Skip to main content

It’s time we admit to, and accept, vinyl’s dirty secret

Three vinyl records below an Audio Technica turntable on a wooden table.
John Higgins / Digital Trends

Long before the recent vinyl renaissance, audiophiles have long espoused the analog benefits of vinyl records as being vastly superior to digital. The argument often includes claims of vinyl sounding “warmer,” or that digital audio is built on discrete steps with a staircase-shaped waveform that leaves out the audio information that a smooth, continuous analog signal retains (this is, by the way, a fallacy that’s been perpetuated for decades).

Because analog sound reproduction — and the analog production chain — is a continuous signal, audiophiles contend that it’s a more accurate representation of the original recording or performance. Except in 2025 (and for the past 40 years), apart from perhaps a few rare instances, there’s no such thing as a purely analog production chain. At some point, even if you’re listening to a vinyl record, that audio signal was digital.

Recommended Videos

Unsurprisingly, there are many steps that go into the production of a recording. There’s obviously the actual singing and playing of the instruments, the addition of any processing and effects during (or after) recording, the media those master tracks are put or saved on, mixing, mastering, and the pressing of the vinyl (and other smaller steps along the way). After the wider introduction of digital audio technology back in the 70s and 80s, it began to work its way in to the production process — either for experimentation to determine what it could do, or to open creative opportunities, or to make the process easier, faster, and cheaper to accomplish.

The dynamic range capability of digital recording over analog also made it a better way to capture orchestral sounds, which require a much wider dynamic range (the difference between the quietest and loudest sound) than pop, rock, or jazz recordings to properly capture a performance.

A vinyl collection shelf with receiver and turntable.
Derek Malcolm / Digital Trends

Once we got to the 1990s and the proliferation of digital audio workstations (DAWs) like Pro Tools, Cakewalk, Digital Performer, and Cubase, digital had become near impossible to avoid. Analog methods, while still taught to new students for the historical perspective, weren’t as much a part of the workflow anymore. (As an audio production student in the mid to late 90s, mine was one of the last class years to cut and splice magnetic tape.)

The non-destructive ability to try different edits quickly proved too appealing to ignore. If Being for the Benefit of Mr. Kite was produced in 1997 instead of 1967 would we have the same psychedelic carnival sojourn comprised of randomly spliced together pieces of an organ recording? Perhaps not. But I digress.

The ability to create a fully analog recording in 2025 is exceedingly difficult and expensive. Analog recording decks require specialized maintenance, and the tape used for master recordings is vastly more expensive than recording to a hard drive (not to mention the degradation of magnetic tape that’s inevitable over time). Unless expressly put together to avoid all digital technology, a modern recording studio will include a DAW, a console that includes digital elements, digital instruments, digital effects modules, and digital controllers.

Mixing is done in the digital realm. Mastering is done in the digital realm. Even reissues and remasters of classic recordings that were originally fully analog are mixed and mastered from masters that were transferred to digital, likely years ago. It’s unavoidable. And really, with digital technology where it is, there’s no reason to even try to avoid it. Except for those who tout the superiority of analog over digital.

Does digital in vinyl matter?

When it comes down to it, any digital addition to the production chain should be audibly transparent — and if it isn’t, there’s something wrong with the equipment, not the medium. Just a few years ago, there was a controversy with MoFi (Mobile Fidelity Sound Lab) where it came out that DSD (Direct Stream Digital) files were used for its All Analog vinyl records, resulting in a $25 million settlement. But was anyone able to audibly identify that in the more than a decade before it came to light?

I’m not here to yuck anyone’s yum, especially since I enjoy the ritual of listening to my favorite vinyl recordings as well. But that’s just it. I appreciate the ritual. Holding the record sleeve, admiring the art and design, sliding the LP out, carefully flipping it in my hands to select the side I want before placing it on my turntable and dropping the needle, it all satiates a need for appreciation.

