommendations

Andrew Zucosky
Andrew has been playing video games since he was a small boy, and he finally got good at them like a week ago. He has been in…
Baldur’s Gate 3 isn’t on Nintendo Switch, but these 7 great CRPGs are
Karlach in Baldur's Gate 3.

Baldur's Gate 3 has taken the video game industry by storm over the last week, even though it's only available on PC. While it will launch for PlayStation 5 on September 6 and is likely to get an Xbox launch eventually, there's one platform that it doesn't look like Baldur's Gate 3 will come to: the Nintendo Switch. Nintendo's hybrid system is a great home to many more traditional RPGs, but even compared to Xbox, the choices for solid CRPGs like Baldur's Gate 3 are slim on Nintendo Switch.
Still, they aren't nonexistent, so if you don't own any other platform that will eventually be able to play Baldur's Gate 3, you do have some options. In particular, the following six games (and one that's coming out soon) are clearly inspired by tabletop and classic CRPGs, and players looking for a Nintendo Switch experience similar to Baldur's Gate 3 should them try out. 
Baldur's Gate and Baldur's Gate II: Enhanced Editions

While Baldur's Gate 3 isn't on Nintendo Switch, its predecessors are. There are actually six remastered Dungeons & Dragons CRPGs on Switch, but I obviously had to shout out the original two Baldur's Gate games. These titles, which were originally developed by BioWare and remastered by Beamdog, set the standards that most Western-developed RPGs have followed in the decades since. The first Baldur's Gate proved that video games could have deeper stories with more complex characters than were typically seen and have gameplay that was more open-ended and reactive to players in its design.
Its sequel, Baldur's Gate II: Shadows of Amn is considered to be even better by some as it builds upon the very solid foundation that its predecessor established. While somewhat dated compared to some slicker modern RPGs, both of these games still hold up and are worth playing if you want to see the birthplace of many foundational RPG ideas. Baldur's Gate and Baldur's Gate II: Enhanced Editions can be bought for $50 on Nintendo Switch, and it includes both game and all of their DLC (plus some new content), along with the visually improved remaster treatment you'd expect. Instead of playing Baldur's Gate 3, you can appreciate these classics on Nintendo Switch.
Divinity: Original Sin 2 - Definitive Edition

Read more
Baldur’s Gate 3 makes gaming’s most complex genre more player-friendly than ever
A party of four adventures walking through a mushroom forest in the Underdark

With Baldur’s Gate 3 now out, I can't help but feel a surge of excitement. A game that I have been playing, --and loving -- since its early access back in 2020 is finally in the hands of the general public. Its reception is overwhelmingly positive and it is truly great to see people sink their teeth into such a fascinating and complex game. That is, if they aren't too intimated to start.

Computer role-playing games (CRPGs) are notorious for being a complicated and daunting genre, especially one like this that draws so heavily on Dungeons & Dragons rule sets. I couldn't blame anyone unfamiliar with the genre who just feels too intimidated by its scope. That being said, don't let Baldur’s Gate 3 scare you off; this is the best introduction to CRPGs ever made.
Start small, start slow
The CRPG genre has a bad reputation for being unwieldy for new players thanks to all of the intricate layers of systems that tend to populate them. You usually have to deal with spells, weapon attacks, environmental stats, verticality, and so much more. It can give a new player stage fright as soon as they are given control of their character. Baldur’s Gate 3, on the other hand, does an excellent job of onboarding new players to the genre with its streamlined rules and systems.

Read more
Baldur’s Gate 3 spit in the face of every modern gaming trend. And it paid off
A wizard charges a spell to hit a minataur.

When you picture a “bankable video game,” what comes to mind? That answer will probably elicit some wildly different answers depending on who you are.

As budgets have grown bigger and projects have become more financially risky, executives have struggled to turn video games into a reliable science. We’ve seen companies like Blizzard completely morph into something unrecognizable as they try to find new monetization streams. Square Enix has strayed away from its turn-based RPG roots in order to chase Sony’s more action-focused, blockbuster vision -- a style that Sony itself is taking a step back from as it explores the unpredictable world of live service games.

Read more