Skip to main content

Verizon to Netflix: Slow video streams are your fault [Update: Verizon slips again in June]

The toxic public debate between Netflix and Verizon over who’s to blame for the slow streaming video Verizon’s customers endure on its networks is starting to get a little ridiculous. And the worst part is, we still don’t know who’s lying and who’s telling the truth. Increasingly, it’s beginning to appear that on either side of the equation, it’s a mix of both. The latest in the he-said/she-said saga between the quarreling companies comes from a blog post Verizon published on Thursday, which claims Netflix is the sole cause of Verizon’s streaming woes. But that’s really just the tip of the tale.

Updated 7/14/2014: Netflix released its Speed Index Report for June today, which once again showed Verizon’s FiOS service slipping in the rankings, down another two spots from May. The latest report puts Verizon’s flagship service at a dismal 12th place in the top 16 ranked ISPs, down 17 percent from 1.9 Mbps in May to 1.59 Mbps in June. The news comes just a few days after Verizon’s condemnation, and adds more heat to the broiling debate between the two companies.

Related Videos

Verizon points the finger

In the blog post, Verizon’s vice president of federal regulatory affairs, David Young, claims that the telecom giant recently completed a review spawned by a letter from a Verizon customer in Los Angeles, who complained that Verizon was throttling his Netflix streams.

Channeling John McCain’s “Joe the plumber” monologue, Young claims this single letter spawned a full review of the customer’s network connection, finding “no congestion anywhere within the Verizon network.” Further, Young claims that its review found “congestion at the interconnection link…used by the transit providers chosen by Netflix to deliver video traffic to Verizon’s network.” In other words, Verizon is claiming quantifiable proof that Netflix is to blame by not keeping up with its transit duties when it comes to supplying video streams to ISPs, using insufficient third-party transit.

Young goes on to argue that a deliberate choice was made by Netflix to deliver its downstream traffic through insufficient means, which are unable to handle the service’s massive traffic streams, which now amount to over 1/3 of all downstream traffic in North America during peak hours.

“For whatever reason (perhaps to cut costs and improve its profitability), Netflix did not make arrangements to deliver this massive amount of traffic through connections that can handle it,” Young writes. “Instead, Netflix chose to attempt to deliver that traffic to Verizon through a few third-party transit providers with limited capacity over connections specifically to be used only for balanced traffic flows. Netflix knew better.”

Indeed, Netflix did know better.

Open Connect

Young’s tack is an interesting one here, considering that Netflix created its own content delivery system, Open Connect, long ago to remedy streaming issues, which Verizon refused to use. Open Connect is essentially a direct connection to Netflix servers that is designed to circumvent the same kinds of third-party transit providers for which Young condemns Netflix for using. Other ISPs who do subscribe to Open Connect, such as Cablevision, rank at the top of the Netflix Speed Index charts.

Still, on the other side of the coin, a recent report from Light Reading claims that Netflix may not be the white knight it paints itself to be. The report outlines claims from Peter Sevcik, an engineer with “decades of Internet experience” who says that the so-called “last mile,” the point at which traffic connects to ISPs, can’t be to blame for streaming issues. Sevcik claims Netflix streaming only takes about 2 Mbps in the last mile, and most ISPs are delivering much more bandwidth than that.

The report seems to support Verizon’s claims that Netflix’s third-party delivery system is simply too congested, and further, that Netflix could purchase more transit to alleviate the issue if it so desired. But Netflix wants to stop giving its money to third-party transit systems, and instead build out its Open Connect system. 

Deal? What deal?

But what about Netflix and Verizon’s deal for faster connection? Not long ago, the two companies made a very public, and very controversial pay-for-speed deal, which was designed to allay the very streaming issues in question. The deal also helped feed the flames of today’s debates about network neutrality, as flocks of consumer advocates argue that such deals could lead to an unfair class system online that favors the rich and powerful.

However, neutrality issues aside, not long after the deal, Verizon began to dip in the speed rankings (see Index chart again), instead of improve. The issue spurred Netflix to begin posting public messages for Verizon customers experiencing buffer issues that read “The Verizon network is crowded right now.” That message did not make Verizon happy and, in fact, sparked a cease and desist order from Verizon’s legal team, as well as general public sparring that helped lead to Thursday’s blog post, and the continued back-and-forth spat.

Regardless of who you believe, we have no doubt there is much more to the story than what’s available to us, the confounded public. In any case, Netflix will almost assuredly respond soon, so we’ll keep you abreast of the situation as it develops. Your move, Mr. Hastings.

Editors' Recommendations

Amazon Prime Video’s Thursday Night Football stream bad for some, again
Dolphins-Bengals on Thursday Night Football.

Three weeks of Thursday Night Football on Amazon Prime Video, and a third week of streaming problems, apparently. The September 29 game, which had the Miami Dolphins at the Cincinnati Bengals, was the third straight to experience any number of problems with the stream itself, according to numerous reports online.

This season is the first in which Amazon is producing the Thursday night broadcast from start to finish and not just distributing it. And just like in Weeks 2 and 3 of the NFL season, the distribution is what had issues. The Prime Video stream would go from an excellent quality to something we can only call "substandard-definition." Everything dropped to a lower resolution, from the game itself to the on-screen graphics and even some of the advertising. And just like in previous weeks, the issues would come and go.

Read more
Thursday Night Football stream struggles continue for Prime Video
amazon prime video thursday night football streaming issues week 3 steelers

Amazon Prime Video execs said this week they were "very hopeful" that Thursday Night Football streaming issues were "going to be less and less a thing." Looks like we'll all have to give it another go for Week 4.

The September 22 game between AFC North rivals Pittsburgh and Cleveland was peppered with continued streaming issues, where the resolution would drop out and pixelate — look bad, in other words — before returning back to normal. Then it would be fine for a while before dropping out again. And the problem wasn't just limited to the game broadcast — ads would look bad, too, which was at least a little ironic given the sheer number of spots for Amazon Web Services.

Read more
The ‘streaming wars’ aren’t what you think
streaming wars not what you think services

More people "streamed" television in July 2022 than watched on traditional cable TV, according to Nielsen. That's a big deal. Because it means streaming no longer is the future — it's the present.

And I suppose that matters. The question is to whom. Not so much me.

Read more