Appreciation of the recording artists. Appreciation of the engineers, mixers, and technicians involved. Appreciation of the effort it takes to create the recording — of which I’m intimately aware.

But more importantly, an appreciation of the art.

Audio Technica AT-LP120-USB turntable, for digitizing vinyl.
Derek Malcolm / Digital Trends

The vast majority of times I put on a record — and this goes back to my teenage years — it’s to experience the art of the album. The craftsmanship of The Wall, the emotional gut-punch of Blackstar, the beauty of Brahms second piano concerto, or the sonic fabric weaved by the John Coltrane Quartet. If I sit down to listen to a record, I’m usually there for the whole thing.

But am I (or are you) missing some extra magic because the Led Zeppelin III remaster had analog-to-digital conversion at some point in the chain? I don’t think so. The magic of the music is there no matter the medium. And the ritual of vinyl so many of us enjoy isn’t affected by 1s and 0s.

Topics
John Higgins
John Higgins is the Senior Editor of A/V at Digital Trends, leading the team in coverage of all manner of audio and video.
Sonos troubles continue as it lays off 200 employees
A Sonos Era 100 speaker next to an iPhone showing AirPlay speaker options.

Just a day after the next potential Sonos project was leaked -- a new streaming box -- more hard news has hit the company. In a call with employees, followed up by a post on the Sonos site titled "Team Update: Changes to the Way We Operate," interim CEO Tom Conrad announced a restructuring to the company. The result is layoffs of about 200 people. According to Sonos employment numbers from 2024, this accounts for about 12% of the company.

In the published statement, Conrad repeated what was stated in a company call just before. "One thing I’ve observed first hand is that we’ve become mired in too many layers that have made collaboration and decision-making harder than it needs to be. So across the company today we are reorganizing into flatter, smaller, and more focused teams," he said. "Most significantly, we are reorganizing our Product organization into functional groups for Hardware, Software, Design, Quality and Operations, and away from dedicated business units devoted to individual product categories."

Read more
JBL’s 100W portable Bluetooth has a nice discount today
The JBL PartyBox Encore 2.

The Super Bowl is only a few days away now, which means we can expect to see plenty of last-minute sales on TVs, soundbars, and other home theater gear. But if you want to treat your Super Bowl party guests to an evening of immersive audio they’ll never forget, you’ll want to have a solid Bluetooth speaker lying around. Fortunately, we came across a great sale while vetting through Bluetooth speaker deals:

For a limited time, when you purchase the JBL Partybox Encore Essential through Amazon, Best Buy, Walmart, and a handful of other retailers, you’ll only pay $250. The full MSRP on this model is $300.

Read more
This 85-inch Samsung QLED TV is $2,250 off — perfect for Super Bowl LIX
The Samsung 55-inch QNX1D Neo QLED on a white background.

If you've got friends and family coming over to watch Super Bowl LIX, you've still got time to purchase an upgrade for your home theater setup. You can make a big splash with the 85-inch Samsung QNX1D Neo QLED 4K TV, which is available with an attention-catching $2,250 discount from Samsung's TV deals that slashes its price from $4,000 all the way down to $1,750. You won't always get the chance to buy this display for less than half-price, so what are you waiting for? Proceed with the transaction right now to make sure that you get it in time for the big game.

Why you should buy the 85-inch Samsung QNX1D Neo QLED 4K TV
The Samsung QNX1D Neo QLED 4K TV, which is also known as the Samsung QN85D Neo QLED 4K TV, offers bright and accurate colors with its QLED TV technology, sharp details with 4K Ultra HD resolution on its 85-inch screen, smooth action with Motion Xcelerator Turbo 120Hz, and 3D surround sound with Dolby Atmos. With these features, it will be like you're watching Super Bowl LIX at Caesars Superdome in New Orleans yourself. Experience every rush, pass, and touchdown as if you're in the stands with the Samsung QNX1D Neo QLED 4K TV.

Read more